The influence of improved air quality on mortality risks in Erfurt, Germany.
Jun 27, 2009Research report (Health Effects Institute)
How better air quality is linked to lower death risks in Erfurt, Germany
AI simplified
Abstract
Air pollution concentrations in Erfurt decreased substantially over the study period, with annual SO2 levels dropping from 64 microg/m3 in 1992 to 4 microg/m3 in 2001.
- A 1.6% increased risk for daily mortality is associated with a 19.7 microg/m3 increase in NO2 (lag day 3).
- A 1.9% increased risk for daily mortality correlates with a 0.48 mg/m3 increase in CO (lag day 4).
- A 2.9% increased risk for daily mortality is linked to a 9743/cm3 increase in ultrafine particles (lag day 4).
- A 4.6% increased risk for daily mortality is associated with a 43.8 microg/m3 daily maximum 8-hour concentration of O3 (lag day 2).
- No consistent associations with daily mortality were found for PM10, PM2.5, or SO2.
- The strongest mortality associations with pollution were observed during the transitional period from 1995 to 1998.
AI simplified
Around the world, daily variations in ambient air pollution have been consistently associated with variations in daily mortality. The aim of the study presented here was to assess the effects of ambient air pollution on daily mortality during a period of tremendous changes in air quality in the city of Erfurt, in eastern Germany, from October 1991 to March 2002. Data on particle size distributions were obtained from September 1995 to March 2002 at a research monitoring station. For particles from 0.01 microm to 2.5 microm in diameter, number concentrations (NCs)* and mass concentrations (MCs) were calculated. Particles with diameters less than or equal to 0.10 microm are defined as ultrafine particles (UFP). Data on the gaseous pollutants NO2, CO, SO2, and O3 and on PM10 (particulate matter [PM] with aerodynamic diameter less than or equal to 10 microm) were obtained from a government air-monitoring station. Data on changes in energy consumption, car fleet composition, and population were collected from local authorities. Death certificates of persons living in and dying in Erfurt were abstracted, and daily mortality counts were calculated. Poisson regression models were used to analyze the data, applying penalized splines (also known as P-splines) to model nonlinear relationships in the confounders. Model selection was done without air pollutants in the models, based on a combination of goodness-of-fit criteria and avoidance of autocorrelation in error terms. Final models included P-splines of time trend, meteorologic data, and influenza epidemics as well as day of the week with an indicator variable. Results are presented as change per interquartile range (IQR), i.e., change in the relative risk of mortality associated with a change in the concentration from the 25th to the 75th percentile of a given pollutant. Air pollutants were considered both as linear terms and as P-splines to assess the exposure-response functions. Changes in effect estimates over time were calculated using fully Bayesian time-varying coefficient models. This method was selected over four other approaches tested in simulation studies. Air-pollution concentrations decreased substantially in Erfurt during the decade under observation. The strongest changes were observed for SO2, for which annual concentrations decreased from 64 microg/m3 in 1992 to 4 microg/m3 in 2001. Concentrations of PM10, PM2.5 (particulate matter with aerodynamic diameter less than or equal to 2.5 microm), and CO decreased by more than 50%. NO2, O3, and ultrafine particles also decreased, though to a lesser extent. Based on visual inspection of the data on the changes in ambient air-pollution concentrations during the study period, we defined three study subperiods: A first subperiod from 1991 to 1995; a second, transitional subperiod from 1995 to 1998; and a third subperiod from 1998 to 2002. Generally, air-pollution concentrations decreased substantially from the first subperiod to the second, and some additional decreases occurred from the second subperiod to the third. During the second, transitional subperiod, natural gas replaced coal as the main energy source in Erfurt. In addition, the number of cars with catalytic converters increased over time, as did the number of cars in general. To facilitate the interpretation of the results, we organized the air pollutants into four groups: (1) NO2, CO, and ultrafine particles, (2) PM10 and PM2.5, (3) SO2, and (4) O3. We observed a 1.6% increased risk for daily mortality (CI, -0.4% to 3.5%) for an increase of 19.7 microg/m3 in NO2 (lag day 3), a 1.9% increased risk (CI, 0.2%-3.6%) for an increase of 0.48 mg/m3 in CO (lag day 4), and a 2.9% increased risk (CI, 0.3%-5.5%) for an increase of 9743/cm3 in ultrafine particles (lag day 4). No consistent associations were observed for PM10, PM2.5, or SO2. For O3, a 4.6% increased risk for daily mortality (CI, 1.1%-8.3%) was associated with a 43.8 microg/m3 maximum 8-hr concentration of O3 per day (lag day 2). For all four pollutants, exposure-response functions suggested no deviation from linearity. However, in time-varying models the strongest associations were observed for NO2, CO, and ultrafine particles during the transition subperiod, from 1995 to 1998, when O3 concentrations were lowest. Changes in source characteristics or ambient air-pollution concentrations were not able to explain these observations in a straightforward manner. However, the observations suggested that changes such as the introduction of three-way catalytic converters in cars and the substitution natural gas for coal might have been beneficial. Overall we concluded that: 1. Economic and political changes and the adoption of new technologies in eastern Germany resulted in distinct improvements in ambient air quality; 2. Urban air pollution in Erfurt changed within one decade from the eastern mixture toward that of western Europe ("western mixture"), which is dominated by concentrations of NOx, O3, fine particles, and ultrafine particles with low concentrations of SO2; 3. There was an association between daily mortality and ultrafine particles and combustion-related gases (lag days 3 or 4); 4. Ultrafine particles seemed to be the best pollution indicator and to point to the role of local combustion in the pollution mixture; 5. Regression coefficients showed variation over time for NO2, CO, ultrafine particles, and O3 that could not be explained by nonlinearity in the exposure-response functions; 6. Mortality associated with pollution was lower at the end of the 1990s than during the 1990s, except for mortality associated with O3; and 7. Mortality associated with pollution was strongest in the second, transitional subperiod, from 1995 to 1998, when changes in source characteristics had taken place but the benefits of improved ambient air quality had not yet been completely achieved.
Related papers
Mar '02
Daily death rates linked to fine and ultrafine air particles in Erfurt, Germany: impact of particle size and amount
cited by 81 papers
research support, u.s. gov't, non-p.h.s.
Aug '12
Short-term air pollution and hospital visits for serious lung infections in young children in Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam
cited by 38 papers
multicenter study
Aug '01
Short-term effects of air pollution in Italy: A combined analysis of studies
top 50% journal
cited by 16 papers
meta-analysis
Jun '09
Long-term traffic air pollution linked to lung and heart death rates in the Netherlands
cited by 125 papers
research support, u.s. gov't, non-p.h.s.
Mar '11
Daily deaths linked to air pollution and changes during extreme heat in Wuhan, China
cited by 27 papers
research support, u.s. gov't, non-p.h.s.
Mar '11
Daily air pollution levels linked to deaths over time in Shanghai, China
cited by 31 papers
research support, non-u.s. gov't
Jan '13
Air pollution and death rates in multiple Latin American cities
cited by 67 papers
research support, non-u.s. gov't
Jan '13
Effects of the 1990 Hong Kong law limiting sulfur in fuel
cited by 7 papers
research support, u.s. gov't, non-p.h.s.
Jul '09
Long-term analysis of how air pollution relates to death rates in the American Cancer Society study
cited by 335 papers
research support, n.i.h., extramural
Feb '12
Baseline Study of London's Low Emission Zone
cited by 18 papers
research support, u.s. gov't, non-p.h.s.