What this is
- Klotho is a protein linked to antiaging effects and is expressed in various tissues, including the kidneys and brain.
- Deficiency in Klotho leads to accelerated aging and associated diseases, while its overexpression can extend lifespan.
- This review explores Klotho's mechanisms in mitigating the twelve hallmarks of aging, including inflammation and cellular senescence.
Essence
- Klotho protein counters multiple aging hallmarks, including inflammation and cellular senescence, potentially extending lifespan and reducing age-related diseases.
Key takeaways
- Klotho mitigates chronic inflammation, which is a major contributor to aging and age-related diseases. By inhibiting pathways like NF-κB and the NLRP3 inflammasome, Klotho reduces the inflammatory response.
- Klotho protects against cellular senescence and promotes mitochondrial function, which are critical for maintaining cellular health and longevity. Its role in enhancing these functions could be pivotal in combating aging.
- Klotho's anti-fibrotic properties prevent organ fibrosis, a common issue in aging that can lead to organ failure. This action is mainly through the inhibition of TGF-β and Wnt signaling pathways.
Caveats
- The exact mechanisms by which Klotho exerts its effects are not fully understood, and many findings are based on preclinical studies rather than clinical trials.
- Klotho levels can be influenced by various factors, including diet and exercise, complicating the assessment of its therapeutic potential.
Definitions
- inflammaging: Chronic low-grade inflammation associated with aging that exacerbates age-related diseases.
- sarcopenia: Loss of muscle mass and strength that occurs with aging and various chronic diseases.
AI simplified
1. Introduction
Aging is an inevitable fact of life. It affects all organs and tissues, leading to impaired function, major debilitating diseases and death. Aging can be slowed by lifestyle changes such as exercise and diet. It is accelerated by many well-known negative factors. This includes smoking, obesity, hyperlipidemia, hypertension, chronic infectious diseases, anti-cancer drugs, radiation and exposure to environmental toxins. In diabetic subjects, high or poorly controlled glucose levels markedly accelerate aging. Similarly, renal disease and associated hyperphosphatemia (phosphatopathy) injure cells and accelerate aging [1].
α-Klotho (denoted here Klotho or KL) is an antiaging agent that is expressed in the kidneys, brain, endocrine organs (e.g., pancreatic β cells, parathyroid glands), blood vessels, skin, and other tissues [2]. It is also expressed by peripheral blood cells. Klotho is an obligate coreceptor for fibroblast growth factor 23 (FGF23), an endocrine FGF (eFGF) produced in bone, but it has several other functions, as reviewed by [3]. Klotho-deficient hypomorphic (KLkl/kl) or null (KL-/-) mice exhibit rapid aging. This syndrome includes stunted growth, hyperphosphatemia, hypercalcemia, cardiac disease, vascular disease (especially calcification), osteopenia, emphysema, sarcopenia, cognitive deficits, multi-organ atrophy and a short lifespan [4,5]. In contrast, overexpression of Klotho in transgenic mice [6], or induced by gene transfer [7], mitigates several features of aging, and increases lifespan by as much as 20 to 30%. There is a membrane-bound form; as well as a soluble form (s-Klotho) found in the blood and the CSF. In humans, s-Klotho declines with age and in several chronic diseases. Furthermore, low Klotho levels are associated with an increase in mortality. In this review, we focus primarily on the mechanisms by which Klotho delays aging.
2. Theories of Aging
There are many theories of aging, but the underlying molecular and cellular mechanisms are still not well defined. Different species age at different rates, suggesting the existence of a poorly understood biological clock [8]. We do not see 80-year old cats or dogs, but many humans surpass that age. The Greenland shark lives hundreds of years. Diverging lifespans (the time from birth to death) most likely represent species evolution in response to the environment, predators, and the availability of food. In order for a species to survive, it has to reproduce at a rate sufficient to match or exceed the death rate. Animals such as mice and rabbits have a short lifespan, but reproduce at a very fast rate. Humans live much longer and reproduce relatively slowly.
Humans are exceedingly complex multi-cellular organisms. Scientists are very far from elucidating all the molecular, cellular and whole organ aspects. To complicate matters, aging affects practically all cells and organs. Different organs can age at a different rate and in different ways. Some connective tissue changes appear irreversible. In view of the biologic complexity, it is not surprising there is no generally accepted theory of aging. Instead, to address this issue, researchers have described a number of hallmarks of aging [9]. There are currently twelve hallmarks, but this could increase. These hallmarks are mostly based on reductionist studies performed in various species (yeast, nematodes, insects and mice), and to a much lesser extent in humans.
Hallmarks of Aging
These are the twelve hallmarks, as described by Lopez-Otin et al. []. 9
Genomic instability/DNA alterations;
Telomere attrition;
Epigenetic alterations;
Loss of proteostasis;
Deregulated nutrient sensing;
Mitochondrial dysfunction;
Cellular senescence;
Stem cell exhaustion;
Altered intercellular communication;
Disabled macroautophagy;
Dysbiosis/altered microbiome;
Chronic inflammation.
As outlined in this manuscript, Klotho mitigates several of these hallmarks (). The description of aging hallmarks has been very useful for research, but it has limitations. Aging and the specific causes of death differ markedly between species. The relative importance of each hallmark is not well defined. They are based on important general concepts, but do not specifically address diseases. For example, cell death and the importance of various pathologies are not part of this scheme. Klotho ameliorates several age-related factors and pathologies (). However, in many of these cases the actual mode of action of Klotho has not been established. Figure 1 Figure 2
Autopsy studies in human populations provide important information. In order to age, an individual has to survive (obviously). A single organ failure frequently leads to death, regardless of the health of the other organs. For example, a person who appears to be in perfect health can die suddenly from a short thrombotic obstruction of a 3 or 4 mm diameter coronary artery. A similar occlusion of the middle cerebral artery can cause a massive fatal stroke. Uncontrolled type 2 diabetes potentially leads to fatal outcomes. These disease conditions are not generally considered “aging,” but occur at a much higher frequency with age. In effect, people do not die from old age, but rather from diseases that are much more common in the elderly.
Pathologies such as atherosclerosis, thrombosis, infarction, cancer, diabetes, fibrosis, emphysema, end-stage renal failure, neurogenerative diseases, autoimmune diseases, chronic inflammatory diseases, infections (deficient immunity), etc., all reduce life expectancy. These conditions are generally multi-factorial and complex. By far, in industrialized countries, death is due to either vascular disease (especially myocardial infarcts and strokes) or cancer in its many forms. Consequently, therapies or lifestyle changes that reduce vascular disease and cancer will have a major impact. Chronic lung diseases, Alzheimer’s disease and diabetes are also common causes of morbidity and mortality. Remarkably, numerous preclinical studies have shown that Klotho has protective effects against most of these major diseases.
3. Overview of Antiaging Activities of Klotho
As mentioned previously, Klotho action mitigates several hallmarks of aging (Figure 1), and ameliorates numerous age-related pathologies (Figure 2). It is beyond the scope of this manuscript to cover all these aspects in detail. However, concerning the pathobiology of Klotho, there have been a number of relevant reviews published by others and us [3,5,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17]. Here, we list the Klotho activities that appear most relevant to aging, whether or not they are linked to the 12 hallmarks. These findings were mostly obtained from preclinical work, but they are in accord with available clinical findings. This is a brief overview of these findings, and several of these features are discussed in subsequent sections of the manuscript.
4. Molecular Features
The molecular aspects of Klotho and its function as a coreceptor for FGF23 have been extensively studied, as reported by several researchers [5,10,52,53,54,55,56,57,58,59,60,61,62,63]. Klotho is expressed on the membrane as a single-pass protein, with a very short cytoplasmic segment (10 aa). In humans it has 1012 aa (130 kD). It has two extracellular domains of similar size—denoted KL1 and KL2. A soluble form of Klotho (s-Klotho) is produced by shedding. This soluble form is also termed processed Klotho (p-KL) by some authors [59]. It is generated by the cleaving action of extracellular proteases, principally ADAM10 and ADAM17 (α-secretases) [58,60]. The released KL1/KL2 segment appears to be the main (and perhaps only) circulating form of Klotho. This is consistent, for example, with the depletion of circulating Klotho observed in mice treated with secretase inhibitors.
However, a smaller form generated by alternative splicing has been described. It encodes KL1 and an additional C-terminal tail of 14 amino acids (but not KL2) [59]. It is termed secreted Klotho (sometimes confusingly abbreviated s-KL). Its existence has been questioned by some authors [61]. These researchers reported that the alternative Klotho mRNA (putative secreted Klotho) has premature termination codons that mark it for degradation by nonsense-mediated RNA decay (NMD). They could not identify production of the protein in vitro. To our knowledge there has been no other publication about Klotho NMD. Interestingly, unlike mice and humans, rats are devoid of this alternative splice variant. In any event, the secreted form of Klotho can be produced by gene therapy vectors, which presumably carry only the coding sequence (no RNA splicing) [7,59]. This allows selective expression of the secreted KL1 domain in vivo, and this has been linked to increased longevity and health in mice [7].
Crystal structure analysis demonstrated that Klotho binds to FGF receptors to produce a high affinity receptor for FGF23 [53]. In the absence of Klotho, FGF23 has low affinity for FGFRs. Klotho has affinity for FGFRs 1c, 3c and 4 [53,62], although FGFR1c appears to be employed the most often. Klotho attaches to FGFR1c by an extension of its KL2 domain. FGF23 binds into a groove formed by components of KL1, KL2 and the FGFR [53,63]. Thus, KL2 is required for receptor assembly and FGF23 binding. The KL1 domain also contributes to FGF23 binding, but does not interact directly to FGFRs.
Importantly, KL1 (with or without KL2) performs many Klotho functions that appear FGF23-independent. This includes blockade of TGF-β, Wnt ligands, insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF-1) and other mediators. For example, a KL1 domain construct exerted anti-cancer activity, but did not promote FGF23 signaling [64]. Related to this issue, Roig-Soriano et al. [59] compared in vivo gene transfer-based treatment with processed Klotho (KL1/KL2 segment) versus secreted Klotho (KL1 domain only). The processed Klotho differed markedly in that it increased FGF23 production in bone, and altered bone microstructure. It also perturbed phosphate and calcium homeostasis. The secreted Klotho did not have these effects. This is consistent with soluble KL1/KL2 acting as a FGF23 coreceptor, although this question was not examined.
In accord with in vitro and in vivo studies, s-Klotho (soluble KL1/KL2) can attach to FGFRs, and function as a coreceptor for FGF23 [53,63,65,66]. This is supported by the finding that s-Klotho protein injection into Klotho hypomorphic mice increased urinary phosphate excretion [67]. In wild-type mice, s-Klotho similarly increased phosphate excretion and lowered serum phosphate [63]. In vitro, s-Klotho enhanced FGF23-induced signaling in Klotho-negative HEK293 cells [53]. Co-stimulation with soluble Klotho appears weaker than with membrane Klotho. Of note, free FGF23 can also bind directly to free s-Klotho (KL1/KL2) at relatively high affinity [56,57,68]. Presumably, the FGF23/s-Klotho soluble complex can then attach to membrane-bound FGFRs and induce signaling. However, the extent to which s-Klotho promotes FGF23 signaling under ordinary physiological conditions remains unclear.
5. Renal Physiology
Klotho physiology in the kidney is the area that has been the best studied and characterized [5,54,55,69,70,71]. Upon binding of both Klotho and FGF23, the activated FGFR signals through multiple pathways, notably PI3K/Akt, Ras/MAPK/ERK and phospholipase Cγ (PLCγ). The activated FGFR1c receptor contributes to phosphate and calcium exchange. In the proximal renal tubule, inorganic phosphate (Pi) re-absorption is reduced (phosphaturic effect), through inhibition of the sodium-phosphate transporters NPT-2a and NPT-2c [53]. Klotho’s action in the distal tubule is different. There, Ca2+ resorption is enhanced by TRPV5 channels. Of importance, FGF23/Klotho/FGFR1c regulates vitamin D by inhibiting 1α-hydroxylase in the proximal renal tubule. This reduces the synthesis of active vitamin D (1,25(OH)2D3)—termed calcitriol. There is also increased enzymatic inactivation of calcitriol, but the regulation of this is not totally resolved [71].
6. Human Mutations
Lack of either Klotho or FGF23 in mice results in hyperphosphatemia, hypercalcemia, 1α-hydroxylase overactivity and hypervitaminosis D. A low phosphate diet improves disease, despite the fact that vitamin D increases further [5]. In humans, Klotho deficiency is most commonly the result of acute or chronic kidney failure [55]. Note that contrary to Klotho hypomorphic mice, these persons usually have low vitamin D levels. This is consistent with advanced renal disease.
Rare human mutations (usually autosomal recessive) cause a severe loss of either FGF23 or Klotho [5,72,73]. Nearly all cases involve FGF23. Very infrequently, low FGF23 levels are caused by anti-FGF23 antibodies, in an autoimmune process. To our knowledge, a Klotho loss of function mutation has only been reported in one person [74]. In all these different cases, the subjects have hyperphosphatemia. Vitamin D levels may also be high. At a young age, these patients develop massive calcification in soft tissues (tumoral calcinosis); as well as calcification of the arteries, and calcification in multiple organs and tissues. They have bone and dental anomalies, and systemic inflammation. To our knowledge, there has not a been a detailed analysis of aging over a long period of time in these individuals. However, hyperphosphatemia and systemic inflammation are factors that can accelerate aging. Note that subjects with FGF23 deficiency can still produce Klotho, which has FGF23-independent functions. In usual end-stage renal disease Klotho levels are low, and these persons have hyperphosphatemia and multiple other anomalies [5,55].
Some clinical FGF23 overproduction syndromes have been reported. These are due to mutations that increase FGF23 levels, or to FGF23-secreting tumors [73,75]. As expected, these individuals develop hypophosphatemia. Similarly, a translocation causing excessive Klotho production (single case reported) was associated with hypophosphatemia [76].
In addition to these findings, several Klotho genetic variants have been described [77,78,79,80,81,82]. The best characterized is denoted KL-VS haplotype. It consists of six single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNP) in strict linkage disequilibrium [77]. The KL-VS haplotype carries two mutations in the coding sequence that produce amino acid substitutions (F352V and C370S). Its occurrence varies in different populations, and it is present in 15% of Caucasians. In neuropathologies and other conditions it is generally protective in the heterozygous state, rather than in the rarer homozygous state where it can be detrimental. KL-VS heterozygosity associates with increased lifespan [78,80]. It has been linked to improved cognitive functions, as well as reduced amyloid-β (Aβ) and risk of Alzheimer’s disease [77,79,80]. Notably, KL-VS heterozygosity is associated with reduced neuroinflammation and neurodegeneration, at least in some of the subgroups that were examined [79]. KL-VS heterozygosity also appears to be protective against cardiovascular disease [81]. Several other Klotho polymorphisms have been associated with disease, but have not been studied as thoroughly as KL-VS. For example, some Klotho genetic variants altered disease expression in either a positive or negative way as related to cognition [77] and diabetes [82]. A caveat is that the beneficial effects of KL-VS heterozygosity have not been confirmed in all studies. The role of the other variants requires more extensive investigation. In all cases, the protective mode of action is not well elucidated.
7. Anti-Inflammatory Activities of Klotho
7.1. Inflammaging
The ability of Klotho to suppress inflammation is possibly its most important function, as related to aging [16,17]. Acute inflammation occurs in numerous settings; very often against infectious agents or in response to tissue injury (heat, toxins, drugs, ischemic necrosis, radiation, etc.). However, various self-components can initiate a type of sterile chronic inflammation associated with aging, and often denoted inflammaging [9,16,28]. Chronic low-grade inflammation is stimulated by pathological products or deposits such as β-amyloid (Alzheimer’s disease), calcium deposits (hypercalcemia/hyperphosphatemia), advanced-glycation end products (AGEs; hyperglycemia/diabetes), dead cell components, and many other factors. As mentioned previously, inflammation exacerbates practically all of the 12 hallmarks of aging [9,28]. Furthermore, it can initiate fibrosis in most tissues, and precipitate organ failure. Thus, the suppression of inflammation as performed by Klotho likely mitigates many aspects of aging.
7.2. Negative Regulation of the NF-κB Pathway
The inhibition of NF-κB by Klotho is an anti-inflammatory mechanism that has been often reported, as we reviewed in [16]. NF-κB is present in immune cells, and practically all other cell types. It plays a major role in initiating inflammatory and/or immune responses in all branches of the immune system [83,84]. NF-κB can be activated by several mechanisms of both innate and adaptive immunity. This includes receptors for damage-associated molecular patterns (DAMPs) and pathogen-associated molecular patterns (PAMPs), such as toll-like receptors (TLR) and NOD-like receptors (NLR). Activation can also be mediated by many other stimuli such as lymphocyte costimulatory molecules, antigen receptors, cytokines, chemokines, and stimulator of interferon genes (STING). Furthermore, NF-κB intersects with the coagulation system to induce both inflammation and thrombosis [83].
NF-κB is not a single protein but rather a family of transcriptional factors [83,84]. The key components involved are p105 (the precursor of p50), p100 (the precursor of p52), p65 (RelA), RelB, and REL (c-Rel). There are two main activation pathways, termed canonical and alternative (noncanonical), but most cells employ the canonical pathway. NF-κB signaling is initiated by the activation of kinases, such as TAK1 and the IKK complex (NEMO/IKKα/IKKβ). In resting cells, the inhibitor of κB (IκB) is bound to NF-κB (p50/p65), which blocks activation. In response to a triggering event, the IκB protein is degraded. This releases NF-κB which then migrates into the nucleus, binds to DNA, and promotes the transcription of hundreds of genes.
In several studies, Klotho blocked NF-κB nuclear translocation, or other NF-κB activating events, in endothelial cells, macrophages, pancreatic β cells and other cells [30,85,86,87,88,89,90,91,92,93,94,95]. Importantly, in cells that lacked Klotho, the addition of s-Klotho to cultures generated Klotho action. This suggests that s-Klotho was endocytosed, but the mechanism has not been elucidated.
7.3. Klotho Suppresses Activation of the NOD-like Receptor Pyrin Domain Containing 3 (NLRP3) Inflammasome
Inflammasomes are large cytoplasmic molecular complexes that detect a variety of injurious (danger) signals. Once activated, the inflammasome activates caspase-1 (or other caspase). The caspase cleaves and activates IL-1β and IL-18, as well as a protein termed gasdermin D. The cleaved gasdermin forms a pore on the membrane, which releases IL-1β and IL-18. But, the pores also provoke lytic cell death (pyroptosis) [96,97]. Several inflammasomes have been characterized (e.g., pyrin, NLRP1, NLRP3, NLRC4, AIM2), and each responds to a different set of danger signals [96,97,98]. Inflammasomes are in immune cells and numerous other cell types.
The NLRP3 inflammasome is the best characterized, and it is triggered by many more stimuli than other inflammasomes [19,96,97,98,99]. The activation of the NLRP3 inflammasome depends on two signals [100]. The first signal is mediated by NF-κB, and it increases the intra-cellular levels of the proteins required for inflammasome assembly. The activation event (signal 2) induces inflammasome assembly and function by mechanisms that are not completely elucidated. It can be delivered by several potential stimuli such as ion fluxes (especially K+ efflux), reactive oxygen species (ROS), crystals (e.g., urate), calcium deposits, lysosomal rupture, components released by dead cells (e.g., ATP), PAMPs, amyloid-β, AGEs, and other mechanisms [97,98,99,100,101]. Klotho blocks signal 1, and in many circumstances mitigates signal 2.
Of particular interest, Klotho inhibited the NLRP3 inflammasome in endothelial cells [29]. In this case, secreted IL-1β (from the inflammasome) bound to IL-1 receptor of endothelial. This stimulated NF-κB and NLRP3 inflammasome activation in a positive feedback loop (autoactivation). Autoactivation was blocked by Klotho, which prevented endothelial dysfunction.
The anti-inflammatory functions of Klotho are relevant to the treatment of sepsis [102,103]. Sepsis is frequently associated with a severe systemic inflammatory response (septic shock), multiple-organ failure, and a high rate of mortality. Klotho deficiency aggravates the severity of sepsis. This might explain why aged individuals have a reduced resistance to sepsis. In preclinical studies, Klotho administration exerted protective effects against endotoxemia in mice (a model of sepsis), and improved organ function [104,105].
8. Inhibition of TGF-β
Klotho blocks TGF-β action, as we have previously reviewed [16]. This is particularly important because overexpression of TGF-β contributes to aging in several ways. This cytokine, and other members of the TGF-β family, can promote cellular senescence, cell death, fibrosis, immune dysfunction, loss of muscle mass, as well as cancer progression [106,107,108,109]. Indeed, TGF-β is involved in a vast number of cellular responses. The TGF-β family includes 33 members. TGF-β is the best characterized, and it signals by a canonical pathway and numerous noncanonical pathways [110,111,112]. It is secreted in latent form, binds to connective tissue components, and is activated primarily by interaction with integrins, although other mechanisms apply. The three isoforms of TGF-β (TGF-β1 is the most abundant) all bind to the same membrane-bound signaling receptor. It consists of two chains; the type 1 chain is denoted TβRI (ALK5) and the type 2 chain TβRII. In the initial interaction, TGF-β binds to TβRII and TβRI to create a serine/threonine kinase complex. TβRII phosphorylates TβRI, which in the canonical pathway phosphorylates Smad2 and Smad3. These two Smads form a complex with Smad4 (the common Smad) that translocates into the nucleus. It then binds to DNA and regulates the transcription of numerous genes.
The TGF-β signaling receptor also activates key noncanonical pathways including ERK, JNK, p38 MAPK, PI3K/Akt, Rho-like GTPases and NF-κB [110,112]. Moreover, it can crosstalk with other pathways influencing a large proportion of cell functions, including other TGF-β family cytokines (BMPs, Nodal, myosin), Wnt, Notch, Hedgehog, Hippo (TAZ/YAP) and JAK/STAT. It can also crosstalk with vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF), epidermal growth factor (EGF) and hepatocyte growth factor (HGF). This demonstrates the exceedingly high number of pathways that can be modified when increasing or decreasing TGF-β activity.
TGF-β is a key regulator of the immune system. It is secreted by regulatory T cells (Treg), macrophages and several other cell types. It exerts immunosuppressive or regulatory functions on dendritic cells, macrophages, B lymphocytes, effector T lymphocytes, NK cells and neutrophils [107,113]. As related to cancer, TGF-β acts as a tumor suppressor in the early stages of neoplasia, but at later stages it promotes cancer progression and metastasis [109].
Klotho inhibits TGF-β by binding to the signaling TGF-β receptor [39,41]. Indeed, it has been reported to attach to the TβRI and TβRII chains of the receptor. These inhibitory effects have been demonstrated in vivo, especially against fibrosis. For instance, Klotho or a short Klotho peptide (KL1 domain) prevented renal fibrosis in mice [114]. The inhibition of TGF-β family members by Klotho might be applicable, for example, to pulmonary fibrosis, chronic renal disease, diabetes, cirrhosis of the liver, systemic sclerosis and sarcopenia. However, applications are still at a preclinical stage.
9. Sarcopenia
Sarcopenia (loss of muscle mass and/or function) is a feature of old age, inflammation/inflammaging, several chronic diseases and cancer. Klotho deficient mice (kl/kl or knockout) have sarcopenia and, in humans, low Klotho levels associate with sarcopenia. This subject has been recently reviewed by others [42,115], and is only briefly covered in this manuscript. The pathogenesis of sarcopenia is complex and not fully understood. The underlying mechanisms likely differ considerably depending on the clinical context, such as aging, obesity, kidney disease, cancer and other conditions. Obesity (sarcopenic obesity) [115] and chronic kidney disease [116] are common factors that induce sarcopenia. Both are associated with decreased s-Klotho levels. Importantly, Klotho overexpression in mice (by viral gene transfer) ameliorated muscle mass and structure, although this appeared to be age dependent [45]. Interestingly, this treatment had an impact on the expression of all the groups of genes related to the hallmarks of aging [45].
The action of TGF-β and myostatin (another TGF-β family member) appears important, at least in some experimental models of sarcopenia. Myostatin reduces muscle mass, as occurs in senile muscle atrophy and cachexia [117]. Ohsawa et al. [41] reported that Klotho inhibits multiple members of the TGF-β family that can reduce muscle mass. This involved TGF-β1, myostatin, GDF11 and activins. This work was performed in vitro; however, the injection of a TGF-β inhibitory drug ameliorated muscle mass in Klotho knockout mice and old wild-type mice.
Other authors have reported that Klotho ameliorates muscle regeneration and healing in response to injury [118]. In renal failure, excess FGF23 and low Klotho induce muscle wasting [119]. It has been proposed that this is due to inflammation; particularly NF-κB activation and the release of inflammatory cytokines. Furthermore, high levels of FGF23 suppress the levels of Klotho and likely negate its activity.
The findings outlined above suggest that Klotho has potential for the treatment of sarcopenia. However, it is still unknown whether it can be applied to human sarcopenia treatment.
10. Antioxidant Functions
Klotho has major antioxidant properties, mainly by activating Nrf2 and FoxO. This promotes the expression of several antioxidant enzymes, including superoxide dismutase (SOD), glutathione (GSH)-associated enzymes, catalase, and the thioredoxin system [35,102,120]. Klotho activated Nrf2 in diseases of the kidneys, the brain and the cardiovascular system [37,121,122,123,124].
In the case of FOXO proteins, Klotho inhibits the IGF-1 receptor, which abrogates IGF-1 inhibition of FOXO. Then, the FOXO proteins migrate into the nucleus and mitigate oxidative stress through enzymes including catalase and manganese SOD [35]. For instance, Klotho protected rat hearts from ischemia–reperfusion injury (IRI) [38]. This depended on the inhibition of the IGF1R/PI3K/AKT pathway.
11. Protection Against Cellular Senescence
As mentioned previously, Klotho has been found to protect cells against senescence. This has been observed in kidney tubules [24], cardiovascular system [23,123], lungs [124], brain [25,125]; pancreatic β cells [26], and other sites.
Classically, cellular senescence was recognized as a feature of telomere attrition, especially in cells dividing in culture. However, cell senescence is also a response to cell injury, which can occur in many situations [126]. For example, it can be triggered by oxidative stress, mitochondrial dysfunction, DNA damage, ER stress, oncogene activation, cancer chemotherapy, inflammatory cytokines, and TGF-β. The two classical features are cell cycle arrest (G1/S or G2 phase), and the senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP) [127]. Senescence-associated β-galactosidase (SA-β-gal) is a marker that is frequently used to identify senescent cells. Activation of some pathways (especially p16 and p53-p21) leads to permanent cell-cycle arrest, although these cells can maintain some functions and have SASP. The SASP consists of the secretion of chemokines, inflammatory cytokines, growth factors and other mediators. However, the senescence markers and composition of the SASP can vary considerably from one cell type to another.
Cells that do not normally divide can nevertheless show other features of senescence, although this can be more difficult to establish. We examined senescence in pancreatic β cells [26]. Of interest, we observed that old mice had increased numbers of senescent β cells. Furthermore, the β cells of these old mice showed severe downregulation of Klotho expression. We examined β-cell senescence in vitro with the INS-1 pancreatic β cell line [26]. Senescence was induced by incubation with doxorubicin. The senescent cells displayed marked loss of Klotho expression. However, the addition Klotho to the cultures protected these cells against senescence. It improved mitochondrial function and reduced ROS production. Klotho also improved insulin secretion. These findings suggest that Klotho has a protective role in the endocrine pancreas, in accord with our previous studies [90,128].
12. Klotho Mitigates Vascular Aging
Pathology involving the arteries is a major negative aspect of aging. It is a frequent cause of death. Arterial calcification and atherosclerosis occur gradually with age. The occurrence of early (premature) vascular aging is precipitated by either smoking, diabetes, hypertension or chronic kidney disease. In cases of advanced renal failure, Klotho insufficiency leads to hyperphosphatemia and markedly increased FGF23 levels. These extremely high levels of FGF23 can activate FGFR4 in the absence of Klotho [129]. High FGF23 levels have multiple adverse effects such as endothelial-cell dysfunction, ventricular hypertrophy, heart failure and increased mortality [129]. In contrast to FGF23, high Klotho levels associate with reduced heart failure [48].
In Klotho-deficient mice, calcification of the arteries occurs rapidly and is a prominent feature [4]. In humans over 70 years old, calcium deposition in multiple vessels is common; notably in the aorta, peripheral arteries, coronary arteries and cerebral arteries [130]. In some cases, calcium accumulates mainly in the media of arteries (Monckeberg’s medial calcific sclerosis) [131]. However, calcium is often deposited in atherosclerotic plaques, including the most clinically relevant sites such as the coronary and cerebral arteries.
Atherosclerosis associates with hyperlipidemia, but inflammation is an important contributing factor [132]. Cholesterol crystals accumulate in the plaques, and these crystals are phagocytosed by macrophages. This results in the activation of the NLRP3 inflammasome. In this situation, thioredoxin-interacting protein (TXNIP), ROS and calcium deposits can probably all activate the inflammasome. Subsequent to this, plaque erosion or rupture leads to thrombosis and vessel occlusion [133].
Recently, in a clinical study, Hellou et al. [134] reported that circulating Klotho levels inversely correlated with calcification of the aorta and iliac arteries. Furthermore, low Klotho was independently associated with increased mortality. Interestingly, Klotho was identified in the wall of blood vessels, and circulating Klotho might not be the only factor. In several previous studies, others also reported that Klotho insufficiency associates with calcific vasculopathy and/or atherosclerosis [135,136,137,138]. Klotho appears to protect against vascular disease by reducing calcification, inflammation and endothelial cell injury.
13. Retinopathy
Diabetes promotes atherosclerotic disease in arteries of various sizes, but arterioles and capillaries can also be involved. Indeed, diabetic retinopathy (DR) is characterized by microangiopathy of the retina. In advanced DR cases (proliferative DR) there is angiogenesis, hemorrhage and fibrosis. This can progress to blindness. In the retina, Klotho is produced locally and appears essential to maintain normal function [139]. The findings suggest that Klotho mitigates DR by preventing epithelial–mesenchymal transition (EMT), ROS production, vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) release, and cell death by apoptosis [140,141]. To our knowledge, its use for clinical treatment has not been reported.
Klotho is also relevant to age-related macular degeneration (AMD). TGF-β2 (produced in the eye) is thought to be a major factor in the pathogenesis of AMD [142]. Increased vitreous TGF-β2 likely induces retinal fibrosis. In mice, intravitreal injection of Klotho protected against TGF-β2-induced EMT, and retinal epithelial-cell degeneration [142]. Klotho treatment ameliorated cell senescence and EMT. There was reduced cytosolic and mitochondrial oxidative stress. These reports in DR and AMD suggest that Klotho could useful in the treatment of some retinopathies.
14. Klotho and the Skin
Klotho is expressed in the skin and other epithelial tissues [2]. Strong positive staining was seen in the epidermis and skin appendages. The skin is a major target of aging, and subject to injury by ultraviolet (UV) radiation and many other factors. Cells may undergo senescence and apoptosis. It is a major target of inflammaging, as well as a wide variety of inflammatory diseases [143]. Despite this, there have been very few studies of Klotho function in the skin. Klotho protected human keratinocytes against UV radiation, possibly by inhibiting NF-κB [144]. It prevented endothelial-to-mesenchymal transition (EndMT) [145], and this also appeared to be related to diminished NF-κB activation. Recently, Humble et al. [146] examined the effect of a Klotho-containing serum on photoaging in a pilot study. The participants experienced improvement in photoaging, wrinkles and other changes. Larger studies are required to confirm these observations.
15. Tumor Suppressor Functions
Age is a major factor in the occurrence of cancer. Some hallmarks of aging are relevant to cancer—especially genomic instability (DNA damage), epigenetic alterations and chronic inflammation. However, cancer cells resist telomere attrition and cell cycle arrest (senescence).
Several studies have confirmed that Klotho exerts potent anti-tumor activity. This has been extensively reviewed by others [15,43,147,148,149], and is only briefly addressed here. Indeed, Klotho inhibits several pathways that promote cancer progression, including Wnt, IGF-1, TGF-β, NF-κB and others. Klotho expression is frequently suppressed in malignant tumors, and tumors expressing higher levels have a more favorable prognosis. Reduced Klotho expression is often related to increased promoter methylation. Klotho is protective in several types of cancer, such as breast, pancreas, colon and liver. Importantly, inducing the expression of Klotho, or treatment with s-Klotho, suppressed the growth of cancer cells, as reviewed [149]. Klotho suppressed cancer cell proliferation, invasion and colony formation. For instance, Abramovitz et al. [64] found that Klotho expression was low in pancreatic carcinoma. Klotho treatment, or overexpression of Klotho, reduced pancreatic cancer cell proliferation, both in vitro and in vivo. It countered IGF-1 and FGF pathways. Injection of the Klotho KL1 domain mimicked the anti-cancer activity of the larger s-Klotho (KL1/KL2). Overall, these studies highlight the potential of Klotho as an anti-cancer agent.
16. Klotho Against Neurodegenerative Diseases
The role of Klotho in the CNS is not precisely elucidated, but there is extensive evidence of neuroprotection. With age, Klotho levels decline in the CSF, and its expression is reduced in the brain. Generally, low levels of Klotho associate with decreased cognitive abilities. The protective function of the KL-VS haplotype in heterozygous form was discussed previously (Section 6). More direct evidence of Klotho protection has been observed in human cerebral organoids. Forced expression of Klotho by these cells decreased neuronal senescence [150]. Importantly, Klotho protected cultured cortical neurons against Aβ toxicity; reducing neuronal apoptosis and degeneration [151]. Interestingly, these investigators observed that Klotho is expressed mostly in the axons of cortical neurons [151]. This work establishes that Klotho has direct neuroprotective effects. In cultures of neural hippocampal precursor cells, others observed that Klotho augmented neuronal differentiation and decreased apoptosis [152]. From an in vivo point of view, Klotho protein injections in nonhuman primates improved their performance in cognitive tests [153].
Indeed, Klotho-dependent neuroprotection has been reported in many preclinical studies [154,155,156,157,158,159,160,161]. It exerts anti-inflammatory and neuroprotective effects [157]. It also ameliorates myelination in the CNS, which is particularly relevant to multiple sclerosis [154]. Recently, Roig-Soriano et al. [7] delivered secreted Klotho in mice with an adeno-associated viral (AAV9) vector. It was administered by combined i.v. and intra-cerebroventricular (ICV) injection. This resulted in increased systemic and cerebral Klotho production. The injected mice showed several benefits, including increased longevity, reduced muscle fibrosis, ameliorated muscle regeneration response and, in the brain, increased cellular markers of neurogenesis.
In Alzheimer’s disease, neuroinflammation and related inflammasome activation are likely key pathogenic factors [162,163,164,165,166,167]. Notably, Aβ and hyperphosphorylated Tau protein, which are major molecular targets, promote the activation the NLRP3 inflammasome [167,168]. Moreover, other molecular targets and other inflammasomes are most likely involved. Klotho reduces neuroinflammation. Notably, it suppresses ROS, TXNIP, NF-κB activation, NLRP3 inflammasome action, and neuronal cell death.
17. Therapy with Klotho and Klotho-Enhancing Agents
17.1. Preclinical Therapy with Proteins, Peptides and Gene Transfer
The numerous antiaging functions of Klotho are summarized in Table 1. A surprising number of physiological mediators, drugs and other products alter Klotho expression [3,169] (Figure 3). With respect to aging, some downregulate Klotho and have a negative impact. This includes, for example, components of the renin-angiotensin system (RAS), NF-κB/inflammatory mediators, FGF23 (especially in renal disease), TGF-β, and hyperglycemia.
In preclinical work, the administration of either s-Klotho, the KL1 domain or Klotho-derived peptides has protected against renal, cardiovascular, metabolic and neurodegenerative diseases [3,5,7,12,141,170]. Anti-inflammatory, anti-fibrotic and neuroprotective effects were observed in several of these studies. Klotho therapy also exerted anti-cancer activities, as mentioned previously.
s-Klotho can bind to FGFR1 and act as coreceptor for FGF23. This requires the KL2 domain. The soluble KL1/KL2 form might be important to promote FGF23 action in blood vessels, but this remains to be confirmed. Of major interest, most (if not all) the blocking properties of s-Klotho can be ascribed to the KL1 domain. Thus, a KL1-derived peptide of 101 amino acids inhibited NF-κB [85,86]. A 30 amino-acid KL1 peptide blocked the TGF-β receptor [114]. Likewise, another 30 amino acid KL1 peptide (P6) attached to Wnt ligands and blocked their activity [40]. KL1 and these peptides are active in human cells, at least in vitro. However, to our knowledge, their therapeutic effectiveness in humans has not been determined.
17.2. Small Drugs That Increase Klotho Levels
Some clinical drugs, nutraceuticals and traditional medicines have been found to increase endogenous Klotho production, as reviewed [3,12,170]. This includes common drugs such as RAS inhibitors (losartan, valsartan), statins (atorvastatin, fluvastatin and others), mTOR inhibitors (rapamycin, everolimus), vitamin D and pentoxifylline. In mice, we found that γ-aminobutyric acid (GABA) systemic therapy increased Klotho in the kidneys, pancreatic β cells and serum [3,90]. GABA also increased Klotho expression in human pancreatic β cells [171,172].
Most types of clinical anti-diabetic drugs are effective at raising Klotho levels, such as metformin, glucagon-like peptide 1 (GLP-1) mimetics, peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor γ (PPAR-γ) agonists and sodium-glucose costransporter 2 (SGLT2) inhibitors [3,16]. This is possibly because hyperglycemia suppresses Klotho production. Well-known nutraceuticals (especially phytotherapeutics), such as astaxanthin, curcumin, ginseng and resveratrol also increase Klotho [3,141].
Drugs that cross the blood–brain barrier (BBB) are indicated for the treatment of central nervous system (CNS) conditions. Some senolytics (drugs that eliminate senescent cells) increased Klotho in the brain. Treatment with the senolytics dasatinib plus quercetin, which cross the BBB, increased Klotho in the kidney, whole brain, cerebellum and choroid plexus of old mice [173]. Urine Klotho was also increased. The application of telmisartan is an interesting possibility. It crosses the BBB, blocks the RAS (AT1 receptor antagonist), activates PPAR-γ and inhibits NF-κB [174]. Thus, it can stimulate Klotho expression by separate pathways. Telmisartan treatment appeared to augment Klotho in the brain of mice [175]. In APP/PS1 mutant mice it improved cognitive impairment, Aβ pathology and neuroinflammation [176].
The vast majority of these studies were performed in rodents. Often, only s-Klotho serum levels were examined. In general, Klotho was re-established to normal or near-normal levels in disease models where it had been diminished. Very little information is available on increasing Klotho levels in healthy animals. Because most of these drugs or substances exert multiple pharmacologic effects, it is unclear to what extent Klotho might contribute to disease amelioration.
17.3. Klotho Enhancement in Clinical Trials
Some evidence of drug-induced Klotho augmentation comes from clinical trials. Klotho increases of 5% to 25% have been reported. Drugs of several types have this property. For example, this was the case for renin-angiotensin system (RAS) inhibitors [177,178], a statin (fluvastatin) alone or combined with a RAS inhibitor (valsartan) [179], an mTOR inhibitor [180], anti-diabetic SGLT2 inhibitors [181], pentoxifylline [182], and vitamin D [183,184].
In a randomized controlled clinical trial, a dietary supplement (TRI 360TM) consisting of multiple vitamins (including vitamin D), minerals and ginseng powder boosted Klotho levels in subjects with psychological symptoms [185]. Klotho was prominently increased at days 90 and 180 of treatment, as compared to the placebo. This was associated with reduced oxidative stress and inflammatory biomarkers. Since multiple substances are in this supplement, it is unclear which enhanced Klotho; although both vitamin D and ginseng appear to have this property.
17.4. Role of Diet and Exercise
Multiple dietary factors have been reported to influence Klotho levels [186,187,188,189]. There have been relatively few clinical trials. Alterations in carbohydrates, fats, vitamins and minerals all appear to modify Klotho expression. Inflammatory dietary profiles inversely associate with serum Klotho levels [186]. Adherence to the Mediterranean Diet significantly increased Klotho [189]. However, in that study, only three items of the diet appeared to mediate most of the positive effect—fruits, dairy products and alcohol. Three other diets were compared and had no significant effect on Klotho. In a study of a similar population [187], the authors examined the contribution of many dietary components. After adjusting for age and sex, the only significant associations with higher Klotho levels that remained were more carbohydrate and total sugars, and less alcohol. A caveat in examining diet studies is the presence of numerous confounding factors. The results obtained in animal models are not necessarily applicable to humans. Klotho levels are highly variable in the human population, and sensitive to many factors. The levels reported with different Klotho assays can vary considerably [5,190].
The ability of exercise to increase Klotho has received considerable attention. This ties in with the well-known health benefits of physical activity and planned exercise. The relationship between exercise and Klotho has been examined by several investigators [191,192,193,194,195,196,197,198,199,200]. Various forms of exercise have been reported to increase Klotho, although there is not a general agreement on the best type, and/or the degree of Klotho enhancement. In a number of studies, the results were influenced by age, obesity, frailty, length of the exercise program and other factors. Of interest, Correa et al. [195] performed a meta analysis. They reviewed the findings from 12 reports involving 621 subjects aged 30 to 65 years. Klotho concentration increased significantly after chronic exercise training (minimum of 12 weeks). Interestingly, Klotho levels generally increased independently of the health condition or the exercise program, but with some exceptions. In conclusion, s-Klotho levels were generally increased after chronic exercise training. However, obesity appears to be a negative factor for Klotho enhancement [198,199,200]. The mechanisms by which exercise increases Klotho are not well understood, and this subject requires further investigation.
Some studies on diet, exercise, chronic diseases, aging and other aspects of Klotho biology are based on a single measurement of Klotho in each individual, and are not definitive. Furthermore, the specificity of some ELISA assays is not completely clear, making comparisons between studies difficult [5,10,190]. This has been a longstanding issue in Klotho research. An additional aspect to consider when analyzing Klotho effects is the concurrent FGF23 level (which is often not available). This is because high FGF23 suppresses the expression of Klotho, and is damaging to endothelial cells and the cardiovascular system [10,190].
18. Conclusions
The ability of Klotho to suppress aging has been known for almost thirty years. These antiaging properties are still not fully delineated, but cannot be ascribed to a single mechanism. Instead, we note several features that match the current hallmarks of aging, as reported in the literature. In mice, overexpression of Klotho modified the expression of all the groups of genes related to the hallmarks of aging. Furthermore, Klotho mitigates several major pathologies that are likely multifactorial and not easily explained by a single hallmark. Indeed, the antiaging properties of Klotho are exceptional. This is completely consistent with the fact that Klotho inhibits several pathways that have long been known to promote aging, such as TGF-β, IGF-1, NF-κB and Wnt.
In addition to this, the regulation of phosphate/calcium homeostasis is important. Klotho deficiency causes hyperphosphatemia, which is not one of the hallmarks but can mediate cellular injury. Other aspects such as protection against DNA damage, telomere attrition and stem cell depletion agree well with the hallmarks. However, in the case of Klotho, some of these aspects have not been examined extensively, and the actual mechanisms involved require more investigation. A major action of Klotho is the reduction in cellular senescence, which has been identified repeatedly. Another recurrent finding is the amelioration of mitochondrial function, and depletion of ROS. These are all important components of the aging hallmark classification.
Protection against inflammation might be the most important feature. Chronic inflammation is one of the major hallmarks of aging. Furthermore, inflammation exacerbates the other hallmarks. Examining the literature, it is evident that most of the diseases that are ameliorated by Klotho have a strong inflammatory component. In fact, Klotho can counteract both acute and chronic inflammation. This is consistent with Klotho’s ability to block NF-κB and the NLRP3 inflammasome. In addition, inflammation contributes to cell death by several pathways. In this regard, Klotho might also be effective against sepsis, and associated septic shock that has a high rate of fatal outcome.
Another key point of Klotho is its anti-fibrotic action. It has been shown to prevent fibrosis in major organs (kidneys, heart, lungs and liver), mainly through the inhibition of TGF-β and Wnt. At advanced stages fibrosis can lead to organ failure, and this is much more likely to occur in aged individuals. The blockade of TGF-β and myostatin also appear to protect against sarcopenia, at least in experimental models. Sarcopenia is a very common morbidity of aging, obesity, chronic diseases and cancer. The inhibition of TGF-β may also be relevant to the treatment of some retinopathies (e.g., diabetic, AMD). Finally, the antitumor functions are well documented, involve several mechanisms, and appear likely to be clinically applicable.
We examined several factors that increase or decrease Klotho. For example, hyperglycemia is a negative factor, and most anti-diabetic drugs increase Klotho. NF-κB (as in inflammation) and TGF-β (as in fibrosis) are other negative regulators of Klotho expression of clinical importance. They are potentially amenable to Klotho therapy. Practically all current drugs or other treatments that increase Klotho also have many other effects. In these cases, it can be extremely difficult to determine the contribution of Klotho. A major limitation remains the lack of clinical investigation of direct Klotho therapy, and this should be a prime goal of future research.