What this is
- This research investigates the role of natural killer T cells (NKTs) in diet-induced (MASH) using Balb/c mice.
- It examines sex-based differences in immune responses and liver damage between male and female mice.
- The study finds that female mice experience milder liver damage compared to males, highlighting the protective role of NKTs in males.
Essence
- NKTs provide protection against liver damage in male Balb/c mice with , while female mice show less dependence on NKTs for liver health. This study emphasizes the importance of sex differences in immune response and disease progression.
Key takeaways
- Female Balb/c mice exhibit milder than males after a high-fat choline-deficient diet, suggesting a sex-based difference in liver disease severity.
- Male Balb/c mice with show reduced liver damage and inflammation compared to CD1d-deficient males, indicating NKTs' protective role in liver health.
- In females, have a negligible role in early progression, suggesting that other factors may contribute to their liver health.
Caveats
- The study primarily uses a mouse model, which may not fully replicate human disease mechanisms. Further research is needed to confirm findings in human subjects.
- The absence of type II NKT cell assessment limits the understanding of their potential role in liver disease, which may differ from type I NKTs.
Definitions
- steatohepatitis: Inflammation and damage to the liver caused by fat accumulation, often associated with metabolic dysfunction.
- NKT cells: A subset of immune cells that share properties of both natural killer cells and T cells, involved in immune responses.
AI simplified
Background
Natural killer T cells (NKTs), first named in 1995 [1], are a heterogeneous group of non-conventional T cells that express both natural killer (NK) cells and lymphocytes T markers, presenting characteristics of both the adaptive and the innate immune system [2, 3]. Based on the expression of the TCR, these cells can be subdivided into two subpopulations: classic NKTs, also known as type I or invariants (iNKTs), which express a semi-invariant T cell receptor (TCR) [4]; and non-classic NKTs or type II, which express a broader TCR repertoire [5].
Unlike conventional T cells, which recognize peptide antigens through the type I and II major histocompatibility complex (MHC), NKTs recognize lipid antigens presented by the non-classical MHC type I, CD1d [6], and can be activated by both self-antigens and foreign/microbial antigens [7]. In the liver, CD1d is expressed on Kupffer cells (KCs), hepatic stellate cells (HSCs), hepatocytes, circulating dendritic cells (DCs) and endothelial cells of the hepatic sinusoids, where NKT cells patrol [8].
NKT cells have been detected in numerous tissues, such as thymus, spleen, lung, bone marrow, lymph nodes, intestines, blood and liver, the latter being the one with the highest frequency of NKTs [9], 20- to 100-fold higher than in other organs [6]. In the murine liver, NKTs represent 20–30% of the total population of hepatic lymphocytes, while in the case of humans, this percentage is reduced to < 1% of hepatic lymphocytes [10, 11]. Of note, while in the murine model liver type I iNKTs are much more abundant than type II NKTs, in humans, the situation is the opposite [10, 12].
Similar to what happens with other cells of the innate immune system (such as macrophages, NK cells or neutrophils), NKTs respond quickly to stimuli capable of activating them, secreting a broad profile of effector cytokines and chemokines in large quantities [13], that can be divided into NKT1 (IFNγ), NKT2 (IL4) or NKT17 (IL17) cytokines. The NKTs will secrete different cytokine profiles based on the tissue milieu, the antigen-presenting cell and the type of lipid antigen [14]. Additionally, distinct subsets of NKTs tend to be more prevalent in different tissues [15]. In particular, NKT1 cells are the most abundant hepatic subset in C57BL/6 mice, while Balb/c mice presents a majority of hepatic NKT2 cells [15], indicating that there can be also strain-dependent differences in NKT-dependent effector properties. Finally, activated iNKTs can unfold perforin-dependent and FasL-dependent cytotoxic functions [16].
Due to the wide repertoire of cytokines that NKTs are capable of secreting, these cells have been implicated in numerous immune responses, including those against infectious agents [17, 18] and tumors [19], regulating multiple autoimmune [20] and inflammatory diseases [21]. In the liver, the activation of NKTs seems to contribute both to the onset and to the end of the inflammation and fibrosis, depending on the liver disease being evaluated, generating much controversy in this regard [14].
Metabolic dysfunction-associated steatotic liver disease (MASLD), previously known as non-alcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD) [22], defined by the presence of hepatic steatosis without causes for secondary hepatic fat accumulation [23], is the most common liver disease in Western countries, has a global prevalence of 25%, depending on the method of diagnosis, age, sex and ethnicity [24, 25]. To date, there are no approved drugs for MASLD, so given the rising global burden of MASLD and its economic impact there is an urgent need to understand the cellular and molecular mechanisms responsible for disease progression [26–28]. MASLD includes different histological conditions: simple fatty liver, characterized by the absence of hepatocellular damage, and MASH (metabolic dysfunction-associated steatohepatitis), characterized by the presence of inflammation and hepatocellular damage, with or without fibrosis. MASLD, and particularly MASH, can progress to cirrhosis and carcinoma hepatocellular [29]. For reasons that are not yet fully clarified, incidence and prevalence of MASLD is higher in men than in premenopausal women (age ≤ 50‐60 years), while after menopause MASLD occurs at higher rate in women [30].
Regarding research concerning NKT cells in metabolic diseases various studies have reported an aggravating role for NKT cells, for example in the liver of leptin-deficient ob/ob mice [31], high-fat diet (HFD) or obesity induced inflammation [32, 33], ethanol-induced liver damage [34], or steatohepatitis [35–38]. Some of these studies also observe that, in the most advanced stage of steatohepatitis, NKTs appear to accumulate in the liver promoting fibrosis by activating hepatic stellate cells [37, 38]. In contrast, other authors have reported opposite results as iNKT-cell-deficient mice displayed increased liver fibrosis in HFD-fed mice [39], suggesting a protective role for iNKTs in this setting. Given that NKT cells are at the crossroad of adaptive and innate immune system, it is possible that some of these discrepancies are due to the genetic background of the mice used. Worth mentioning, the studies that support a detrimental role for NKT cells in steatohepatitis were performed in C57Bl6/J mice [32–38], with a Th1-dominant immune response. However, the study of Miyagi et al. [39], in which a protective role for iNKT-cells was seen, was performed using Jα18 deficient mice (lacking only type I NKTs) in the Balb/c strain, with a Th2-dominant response [40].
Thus, given the as yet unclear role of NKTs in MASLD/MASH, we wanted to shed some light on the matter by investigating the role of these cells in a mouse model of diet-induced steatohepatitis. To validate if the Th2-phenotype affected NKT cell behavior during MASH we chose to use the Balb/c strain and CD1d-deficient mice, in the Balb/c background. CD1d-deficient mice, lacking both type I and type II NKTs, the latter type more abundant in human than in mice [12], was the model selected as previous studies had been carried out in Balb/c Jα18-deficient mice lacking only type I NKTs, and the possible contribution of type II NKTs in this context had not been yet addressed [39].
Furthermore, taking into account that, to date, most of the studies have been performed in male mice and, to our knowledge, no comparative gender study of steatohepatitis with the Balb/c strain has been carried out in mice lacking NKTs, we also included females to assess the relevance of the genetic background and the existence of a possible sexual dimorphism in the role of NKT cells in this pathology.
Consistent with the Th2 immune response observed in the Balb/c strain, we hypothesize that NKT-cell-deficient mice will exhibit more aggravated steatohepatitis than their wild type counterparts. Females are also expected to have a milder form of steatohepatitis than males, consistent with the known protection provided by estrogens [41–43], and as it has been already reported by others that gender and the mouse strain affect MASLD [44, 45].
Materials and methods
Animal care and experimental protocol
Animal studies were approved by the institutional animal care committee (Universitat de Barcelona, protocol 177/20), in accordance with the principles and procedures outlined in the National Institutes of Health Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals. Male and female Balb/c mice and CD1d knock-out mice (CD1d−/−), also in Balb/c background, were used at 6 to 8 weeks of age. Balb/c mice were purchased from Charles River, and the CD1d−/− colony (The Jackson Laboratory, Stock #003814, C.129S2Cd1tm1Gru/J) was a gift from Drs Engel and Puñet-Ortiz, Universitat de Barcelona. All mice were housed in the animal facilities of the Faculty of Medicine (Universitat de Barcelona) with a 12-h light/dark cycle. Food and water were provided ad libitum. To study the role of NKT cells in a MASH model, animals were fed a high-fat choline-deficient diet (HFCD) (L-amino acid diet with 60% kcal from fat, 0.1% of methionine and no added choline, Open Source diets #A06071302) for 6 weeks [46]. Control animals were fed with a standard chow diet (CHOW). Mice, Balb/c and CD1d−/−, were divided by sex and genotype and randomly assigned into groups according to the following scheme: male mice [CHOW CD1d KO, n = 8; CHOW Balb/c, n = 8; HFCD CD1d KO, n = 10; HFCD Balb/c, n = 10]; female mice [CHOW CD1d KO, n = 8; CHOW Balb/c, n = 8; HFCD CD1d KO, n = 10; HFCD Balb/c, n = 10]. After 6 weeks of CHOW or HFCD diet, animals were killed, using pentobarbital (50 mg/kg) intraperitoneal injection, and blood and hepatic samples were obtained for analysis.
NAFLD activity score (NAS)
NAS score was determined in H&E samples as previously reported [47]. In brief, NAS score was blindly assessed in CHOW and HFCD groups (n = 8 for CHOW groups, and n = 10 for HFCD groups) evaluating the degree of steatosis (ranging from 0 to 3 as follows: < 5% Score 0, 5%-33% Score 1, 33%− 66% Score 2, > 66% Score 3), lobular inflammation (ranging from 0 to 3 as follows: no foci Score 0, > 2 foci per 200X field Score 1, 2–4 foci per 200X filed Score 2, > 4 foci per 200X field Score 3), and ballooning (ranging from 0 to 2 as follows: no ballooning Score 0, few balloon cells Score 1, many cells/prominent ballooning Score 2). According to this algorithm, total NAS score ranges from 0 to 8 [47].
RNA isolation and RT-PCR
Total RNA was isolated from the liver left lobe with TRIzol™ Reagent (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA, USA), following the manufacturer’s protocol (n = 5 for all groups). Reverse-transcription was performed with iScript cDNA Synthesis Kit (Bio-Rad Laboratories, Hercules, CA, USA) from 1 µg of RNA. Real-Time PCR was executed with iTaq Universal SYBR Green Supermix (Bio-Rad Laboratories) from 10 ng of cDNA, following the manufacturer’s instructions using an iCycler Thermal Cycler iQ5 Multicolor Real-Time PCR Detection System (Bio-Rad Laboratories). β-actin was used as a housekeeping gene since its expression was not affected by genotype, sex, or diet.
| Gene | Forward 5′ 3’ | Reverse 5′ 3’ |
|---|---|---|
| α-SMA | ATG GCT CTG GGC TCT GTA AG | CCC ATT CCA ACC ATT ACT CC - |
| β-Actin | GAC GGC CAG GTC ATC ACT AT | CGG ATG TCA ACG TCA CAC TT |
| CD1d | AAT TAC ACC TTC CGC TGC C | CTT CGT GAA GCT GAT GGT GG |
| Col1a1 | GAG CGG AGA GTA CTG GAT CG | GTT CGG GCT GAT GTA CCA GT |
| F4/80 | TTT CCT CGC CTG CTT CTT C | CCC CGT CTC TGT ATT CAA CC |
| IFN-γ | CAG CCA AGC GGC TGA CTG AA | GTG CTG TCT GGC CTG CTG TT |
| IL-1β | GAG CTG AAA GCT CTC CAC CTC | CTT TCC TTT GAG GCC CAA GGC |
| IL-4 | CAG GAG AAG GGA CGC CAT GC | TGC GAA GCA CCT TGG AAG CC |
| IL-6 | CCG GAG AGG AGA CTT CAC AG | CCG GAG AGG AGA CTT CAC AG |
| IL-10 | CGG GAA GAC AAT AAC TGC ACC C | CGG TTA GCA GTA TGT TGT CCA GC |
| IL-12 | ATA AGA CGA CGG CAC GAA GG | GGT AAG GAT GAA GAG GGA GTT CAA |
| CCL2 | CAA GAA GGA ATG GGT CCA GA | GCT GAA GAC CTT AGG GCA GA |
| TNF-α | CTG AAC TTC GGG GTG ATC GGT | ACG TGG GCT ACA GGC TTG TCA |
Tissue analysis: H&E and Sirius red staining
A piece of the liver left lobe was formalin-fixed for 24 h and paraffin embedded. Sections of 7 µm were routinely stained with H&E or 0.1% Sirius red-picric solution following standard procedures (n = 8 for CHOW groups, and n = 10 for HFCD groups). The slices were examined with a Nikon (Tokyo, Japan) Eclipse E-1000 microscope equipped with an Olympus (Tokyo, Japan) DP72 camera. The quantification of the collagen fibers stained with the Sirius Red solution was blindly assessed in all the experimental groups with the ImageJ 1.48v software (National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD).
Hydroxyproline quantification
Hepatic hydroxyproline levels, an indirect measure of collagen content, were determined (n = 8 for CHOW groups, and n = 10 for HFCD groups) by a modification of the protocol published by Reddy et al. [48]. Briefly, liver samples and trans-4-Hydroxy-L-proline standards were homogenized in 6N HCl and later hydrolyzed by autoclaving at 121°◦C for 25 min. Hydroxyproline content from samples and standards was then oxidized with Chloramine-T and colored with Ehrlich reagent; absorbance was read at 550 nm in a Multiskan Sky Microplate Spectrophotometer (ThermoFisher Scientific, Waltham, MA, USA).
Transaminases, triglycerides and cholesterol
A blood sample was obtained from the animals at the time of killing. After a centrifugation (10,000g, 10 min, 4 °C), the serum was separated diluted 1/8 in saline (0,9% NaCl). Alanine and aspartate transaminases (ALT and AST) were measured (n = 8 for CHOW groups, and n = 10 for HFCD groups) using a biochemical analyzer at the Hospital Clinic, Barcelona.
A piece of liver (approximately 20 mg) obtained after killing was homogenized manually, with a disposable pellet pestle, in physiological saline. After centrifugation (10,000g, 10 min, 4 ºC), the supernatant was diluted 1/4 in physiological serum. Triglycerides and cholesterol (n = 8 for CHOW groups, and n = 10 for HFCD groups) in diluted homogenate were measured using a biochemical analyzer at the Hospital Clinic, Barcelona.
Sodium dodecyl sulfate protein gel electrophoresis and immunoblot analysis
Cell lysates were prepared in RIPA buffer (50-mM Tris·HCl, pH 8, 150-mM NaCl, 1% Nonidet P-40, 0.1% sodium dodecyl sulfate, 1% Triton X-100 plus proteinase inhibitors). Protein concentration was determined by Bradford assay, and samples containing 10–50 μg were separated by sodium dodecyl sulfate protein gel electrophoresis. Proteins were transferred to nitrocellulose membranes. After this, membranes were blocked in 8% nonfat milk in 20-mM Tris–HCl, 150-mM NaCl, and 0.05% Tween 20 for 1 h at room temperature. Primary antibodies against α-SMA (clone 1A4), anti-β-actin-HRP (#A5228 and #A3854, respectively; Sigma-Aldrich), and anti-COL1A1 (#AB765P, Chemicon) were used.
Immunohistochemical (IHC) staining
Formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded tissues, from HFCD Balb/c (n = 5) or HFCD CD1d−/− (n = 4) male mice, were sliced into 4-µm sections. Following deparaffinization with xylene and decreasing concentrations of ethanol, antigen retrieval was performed with 10 mM citrate buffer (pH 6) at 100°C for 15 min. Then, endogenous peroxidase was blocked using 3% H2O2 in methanol and non-specific binding sites were blocked using 10% normal goat serum (#50197Z; ThermoFisher Scientific, Waltham, MA, USA). Slices were incubated overnight with unconjugated primary antibodies against MPO (#ab9535; Abcam, Cambridge, MA, USA) or F4/80 (#70076; Cell Signaling Technology, Danvers, MA, USA), 45 min with a biotinylated anti-rabbit IgG antibody (sc-2491, Santa Cruz Biotechnology, Santa Cruz, CA, USA) and 30 min with an ABC peroxidase complex (#32020, ThermoFisher Scientific). Finally, antigens were stained with DAB-peroxide buffer and tissue was counter-stained with hematoxylin and mounted with Aquatex (Merck Millipore, Burlington, MA). Images were visualized with a Nikon (Tokyo, Japan) Eclipse E-1000 microscope equipped with an Olympus (Tokyo, Japan) DP72 camera.
Flow cytometry: preparation of cell suspension and antibodies
Mice were anesthetized with pentobarbital (50mg/kg, i.p.), the ventral midline abdomen and peritoneal wall opened to expose the liver, portal and cava veins. 100 ul of heparin (stock 1000U/mL in PBS + 10mM EDTA) were carefully injected in the inferior cava vein to avoid coagulation, a 24G catheter was placed and ligated into the portal vein and another 18G catheter in the inferior cava. Sutures were placed around the superior vena cava and close to the kidneys. The livers were perfused with 100 mL PBS + 10mM EDTA), the sutures closed, at a flow of 4ml/min, and the flow out was collected in a 100mL container placed under the 18G catheter. Afterwards, it was centrifuged at 600g, 5 min, the pellet resuspended in 1mL ACK lysis buffer (ThermoFisher #A1049201) for 5min at RT. Then, diluted with 20ml PBS + 2%FBS + 0.05%NaN3, and centrifuge again at 600g, 5 min. The clean pellet was then resuspended in PBS and cells were counted in hematocytometer. The cellular concentration was adjusted to approximately 1 × 106 cells per condition in 100µl wash buffer (PBS + 2% FBS + 0.05% NaN3) including the antibodies used. Samples were incubated in the dark, 30 min, 4ºC, and afterwards washed in wash buffer (200µl), centrifuged at 600g, 5min, and resuspended in 100µl PBS. The antibodies used were: mouse CD3 FITC Conjugate #HM3401 (Invitrogen), mouse CD4 APC Conjugate #MCD0405 (Invitrogen), rat Anti-Mouse CD19-PE/CY5.5 #1575-16 (Southern Biotech), rat Anti-Mouse Ly6G/GR-1-PE/CY7 #1900–17 (Southern Biotech), Alexa Fluor 700 Rat Anti-Mouse CD45 #560510 (BD Pharmingen), PerCP-Cy 5.5 Rat Anti-CD11b #550993 (BD Pharmingen), BV605 Rat Anti-Mouse Ly-6C #563011 (BD Horizon), anti-Mouse CD8a PE-Cy7 #60–0081-U025 (TONBO Biosciences), BUV395 Rat Anti-Mouse F4/80 #565614 (BD Horizon), mouse CD1d PBS-57 (an analogue of α-GalCer) (PE-Labeled Tetramer) and mouse CD1d Unloaded (PE-Labeled Tetramer) (NIH Tetramer Core Facility at Emory University). Cells were analyzed on a BD LSRFortessaSORP cytometer analyser and analyzed with free software using https://floreada.io/↗. Dead cells were excluded from analysis by staining with Live/Dead dye (LIVE/DEAD Fixable Violet Dead Cell Stain Kit #L23105↗ (ThermoFisher Scientific) (n = 4 or 5).
Statistical analysis
Results were analyzed using a 3-way ANOVA, using sex, CD1d-genotype and diet as independent factors. Afterwards, Sidak’s multiple comparison test was run between groups differing by only one of the mentioned factors. All statistical analysis was performed using GraphPad Prism 8 (GraphPad Software, San Diego, CA). Results are expressed as mean ± SEM, a p-value < 0.05 was considered significant. In addition, when needed, to test whether mean difference between two groups is statistically significant the Student’s t test was used, and the resulting p value expressed numerically in the figure.
Results
HFCD induced steatohepatitis in male and female mice, being more severe in CD1dmale mice −/−
HFCD feeding induces more severe steatohepatitis in males than females, especially in CD1dmice.Representative H&E staining of liver sections, scale bar: 100 µm;serum levels of transaminases, ALT and AST;intrahepatic triglycerides (TG) and cholesterol (Chol) levels;liver-to-body ratio; andNAS score were determined in CHOW, 6 weeks HFCD-fed Balb/c (WT) and CD1d-KO mice, males or females.= 8–10. Data are expressed as mean ± SEM, *< 0.05, **< 0.005, ***< 0.001 vs. corresponding HFCD-groups −/− a b c d e n p p p
Liver fibrosis is aggravated in male CD1dmice fed HFCD −/−
Imaging quantification of the positive areas for collagen in all HFCD mice, Fig. 2b, indicated similar degree of fibrosis in both sexes, in one hand, and corroborated that male CD1d-/- mice had significantly higher fibrosis than any other group. These results were additionally validated by determining hydroxyproline concentration in hepatic tissue, as shown in Fig. 2c.
Of note, mRNA expression of α-SMA and COL1A, Fig. 3c, revealed that male livers, Balb/c or CD1d−/−, displayed enhanced levels of these fibrosis markers than female mice, indicative of more active fibrosis in males than females.
Liver fibrosis is exacerbated in male CD1dmice fed HFCD.representative Sirius red staining of liver sections, scale bar: 100 µm;Sirius red quantification by ImageJ,= 8–10; andhydroxyproline concentration were determined in hepatic tissue in CHOW or 6 weeks HFCD-fed Balb/c (WT) or CD1d-KO mice, males or females,= 8–10. Data are expressed as mean ± SEM, *< 0.05, **< 0.005, ***< 0.001 vs. corresponding HFCD-groups −/− a b c n n p p p
α-SMA and COL1A1 expression in hepatic tissue.Hepatic αSMA, andCOL1A1 protein expression were determined in hepatic tissue of 6 weeks fed CHOW or HFCD in Balb/c (WT) or CD1d-KO mice, males or females, by immunoblot,= 1–2 for chow groups,= 3 for HFCD groups.mRNA expression of αSMA and COL1A1,= 5. Data are expressed as mean ± SEM, *< 0.05, **< 0.005, ***< 0.001 vs. corresponding HFCD-groups a b c n n n p p p
Inflammatory gene expression is enhanced in male mice fed HFCD
While in females HFCD induced also an inflammatory response, although to a lesser extent than in male mice, especial mention should be given to IL6 (Fig. 4d) which displayed a higher increase in male HFCD-fed CD1d−/− mice, correlating with disease severity, but was not increased in HFCD-female mice compared to the female chow group.
Inflammatory gene expression in hepatic tissue.TNF;CCL2;IL1β; orIL6 mRNA expression were determined by qPCR in hepatic tissue of Chow or 6 weeks HFCD-fed Balb/c (WT) or CD1d-KO mice, males or females. Data are expressed as mean ± SEM,= 5, *< 0.05, **< 0.005, ***< 0.001 vs. corresponding HFCD-groups a b c d n p p p
NKT-cell deficiency aggravated pro-inflammatory effects of HFCD showing sex distinctive Th1/Th2 polarization
Moreover, IL12 and IL10 mRNA expression (Fig. 5c, d) were enhanced after steatohepatitis induction, particularly in males. Of note, IL10, cytokine with anti-inflammatory and immunosuppressive properties, was significantly decreased in HFCD CD1d−/− male mice as compared to HFCD Balb/c mice. Finally, macrophage marker F4/80 (Fig. 5e), strongly increased by HFCD in male mice compared to females, but was not affected by NKT deficiency.
Innate immune gene expression in hepatic tissue.IFNγ;IL4;IL12;IL10; orF4/80 mRNA expression were determined by qPCR in hepatic tissue of Chow or 6 weeks HFCD-fed Balb/c (WT) or CD1d-KO mice, males or females. Data are expressed and mean ± SEM,= 5, *< 0.05, **< 0.005, ***< 0.001 vs. corresponding HFCD-group a b c d e n p p p
Lack of NKT cells in male mice results in exacerbated neutrophilic and inflammatory macrophages infiltration during steatohepatitis
Given the significant changes in inflammatory and anti-inflammatory gene expression detected after HFCD feeding not only between males and females, but also due to NKT cells deficiency, and to better illustrate how NKTs shape the inflammatory milieu, we performed flow cytometry in the livers to analyze the T cell population and other important immune populations that could result affected by NKTs, mainly macrophages and neutrophils.
We next analyzed total T cells (CD45+CD3+) in liver observing a significant increase in this population in MASH both in male and female mice (Fig. 6b). However, there was almost no increase in total T cells in CD1d−/− male mice with steatohepatitis. While we cannot rule out that part of this lack of increase could be due to the absence of NKT-cell expansion characteristic of the mouse model, the magnitude of the numbers indicates that CD1d deficiency compromises also T cell proliferation during steatohepatitis in male mice. Again, the reduction in T cell numbers in CD1d−/− male mice during diet-induced steatohepatitis was more modest in their female counterparts.
When analyzing the T cell subsets: CD4+ T cells and CD8+ T cells, or the ratio CD8+/CD4+, in MASH livers, as expected, there was a decrease in CD4+ T cells in favor of CD8+ cells, as clearly observed in Fig. 6c–e indicative of the chronic inflammatory state in male and female MASH livers. Nevertheless, despite the difference in T cells observed in Fig. 6b, and differences in CD4+ and CD8+ T cells induced by diet in T cells subsets, we did not observe major differences in T cells subsets due to genotype or sex (Fig. 6c–e). The only exception was the reduced presence of CD4+ T cells in the basal state in female CD1d−/− livers as compared to Balb/c females (Fig. 6c).
Macrophage levels and phenotype were also analyzed (Fig. 7c–f). Female mice displayed reduced levels of macrophages than male mice in the basal (CHOW) state, Fig. 7c, regardless of the genotype, that significantly increased upon MASH induction. In contrast, in males, CD1d−/− mice had lower levels of macrophages than Balb/c males in the basal state, indicating that CD1d deficiency altered macrophage presence in the liver. In both males and females, MASH induction shifted the population from Ly6Clo predominant in the basal state, to MASH-predominant Ly6Chi. Interestingly, the ratio Ly6Chi to Ly6Clo was higher in males than in females with MASH, Fig. 7f, denoting again the lower inflammatory state present in females.
Finally, in CD1d−/− male mice with MASH the ratio Ly6Chi to Ly6Clo was significantly higher than in HFCD-fed Balb/c male mice, consistent with the enhanced inflammatory state observed in these mice by qPCR. Moreover, given the enhanced presence of inflammatory macrophages in males, we also evaluated the presence of hepatic crown-like structures, a histological feature of MASH in mice and humans characterized by the presence of macrophage aggregates surrounding hepatocytes with large lipid droplets [49] observing its presence in Balb/c and CD1d−/− male mice after HFCD (Fig. 7g).
T cell subsets in liver after HFCD in males and females of Balb/c or CD1d-/- mice. The hepatic levels oftype I NKT cells (CD3e, Tet-CD1d-PBS-57);% T cells (CD3 +);CD4T cells;CD8T cells; orratio CD8/CD4T cells were determined by flow cytometry in livers of Chow or 6 weeks HFCD-fed Balb/c (WT) or CD1d-KO mice, males or females. Data are expressed as mean ± SEM,= 4–5, *< 0.05, **< 0.005, ***< 0.001 vs. corresponding compared group. To compare the means between two particular groups the Student’stest will be used, and the resulting p value expressed numerically in the figure a b c d e + + + + + + n p p p t
Neutrophils and macrophage subsets in liver in males and females of Balb/c or CD1dmice after Chow or HFCD feeding.Neutrophils (Ly6G);MPO immunohistochemistry (20X), red arrows point to MPO-positive cells in male tissue from sections from 6 weeks HFCD-fed Balb/c (WT) or CD1d-KO mice;macrophages (F4/80, CD11b);Ly6Cmacrophages;Ly6Cmacrophage; orratio Ly6C/Ly6Cmacrophages were determined by flow cytometry in hepatic tissue of Chow or 6 weeks HFCD-fed Balb/c (WT) or CD1d-KO mice, males or females;representative F4/80 immunohistochemistry (20x), in 6 weeks HFCD-fed Balb/c (WT) or HFCD-fed CD1d-KO male mice, red arrows indicated hepatic crown-like structures in male tissue sections from HFCD Balb/c (WT) or CD1d-KO mice. Data are expressed as mean ± SEM,= 4–5, *< 0.05, **< 0.005, ***< 0.001 vs. corresponding compared group. To compare the means between two particular groups the Student’stest will be used, and the resulting p value expressed numerically in the figure −/− + + + hi lo hi lo a b c d e f g n p p p t
Discussion
To sum up, our results reveal that the consumption of HFCD diet induces significant liver damage, inflammation and fibrosis in Balb/c mice, with a more pronounced impact in CD1d−/− male mice lacking NKT cells. Moreover, we detected enhanced levels of hepatic iNKT cells in Balb/c mice during HFCD feeding, in both sexes, despite observing that basal hepatic iNKT cell levels in female Balb/c mice were significantly lower than those in Balb/c male. Our model replicates the sex-related differences in disease severity observed in human MASH, as Balb/c female mice displayed moderated MASH features than males. In female Balb/c mice fed HFCD there was decreased presence of inflammatory macrophages (Ly6Chi) while displaying a higher presence of reparative macrophages (Ly6Clo) as compared to males. Moreover, we observed that IFN-γ and IL-4, two cytokines typically released by NKT cells in response to diverse stimuli, demonstrate distinct gene expression patterns in male and female mice. In all, our data indicate that NKT cells contribute to protect against the development of liver fibrosis and an exacerbated inflammatory response during MASH in Balb/c mice.
The activation of hepatic NKTs seems to contribute both to the onset [34–38, 50, 51] and to the inhibition [39] of inflammation and fibrosis, depending on the etiology of the liver disease being evaluated. In the context of steatohepatitis, several studies with experimental murine models indicate both the accumulation of NKTs in the liver correlating with disease progression [38] and a pathogenic role of these NKTs in its development [33, 37, 52]. However, the majority of these studies share a commonality in using the C57BL/6 mouse strain. In this regard, the severity of steatohepatitis has been demonstrated to change depending on the background of the strain employed [40]. Another pivotal aspect is the lack or sex-perspective in many of these studies, even though the disease displays differential prevalence and severity based on gender in patients [53–55].
Given these considerations, we analyzed the sexual dimorphism in an experimental MASH model induced by a HFCD diet in Balb/c strain animals, along with exploring the role of NKTs within this context. The choice of CD1d−/− mice for this study was made due to their deficiency not only in type I NKT cells (iNKTs), as in prior investigations [39], but also in type II NKT cells, which are less explored in mouse models but more prevalent than iNKTs in the human liver [12].
Our findings reveal that the consumption of an HFCD diet induces significant liver damage in mice, particularly in CD1d−/− animals, with a more pronounced impact in males than females, aligning with the elevated fibrosis and inflammation observed in HFCD-fed male CD1d−/− mice. Thus, our results suggest that the absence of NKTs exacerbates liver damage induced by the MASH diet, irrespective of gender. In line with our observations, Miyagi et al. [39] reported heightened liver damage in Balb/c male mice lacking iNKTs (Jα18−/−) and fed a high-fat diet, compared to control mice, within just 5 weeks of dietary intervention. Notably, their study was conducted solely in male mice devoid of type I NKT cells (iNKTs), whereas our investigation explores into the contributions of both type I and type II NKT cells (via CD1d knockout) in both male and female mice. Considering the more prominent presence of type II NKT cells in human livers, as opposed to type I, our utilization of CD1d-knockout mice in this study potentially holds greater relevance to human pathology.
In our model, we observed enhanced levels of hepatic iNKT cells during HFCD feeding, in males and females. Unfortunately, studies investigating NKT cells and their association with MASLD in humans are very limited. Nevertheless, certain research has reported an increase in CD3 + CD56 + cells (NKTs) in the livers of MASLD/MASH patients, primarily through immunohistochemical analysis [38, 56, 57]. Of interest, some of these studies indicate an increase in hepatic NKT cell presence as MASLD progresses to MASH [38, 56]. However, in-depth studies utilizing CD1d tetramers for characterizing NKT presence in MASLD/MASH, and specifically distinguishing gender-related differences, are currently lacking and we hope that our data could fuel such investigations.
The discovery that hepatic iNKT cell levels were markedly lower in female Balb/c mice compared to their male counterparts was entirely unforeseen. In other mouse strains, like C57Bl6/J, hepatic NKT cell levels have been reported to exhibit relatively similar proportions between sexes [58]. However, there is a lack of comparative studies scrutinizing male and female hepatic NKT cells, particularly within the Balb/c strain. Pioneering studies by the Godfrey and [59] and Kronenberg labs [60] have documented hepatic iNKT cell levels in male Balb/c mice and other strains, revealing hepatic iNKT cell percentages around 11% to 22% (respectively, of total T cells), which aligns with our findings in males.
Interestingly, a separate study conducted in Balb/c mice, using the same methodology [59, 60], yielded unexpected results by revealing lower hepatic iNKT cell levels [61], constituting approximately 4% of total T cells. It is worth noting that this study solely focused on female Balb/c mice. Remarkably, the levels found in hepatic iNKT cells in females Balb/c mice are similar to the levels reported in here. Thus, to the best of our knowledge, our report is the first study comparing simultaneously hepatic iNKT cells in male and female mice of the Balb/c strain.
However, the absence of an assessment of type II NKT cell levels is a limitation of our study. Despite this limitation, the lower level of hepatic iNKT cells in females found in our study is consistent with the fact that male mice are more profoundly affected than females during steatohepatitis by the lack of NKT cells, and to the observation that this has a major impact in other inflammatory cell types.
When assessing liver/body weight ratios, HFCD diet-fed mice displayed increased values in both sexes, indicative of the accumulation of intrahepatic lipids and compatible with the enhanced accumulation of triglycerides observed after HFCD, due in one hand to the high fat diet composition of the diet (60%), and to the lack of choline that hampers VLDL exports from the liver [62]. Moreover, the triglyceride accumulation and liver/body ratio were superior in male mice.
Of interest, IFN-γ and IL-4, two cytokines with apparently opposite functions (pro-inflammatory and pro-fibrotic, respectively) and typically released by NKT cells in response to diverse stimuli, demonstrate distinct gene expression patterns in male and female mice. In females, the CD1d−/− groups displayed an elevation in liver gene expression for both cytokines, regardless of the diet, possibly indicating a compensatory mechanism set off by other liver IFN-γ-producing cells (like NK cells, MAIT, or γδ T cells) due to the absence of NKT cells. Conversely, in males, IL-4 gene expression levels remained unchanged across different groups, while IFN-γ expression notably surged in the HFCD Balb/c group (in comparison to the HFCD CD1d−/− group and the control group). This increase underscores the role of NKT cells in IFN-γ secretion and the protection against diet-induced steatohepatitis in male mice, since the HFCD CD1d−/− group exhibited a greater inflammatory response even in the absence of the IFN-γ generated by NKTs.
In agreement with previous studies in male Balb/c mice [39], we observe that NKT cells contribute to protect the liver against the development of liver fibrosis and an exacerbated inflammatory response during MASH. In contrast, investigations on the C57BL/6 mouse strain reveal a different facet, implicating NKT cells in a pro-fibrotic and pro-inflammatory capacity in diet-induced steatohepatitis [35–38]. Deciphering the cause of this discrepancy, one must consider the polarization of the immune system. While the C57BL/6 mice tend towards a Th1-polarized response, Balb/c mice lean towards a Th2-immune response [63]. Importantly the differential behavior of NKT cells in the Balb/c and C57Bl6/J strains seems not to be specific for MASH. A systematic study performed in the context of malaria infection reported that CD1d-restricted natural killer T (NKT) cells can contribute to either protection against or susceptibility to malaria depending on the host genetic background [64]. Investigating the role of CD1d-restricted NKT cells in terms of mortality percentage and infection-associated histological markers, on the Balb/c background NKT cells seem protective, while on the C57BL6 background were not, since CD1d−/− C57BL6 mice experienced partial protection against disease [64]. These data, consistent with our results, support that the behavior of NKT cells depends on the immune makeup of the strain which has been proved critical in determining the outcome in diseases such as obesity and diabetes [65].
In concordance with human pathology, our diet-induced steatohepatitis rodent model mimics sex-related differences in disease severity. Specifically, male subjects exhibited heightened liver damage, hepatic inflammation, and more pronounced steatosis, consistent with previous research [44, 45]. Elevated expression of fibrogenic genes (α-SMA, COL1A1) in males further accentuated this disparity. Similarly, in humans, it is acknowledged that women excel in resolving inflammation and limiting chronic inflammation more effectively than men [66]. In addition, the established influence of estrogens in shaping the female immune system and safeguarding against MASH should be noted [41–43]. Remarkably, CD1d−/− animals displayed amplified fibrosis in males compared to females, indicating a more active fibrotic process. Our cytometry data support this assessment by identifying a higher proportion of inflammatory macrophages (Ly6Chi/Ly6Clo) in HFCD CD1d−/− male mice, with potential involvement in driving fibrosis [67].
Furthermore, flow cytometry data underscore marked distinctions between females and males. Specifically, females exhibit fewer inflammatory macrophages (Ly6Chi), even in their basal state, while displaying a higher presence of reparative macrophages (Ly6Clo). In our model, female mice demonstrate subtle NKT-dependent protection against HFCD consumption, maybe due to their relatively lower levels of iNKT cells. Changes in liver damage (ALT levels) and the immune pattern, displaying increases levels of neutrophils and a growing proportion of inflammatory macrophages, suggest that over an extended period NKT-induced protection might assume a significant role in female mice confronted with heightened damage and inflammation.
Consistent with this view, our preliminary data from a liver cancer model (Cuño-Gómiz et al., unpublished results), involving diethyl nitrosamine (DEN) injection in combination with HFCD diet confirms this notion. In fact, our initial findings reveal a significant surge in alpha-fetoprotein (AFP), a biomarker for hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC), in CD1d-deficient female mice serum compared to Balb/c female mice following 8 months of treatment with DEN + HFCD (9.134 ± 1.957* µg/ml of AFP in CD1d-KO female mice, n = 10, vs. 3.602 ± 0.641 µg/ml of AFP in Balb/c female mice, n = 7, p < 0.01). While these observations are promising, further investigation is essential considering the complex interplay of factors involved. Reliable animal models that accurately emulate human pathology are necessary for advancing scientific understanding.
Perspectives and significance
Our findings imply that hepatic NKT cells play a role in mitigating inflammation during MASH progression in male Balb/c mice by modulating the immune environment towards a more favorable state for inflammation control. In female Balb/c mice, the inherent protection maybe conferred by estrogens and the female immune response appears effective in managing early MASH with minor influence from NKT cells. In this sense, our results may provide a broader perspective on the sex-dependent influence of NKT cells in other inflammatory diseases, beyond its protective role in MASH or in liver tumorigenesis.
Supplementary Information
Additional file 1. HFCD feeding induces more severe steatohepatitis in males than females, especially in CD1d−/− mice. a Representative H&E staining of liver sections, scale bar: 100 μm; b body weight; and c liver weight of 6 weeks HFCD-fed Balb/c (WT) and CD1d-KO mice, males or females. n = 8–10. Data are expressed as mean ± SEM, *p < 0.05, **p < 0.005, ***p < 0.001 vs. corresponding HFCD-groups.