Full text is available at the source.
Drug therapy for obstructive sleep apnoea in adults
Jun 4, 2013The Cochrane database of systematic reviews
Medicine treatments for adults with blocked airway sleep apnea
AI simplified
Abstract
Drug therapies may reduce the apnoea hypopnoea index (AHI) by between 24% and 45% in patients with obstructive sleep apnoea (OSA).
- Thirty trials involving 516 participants assessed various drug therapies for OSA.
- Fluticasone significantly reduced AHI from 30.3 to 23.3 and improved daytime alertness compared to placebo.
- Donepezil led to a reduction in AHI from 23.2 to 20 after three months in patients with mild to moderate Alzheimer's disease.
- High-dose ondansetron and fluoxetine treatment resulted in a 40.5% decrease in AHI after 28 days.
- Paroxetine reduced AHI by an average of 6.10 events/hour but did not improve daytime symptoms.
- Overall, the quality of evidence supporting drug therapy for OSA is low, necessitating further research.
AI simplified
BACKGROUND: The treatment of choice for moderate to severe obstructive sleep apnoea (OSA) is continuous positive airways pressure (CPAP) applied via a mask during sleep. However, this is not tolerated by all individuals and its role in mild OSA is not proven. Drug therapy has been proposed as an alternative to CPAP in some patients with mild to moderate sleep apnoea and could be of value in patients intolerant of CPAP. A number of mechanisms have been proposed by which drugs could reduce the severity of OSA. These include an increase in tone in the upper airway dilator muscles, an increase in ventilatory drive, a reduction in the proportion of rapid eye movement (REM) sleep, an increase in cholinergic tone during sleep, an increase in arousal threshold, a reduction in airway resistance and a reduction in surface tension in the upper airway.
OBJECTIVES: To determine the efficacy of drug therapies in the specific treatment of sleep apnoea.
SEARCH METHODS: We searched the Cochrane Airways Group Specialised Register of trials. Searches were current as of July 2012.
SELECTION CRITERIA: Randomised, placebo controlled trials involving adult patients with confirmed OSA. We excluded trials if continuous positive airways pressure, mandibular devices or oxygen therapy were used. We excluded studies investigating treatment of associated conditions such as excessive sleepiness, hypertension, gastro-oesophageal reflux disease and obesity.
DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS: We used standard methodological procedures recommended by The Cochrane Collaboration.
MAIN RESULTS: Thirty trials of 25 drugs, involving 516 participants, contributed data to the review. Drugs had several different proposed modes of action and the results were grouped accordingly in the review. Each of the studies stated that the participants had OSA but diagnostic criteria were not always explicit and it was possible that some patients with central apnoeas may have been recruited.Acetazolamide, eszopiclone, naltrexone, nasal lubricant (phosphocholinamine) and physiostigmine were administered for one to two nights only. Donepezil in patients with and without Alzheimer's disease, fluticasone in patients with allergic rhinitis, combinations of ondansetrone and fluoxetine and paroxetine were trials of one to three months duration, however most of the studies were small and had methodological limitations. The overall quality of the available evidence was low.The primary outcomes for the systematic review were the apnoea hypopnoea index (AHI) and the level of sleepiness associated with OSA, estimated by the Epworth Sleepiness Scale (ESS). AHI was reported in 25 studies and of these 10 showed statistically significant reductions in AHI.Fluticasone in patients with allergic rhinitis was well tolerated and reduced the severity of sleep apnoea compared with placebo (AHI 23.3 versus 30.3; P < 0.05) and improved subjective daytime alertness. Excessive sleepiness was reported to be altered in four studies, however the only clinically and statistically significant change in ESS of -2.9 (SD 2.9; P = 0.04) along with a small but statistically significant reduction in AHI of -9.4 (SD 17.2; P = 0.03) was seen in patients without Alzheimer's disease receiving donepezil for one month. In 23 patients with mild to moderate Alzheimer's disease donepezil led to a significant reduction in AHI (donepezil 20 (SD 15) to 9.9 (SD 11.5) versus placebo 23.2 (SD 26.4) to 22.9 (SD 28.8); P = 0.035) after three months of treatment but no reduction in sleepiness was reported. High dose combined treatment with ondansetron 24 mg and fluoxetine 10 mg showed a 40.5% decrease in AHI from the baseline at treatment day 28. Paroxetine was shown to reduce AHI compared to placebo (-6.10 events/hour; 95% CI -11.00 to -1.20) but failed to improve daytime symptoms.Promising results from the preliminary mirtazapine study failed to be reproduced in the two more recent multicentre trials and, moreover, the use of mirtazapine was associated with significant weight gain and sleepiness. Few data were presented on the long-term tolerability of any of the compounds used.
AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS: There is insufficient evidence to recommend the use of drug therapy in the treatment of OSA. Small studies have reported positive effects of certain agents on short-term outcomes. Certain agents have been shown to reduce the AHI in largely unselected populations with OSA by between 24% and 45%. For donepezil and fluticasone, studies of longer duration with a larger population and better matching of groups are required to establish whether the change in AHI and impact on daytime symptoms are reproducible. Individual patients had more complete responses to particular drugs. It is possible that better matching of drugs to patients according to the dominant mechanism of their OSA will lead to better results and this also needs further study.
Related papers
Apr '06
Medicine treatments for adults with obstructive sleep apnea
cited by 57 papers
systematic review
Jul '15
How opioid, sleep, and sedative medicines affect breathing during sleep in adults with obstructive sleep apnea
cited by 54 papers
systematic review
Nov '20
Throat muscle exercises for treating obstructive sleep apnea
cited by 41 papers
systematic review
Dec '19
Using pressure changes or added moisture to improve continuous positive airway pressure use in adults with obstructive sleep apnea
cited by 14 papers
systematic review
Jan '20
Anti-inflammatory drugs for treating blocked breathing during sleep in children
cited by 27 papers
systematic review
May '19
Using body position to reduce breathing pauses in obstructive sleep apnea
cited by 33 papers
systematic review