The Cochrane database of systematic reviews··
Education support services to help children and teens with chronic illnesses stay engaged in school and do better academically
Updated
Abstract
Four studies involving a combined total of 359 participants examined educational support interventions for children and adolescents with chronic health conditions.
- Evidence suggests that educational support improved school engagement in three of the four studies.
- Contradictory results were observed regarding academic achievement, with one study showing a positive effect and another a negative effect.
- One study indicated a positive impact on transition back to school, but the evidence came from a small sample size (n = 30), suggesting uncertainty about the effect.
- Two studies reported a positive impact of educational support interventions on mental health, specifically self-esteem.
- The overall certainty of evidence for school engagement and academic achievement was judged to be 'very low', while mental health outcomes were assessed as having 'low' certainty.
Simplified
BACKGROUND: Chronic health conditions in children and adolescents can have profound impacts on education, well-being and health. They are described as non-communicable illnesses that are prolonged in duration, do not resolve spontaneously, and rarely cured completely. Due to variations in the definition of chronic health conditions and how they are measured prevalence estimates vary considerably and have been reported to be as high as 44% in children and adolescents. Of young people with a chronic health condition, an estimated 5% are affected by severe conditions characterised by limitations to daily activities impacting their ability to attend school. School attendance is important for academic and social skill development as well as well-being. When children and adolescents are absent from school due to a chronic health condition, school engagement can be affected. Disengagement from school is associated with poorer academic achievement, social-emotional functioning and career choices. Education support services for children and adolescents with chronic health conditions aim to prevent disengagement from school, education and learning during periods where their illness caused them to miss school. However, there is limited evidence on the effectiveness of educational support interventions at improving school engagement and educational/learning outcomes for children and adolescents with chronic health conditions.
OBJECTIVES: To describe the nature of educational support interventions for children and adolescents with a chronic health condition, and to examine the effectiveness of these interventions on school engagement and academic achievement.
SEARCH METHODS: We searched eight electronic databases which span the health/medical, social sciences and education disciplines between 18 and 25 January 2021: Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL), MEDLINE (Ovid), Embase (Ovid). CINAHL (EBSCO), PsycINFO (EBSCO), ERIC (Education Resources Information Center), Applied Social Sciences Index and Abstracts: ASSIA (ProQuest), and PubMed (from 2019). We also searched five grey literature trials registers and databases between 8 and 12 February 2021 to identify additional published and unpublished studies, theses and conference abstracts, as well as snowballing reference lists of included studies.
SELECTION CRITERIA: Randomised controlled trials (RCTs), controlled before-and-after studies and interrupted time series studies that met the inclusion criteria were selected. Other inclusion criteria were: participants - must include children or adolescents (aged four to 18 years) with a chronic health condition, intervention - must include educational support, outcomes - must report the primary outcomes (i.e. school engagement or academic achievement) or secondary outcomes (i.e. quality of life, transition to school/school re-entry, mental health or adverse outcomes).
DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS: Two people independently screened titles and abstracts, and full-text articles, to identify included studies. Where disagreements arose between reviewers, the two reviewers discussed the discrepancy. If resolution was unable to be achieved, the issues were discussed with a senior reviewer to resolve the matter. We extracted study characteristic data and risk of bias data from the full texts of included studies using a data extraction form before entering the information into Review Manager 5.4.1. Two people independently extracted data, assessed risk of bias of individual studies and undertook GRADE assessments of the quality of the evidence. Meta-analysis was not possible due to the small number of studies for each outcome. Our synthesis, therefore, used vote-counting based on the direction of the effect/impact of the intervention.
MAIN RESULTS: The database searches identified 14,202 titles and abstracts. Grey literature and reference list searches did not identify any additional studies that met the inclusion criteria. One hundred and twelve full-text studies were assessed for eligibility, of which four studies met the eligibility criteria for inclusion in the review. All studies were randomised controlled studies with a combined total of 359 participants. All included studies were disease-specific; three studies focused on children with cancer, and one study focused on children with Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD). There was evidence that education support improved school engagement with three of four studies favouring the intervention. Three studies measured academic achievement but only two studies provided effect estimates. Based on the vote-counting method, we found contradictory results from the studies: one study showed a positive direction of effect and the other study showed a negative direction of effect. One study measured transition back to school and found a positive impact of education support favouring the intervention (SMD 0.18, 95% CI -0.46 to 0.96, no P value reported). The result came from a single study with a small sample size (n = 30), and produced a confidence interval that indicated the possibility of a very small or no effect. The overall certainty of evidence for these three outcomes was judged to be 'very low'. Two of four studies measured mental health (measured as self-esteem). Both studies reported a positive impact of education support interventions on mental health; this was the only outcome for which the overall certainty of evidence was judged to be 'low' rather than 'very low'. No studies measured or reported quality of life or adverse effects. Risk of bias (selection, performance, detection, attrition, reporting and other bias) was assessed using the Cochrane risk of bias tool for randomised trials (version 1). Overall risk of bias for all studies was assessed as 'high risk' because all studies had at least one domain at high risk of bias.
AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS: This review has demonstrated the infancy of quality research on the effectiveness of education support interventions for children and adolescents with chronic health conditions. At best, we can say that we are uncertain whether education support interventions improve either academic achievement or school engagement. Of the secondary outcomes, we are also uncertain whether education support interventions improve transition back to school, or school re-entry. However, we suggest there is some evidence that education support may slightly improve mental health, measured as self-esteem. Given the current state of the evidence of the effectiveness of education support interventions for children and adolescents with chronic health conditions, we highlight some important implications for future research in this field to strengthen the evidence that can inform effective practice and policy.
Funding
Competing interests
Tony Barnett: Declares no conflict of interest. Michelle Tollit: Declares no conflict of interest. Savithiri Ratnapalan: Declares no conflict of interest. Susan Sawyer: Declares no conflict of interest. Margaret Kelaher: Author deceased; No known conflicts of interest previously declared.
PubMed
Related papers
Nov '22
Folic acid supplements and malaria risk and severity in people using antifolate malaria drugs in affected areas
cited by 30 papers
systematic review
May '23
Recovery schools and their impact on behavior and school performance in students recovering from substance use
top 10% journal
cited by 11 papers
journal article
May '23
Small class sizes linked to better student achievement in primary and secondary schools
top 10% journal
cited by 28 papers
journal article
Jun '24
Summer programs and their effects on outcomes for disadvantaged or at-risk young people
top 10% journal
cited by 5 papers
journal article
Dec '16
School education programs to prevent accidental injuries in children and young people
cited by 20 papers
systematic review
Mar '14
Lifestyle changes to improve school performance in overweight and obese children and teens
cited by 54 papers
systematic review
Oct '18
Interventions for Multiple Risk Behaviors in Young People at Home, School, and Personal Levels
cited by 67 papers
systematic review
Jul '16
Technology tools to support memory and thinking skills recovery in children and teens after brain injury
cited by 18 papers
systematic review
Mar '18
Physical activity, diet, and other behavior changes to improve thinking skills and school performance in children and teens with obesity or overweight
cited by 46 papers
systematic review
Jan '18
How Exercise, Diet, and Other Behaviors May Improve Thinking and School Performance in Overweight Children and Teens
cited by 61 papers
systematic review