What this is
- The study develops a , UniShrimpChip, to analyze gene expression in testicular development of the black tiger shrimp (Penaeus monodon).
- It compares gene expression levels between wild broodstock and domesticated shrimp of varying ages.
- The findings reveal distinct transcriptomic differences that may influence reproductive maturation.
Essence
- UniShrimpChip reveals significant differences in gene expression between wild and domesticated black tiger shrimp, particularly regarding reproductive maturation. Notably, specific subunits of the gene family show varying expression levels, suggesting their potential role in reproduction.
Key takeaways
- Distinct gene expression patterns were observed between wild and domesticated shrimp. Wild broodstock exhibited higher expression levels of certain genes linked to reproductive success compared to domesticated shrimp.
- The study identified 1,439 differentially expressed transcripts, with 237 genes higher and 251 genes lower in domesticated shrimp compared to wild ones. This indicates a potential impact of domestication on reproductive gene expression.
- The expression levels of subunits CSN5 and CSN6 were significantly lower in 18-month-old domesticated shrimp, suggesting that optimal mating age may be before 18 months for better reproductive outcomes.
Caveats
- The study's findings are based on microarray data, which may not capture all nuances of gene expression. Further validation through additional methods is necessary.
- The relationship between gene expression and reproductive performance remains to be fully elucidated, requiring more in-depth functional studies.
Definitions
- cDNA microarray: A laboratory tool used to detect the expression of thousands of genes simultaneously by hybridizing cDNA to DNA probes on a chip.
- COP9 signalosome: A protein complex involved in regulating various cellular processes, including development and differentiation, by controlling protein degradation.
AI simplified
Background
Even though Thailand was a leading producer of cultured black tiger shrimp (, generating at least 200,000 metric tons with an income of over 2 billion USD annually in the nineties [], the shrimp industry has deteriorated due to widespread disease, slow growth rate, and low quality broodstock. Penaeus monodon) 1
The reproductive maturation of both males and females of penaeid shrimp are poorly understood [], and the males have been studied even less than in the females []. Reduced degrees of maturation are usually observed in the captive brooders compared to the wild brooders. For instance, when mated with wild males, the wild females gave higher egg production and % fertilized eggs than the pond-reared females. Similarly, when mated with wild females, the wild males gave higher % fertilized eggs and % nauplii than the pond-reared males []. In females, the low degrees of reproductive maturation in captivity can be relieved by unilateral eyestalk ablation technique that can induce ovarian development and ovulation []. However, the technique does not affect the male reproductive maturation []. Moreover, there has not been any report on optimal age of the males for mating though a previous study insuggested that age positively correlated to the gonad weight, spermatophore weight, sperm count and % normal sperm []. Therefore, it is important to understand fundamental differences in molecular mechanisms between domesticated and wild-caught male broodstock in order to improve farming conditions and sustain the aquaculture of this species. 2 3 4 2 5 6 P. monodon
Various efforts have been made to study the fundamental mechanism of male reproduction in this species. Leelatanawit et al. constructed subtractive cDNA libraries ofovaries and testes to identify gender-specific transcripts []. Unfortunately, almost all of the preferentially expressed ESTs in thetestis were unknown transcripts (96.7%). A search for genes differentially expressed in testes was continued by constructing conventional and subtractive EST libraries from testis ofto identify several reproduction-related genes such as(),(),() and[,]. Recently, more testis ESTs (4,803 ESTs) were sequenced and analyzed to indentify more testis-relevant genes in this organism []. These previous studies started to shed some light onto potential genes involved in testicular development. Yet, further investigation is needed to understand this process in. P. monodon P. monodon P. monodon PMTST1 P. monodon testis-specific transcript 1 spermatogonial stem-cell renewal factor, transformer 2 Tra-2 progestin receptor membrane component 1 PGRMC1 Dmc1 P. monodon 7 8 9 10
Microarray technology can simultaneously monitor gene expression levels of a large number of genes []. Previously, we have constructed a reproduction-specific cDNA microarray (Array) to study different stages of the ovarian development of the black tiger shrimp and able to identify many important reproduction-related genes exhibiting a differential expression profile during its ovarian development such as() []. 11 12 Repro nuclear autoantigenic sperm protein NASP GTS
In this study, we have constructed another version of microarray containing unigenes to include more genes on the array for more diverse studies of this species. This is the first report in the black tiger shrimp to use the microarray technique to study testicular development. The microarray results identified differentially expressed gene clusters which might be involved in differences between domesticated and wild-caught male broodstock. Some of these genes (i.e. different isoforms of()) were further characterized for their possible roles on testicular development. constitutive photomorphogenic 9 signalosome CSN
Results
Features of UniShrimpChip
A cDNA microarray, UniShrimpChip, was constructed from 5,568 sequences of the previously established 12 EST libraries [] and spotted in duplicate on each microarray slide (Figure). A total of 260 control spots include both positive (shrimp genomic DNA) and negative controls (buffer, bacteria DNA, virus DNA). The highest numbers of features on UniShrimpChip was sequences found in testis and ovary EST libraries (about 22% each) of. A total of ~70% of the features were homologues of genes with putative known functions (Figure). The features of UniShrimpChip were further categorized according to the Gene Ontology (Figure). The highest numbers of features belonged to the "biological function" (42%) followed by the "molecular function" (32%) and the "cellular components" (26%). 13 1 1 2A P. monodon

. Summary of the tissue origin for the features used on the microarray (UniShrimpChip)

. (A) Pie diagrams show the percentage distribution of sequences among the three principal GO categories: (B) molecular functions, (C) biological processes and (D) cellular components. The percentage of sequence numbers in each category was calculated from the total sequence numbers assigned in that particular category. Functional categories by Gene Ontology (GO) analysis of UniShrimpChip features
Large-Scale Gene Expression Analysis in Testis of Penaeus monodon
UniShrimpChip was used to compare gene expression profiles of testes from wild (West and East coasts of Thailand) and domesticated brooders (Cy5, Red) by using pooled testes from juveniles as a common references (Cy3, Green) (Table). From the total of the 18 microarray comparisons, the overall expression patterns of every transcript were clustered to identify relationship among the brooder types (Figure). Hierarchical cluster revealed distinct differences in expression patterns between wild and domesticated brooders. Among domesticated shrimp at different ages, the 18-month-old group was clearly clustered as a separated group from the other cluster that contained both 10- and 14-month-old shrimp; Figure. However, if only gene expression patterns of transcripts from the testis library (1,076 transcripts) were considered, the hierarchical cluster of array results was different (Figure). Although the wild shrimp (West and East) were still clustered together and distinct from the domesticated groups, the domesticated shrimp could be further divided to 3 subgroups; 18-month-old shrimp alone, 14-month-old containing a single individuals of 18-month-old and 10-month-old containing a single individual of 14-month-old shrimp. No correlation according to gonadosomatic index (GSI) and ratio of sperm sac to testis weights (SS/TT) was observed. 1 3 3A 3B
From all 5,568 features of UniShrimpChip, 3,455 transcripts were selected for further analysis as they were present in at least 14 of the 18 microarrays (~80% of all the arrays). Of these, 1,439 transcripts exhibiting expression changes > 1.5 fold in at least 9 of the 18 microarrays (50% of all the arrays) were clustered according to their expression patterns (Figure). These differentially expressed transcripts were from different EST library origins. The majority of these genes were from testis (30.4%) and heart (28.9%), whereas the remaining transcripts were from ovary (14.8%), gill (10.7%), hemocyte (9.8%), hepatopancreas (2.6%), intestine (1.0%), and others (1.7%) (Additional file: Supplemental Figure S1). 4 1
From the 1,439 differentially expressed transcripts, 237 and 251 genes were expressed higher and lower in the domesticated than the wild shrimp, respectively. Comparing the expression levels between juveniles and broodstock, the microarray results revealed 576 genes with higher expression levels in juvenile, whereas only 85 genes were expressed higher in broodstock. Hierarchical cluster analysis of these differentially expressed transcripts revealed different gene groups (Figure). Examples of selected gene groups with different expression patterns were further examined (Figure). 4 4
Besides the comparison between the wild and domesticated gene expression profiles, the differences in gene expression levels among different ages within the domesticated groups (10-, 14-, and 18-month-old brooders compared with juveniles, experiments III-V) were also observed, albeit not as distinct. From the overall expression patterns, the 18-month-old profiles seemed different from the 10- and 14-month-old groups. For instance, the expression levels of the 18-month-old domesticated samples in Cluster 3 were slightly lower than the remaining samples from the domesticated group (Figure). Interestingly, from the different gene expression groups, a gene family ofhomologs was presented in many clusters (Clusters I-III; Figure). The differential expression patterns of these gene subunits between the domesticated and wild groups raise a question whether they are involved in reproductive maturation in. 4 4 constitutive photomorphogenic 9 signalosome (CSN) P. monodon

. WBW and WBE are wild broodstock from the West and East coasts of Thailand, respectively. DB10, DB14, and DB18 are 10-, 14, and 18-month-old domesticated broodstock, respectively. GSI is a gonadosomatic index value calculated from the percentage of gonad weight by total body weight. SS/TT is a ratio of sperm sac weight to testis weight. Cluster analysis of overall gene expression patterns from wild and domesticated male broodstock (A) using all transcripts on the UniShrimpChip and (B) using only transcripts from testis ESTs

. Testis from broodstock was labeled with Cy5 fluorescent dye (red) and pooled testes from juveniles with Cy3 fluorescent dye (green). Hierarchical clustering analysis of the 1,439 transcripts present in at least 14 of the 18 microarrays and whose expression differences were greater than 1.5 fold in at least 9 of the 18 microarrays. Clusters 1-4 show examples of various patterns of differentially expressed transcripts. Transcripts in blue letters were further characterized by quantitative real-time PCR. Gene expression analysis by the UniShrimpChip comparingtranscript levels in testis of wild broodstock from the West and East coasts of Thailand (WBW and WBE, respectively), domesticated broodstock at 18, 14, and 10 months (DB-18, DB-14, and DB-10, respectively) using testes pooled from 114 juveniles (JN) as a common reference P. monodon
| Experiment | Cy3 | Cy5 |
|---|---|---|
| Gene expression levels in wild-caught broodstock | ||
| I | Juveniles(pooled,= 114)n | West-coast broodstock(individual,= 3; GSI* = 1.3, 1.0, 0.7%)n |
| II | Juveniles(pooled,= 114)n | East-coast broodstock(individual,= 3; GSI = 0.9, 0.7, 0.5%)n |
| Gene expression levels in domesticated broodstock | ||
| III | Juveniles(pooled,= 114)n | 18-months-old domesticated broodstock (individual,= 4; GSI = 0.8, 0.6, 0.6, 0.4%)n |
| IV | Juveniles(pooled,= 114)n | 14-months-old domesticated broodstock (individual,= 4; GSI = 1.0, 0.8, 0.6, 0.4)n |
| V | Juveniles (pooled,= 114)n | 10-months-old domesticated broodstock (individual,= 4; GSI = 1.0, 0.7, 0.6, 0.4)n |
Gene Expression Levels Confirmed by Reverse-transcriptase Quantitative PCR (RT-qPCR)
Expression levels of,, and,, andhomologues in testes of wild broodstock (the Andaman Sea, West and the Gulf of Thailand, East) and domesticated broodstock (18, 14, and 10 months old) were confirmed using reverse-transcriptase quantitative PCR (RT-qPCR, Figure) analysis. CSN2, 4, 5, 6 7a 8 small ubiquitin-like modifier 1(SUMO-1) zipper 5
Fivesubunits () were present in the UniShrimpChip and their gene expression levels exhibited differential patterns in the microarray results. An additional subunit of this gene family,subunit (), was just found from the recently sequenced testis cDNA library of[]; thus, the expression profiles of this subunit were included with the five subunits for RT-qPCR analysis. CSN CSN4, 5, 6, 7a and 8 CSN CSN2 P. monodon 10
The expression levels ofin the wild brooders obtained from the RT-qPCR agreed with the microarray data. The most distinct expression levels of the testes from the West coast of Thailand were significantly higher than the rest (< 0.05). With the domesticated group of different ages, the expression levels of theandwere lowest in the samples of 18-month-old domesticated group; the lower expression levels of the 18-month-old domesticated group were significant for theandtranscripts (P < 0.05). Also, agreed with the microarray results, the RT-qPCR results showed that the expression levels ofandexhibited no significant difference among the samples (P > 0.05). Moreover, among the six subunits of thegenes studied in the work,andwere expressed at much lower levels than other subunits (Figure). CSN4-6 P CSN2, CSN4, CSN5, CSN6 CSN7a CSN2 CSN5 CSN7a CSN8 CSN CSN2 CSN8 5A
Besides thegene family, two additional genes (and, representing different expression patterns were also validated by the RT-qPCR analysis. From the microarray result, thetranscript was expressed higher in the domesticated group than in the wild samples (Figure; Cluster 1). The RT-qPCR results also revealed significantly higher expression levels of this transcript in the domesticated group than in the wild brooders (P < 0.05; Figure). For, the microarray data suggested comparable expression levels in all groups (Figure, Cluster 2) which were confirmed by the RT-qPCR results that the expression levels were not significantly different (P > 0.05) in all samples tested (Figure). CSN zipper small ubiquitin-like modifier 1, SUMO-1) zipper SUMO-1 4 5B 4 5B

. Black and patterned black bars are relative expression levels of wild broodstock from the West and East coasts of Thailand, respectively. Grey, lined grey and dotted grey bars are relative expression levels of domesticated broodstock (DB) at 18-, 14-, 10-month-old, respectively. Different letters above each bar designate significant differences in expression level (P < 0.05). Reverse-transcriptase quantitative PCR results of (A)subunits, (B)and CSN zipper SUMO-1
Full-length cDNA Sequences and Phylogenetic Analysis of CSN5 and CSN6
The full-length cDNA sequence of the CSN gene family has never been reported in any crustacean. In this study, the full-length ORF of5 and6 (accession numbers areand, respectively) were successfully isolated by RACE-PCR. For the5, an ORF of 1,056 bp corresponding to 351 amino acids, with 5'UTR and 3'UTR of 199 and 459 bp (excluding the poly A tail), respectively, were identified (Figure). The predicted pand molecular weight (MW) of the deduced CSN5 protein were 5.94 and 39.74 kDa, respectively. The closest similarity of this transcript was5 of(-value = 1e-149). For the6, the full-length cDNA sequence contains an ORF of 1,101 bp corresponding to 366 amino acids with 5'UTR and 3'UTR of 80 and 239 bp (excluding the poly A tail), respectively (Figure). The predicted pand MW of the deduced PmCSN6 were 5.32 and 40.27 kDa, respectively. The closest similarity of the6 transcript wasof(-value = 1e-107). Both of the deduced PmCSN5 and PmCSN6 proteins contained a JAB/MPN domain (positions 64-201 with-value = 2.85e-50 and positions 78-212,-value = 1.68e-15, respectively; Figureand). PmCSN PmCSN PmCSN I CSN Apis mellifera E PmCSN I PmCSN CSN6 Xenopus laevis E E E HQ416699 HQ416700 6 7 6 7
A bootstrapped neighbor-joining tree indicated that vertebrateare extremely conserved across different taxa (Figure). The newly characterizedwas phylogenetically recognized as a member of invertebrate. Although it showed the closest similarity withbased on sequence similarity comparison, they are distantly related among each other phylogenetically. In addition, bothandare more differentiated from other invertebratethan that of other species. Interestingly,was phylogenetically allocated to a member of the vertebrate rather than the invertebratealong with that ofand(Figure). CSN5s PmCSN5 CSN5s Apis mellifera CSN5s PmCSN5s AmCSN5s CSN5s PmCSN6 CSN6s Strongylocentrotus purpuratus Ixodes scapularis 8 9

. Start (ATG) and stop (TAA) codons are illustrated in boldface and underlined. The deduced CSN5 protein contained a JAB/MPN (positions 64-201,value = 2.85e-50; highlighted). The full-length cDNA sequence and deduced protein sequences of(1,255 bp; ORF 1,056 bp, 351 aa) of CSN5 P. monodon E-

. Start (ATG) and stop (TAA) codons are illustrated in boldface and underlined. The deduced CSN6 protein contained a JAB/MPN (positions 78-212,value = 1.68e-15; highlighted). The full-length cDNA sequence and deduced protein sequences of(1,420 bp; ORF 1,101 bp, 366 aa) of CSN6 P. monodon E-

. Amino acid sequences of different isoforms of CSN5 from,;,;,;,),,),,),,),,),,),,), Salmo salar (,),,),,),,),,),,),,),,;,),,),,),,),,),,),,),,),,;,;,;,;,;,;,),,;,),,;,;,;,;,;,),,;,),(,),(,),(,),(,),(,),(,),,),(,),(,),(,),(,),(,)(,),(,),(,),(,),(,),(,)andJaponica Group(,) were retrieved from the GenBank and compared with that of(). A bootstrapped neighbor-joining tree illustrating relationships between CSN5 of various taxa Canis familiaris (CfCSN5-1 CfCSN5-3 CfCSN5-4 CfCSN5-5 Caenorhabditis elegans (CeCSN5 Danio rerio (DrCSN5 Xenopus (Silurana) tropicalis (XtCSN5 Xenopus laevis (XlCSN5 Rattus norvegicus (RnCSN5 Sus scrofa (SscCSN5 SsaCSN5 Oncorhynchus mykiss (OmCSN5 Acyrthosiphon pisum (ApCSN5 Gallus gallus (GgCSN5 Osmerus mordax (OmCSN5 Oryctolagus cuniculus (OcCSN5 Homo sapiens (HsCSN5a Mus musculus (MmusCSN5a MmusCSN5b Culex quinquefasciatus (CqCSN5 Ciona intestinalis (CiCSN5 Bos Taurus (BtCSN5-1 Equus caballus (EcCSN5 Ornithorhynchus anatinus (OaCSN5 Monodelphis domestica (MdCSN5 Strongylocentrotus purpuratus (SpCSN5 Pan troglodytes (PtCSN5-1 PtCSN5-2 PtCSN5-3 PtCSN5-4 PtCSN5-5 PtCSN5-6 PtCSN5-7 Apis mellifera (AmCSN5-1 AmCSN5-2 Macaca mulatta (MmulCSN5-1 MmulCSN5-2 MmulCSN5-3 MmulCSN5-4 MmulCSN5-5 MmulCSN5-6 Arabidopsis thaliana (AtCSN5a AtCSN5b Bombyx mori BmCSN5 Tribolium castaneum TcCSN5 Nasonia vitripennis NvCSN5 Pediculus humanus corporis PhCSN5 Aedes aegypti AaCSN5 Glossina morsitans morsitans GmCSN5 Drosophila melanogaster (DmeCSN5 Drosophila mojavensis DmoCSN5 Drosophila grimshawi DgCSN5 Drosophila virilis DvCSN5 Drosophila simulans DsCSN5 Drosophila ananassae DaCSN5 Drosophila yakuba DyCSN5 Drosophila erecta DeCSN5 Drosophila willistoni DwCSN5 Drosophila sechellia DsCSN5 Sumatran orangutan SoCSN5 Ixodes scapularis IsCSN5 Oryza sativa OsCSN5 Penaeus monodon PmCSN5 XP_535093 XP_859089 XP_859121 XP_859165 P91001 NP_957019 NP_989109 NP_001086291 NP_001020866 NP_001098770 ACH70627 NP_001158520 NP_001156462 NP_001034400 ACO09632 XP_002710500 EAW86931 EDL14298 EDL14299 XP_001862398 XP_002129245 XP_583747 XP_001494265 XP_001512862 XP_001368118 XP_001190460 XP_001148926 XP_001148995 XP_001149144 XP_522159 XP_001162598 XP_001162682 XP_001162723 XP_623806 XP_623836 XP_001097450 XP_001097549 XP_001097650 XP_001097759 XP_001097856 XP_001098042 Q9FVU9 Q8LAZ7 NP_001138802 XP_972769 XP_001599567 XP_002422812 XP_001649479 ADD19140 Q9XZ58 XP_001998673 XP_001990340 XP_002056387 XP_002103175 XP_001954897 XP_002097599 XP_001980192 XP_002074130 EDW44858 XP_002819198 XP_002408598 NP_001054112

. Amino acid sequences of different isoforms of CSN6 from(,),(,),(,),,),,),,),,),,),,;,;,),,),,),,),,),,),,;,),(,),(,),(,),(,),(,),(,), Aedes aegypti (,),(,),(,),(,),(,),(,),(,),(,),(,),(,),(,),(,),(,) and(,) were retrieved from the GenBank and compared with that of(). A bootstrapped neighbor-joining tree illustrating relationships between CSN6 of various taxa Mus musculus MmusCSN6 Xenopus (Silurana) tropicalis XtCSN6 Oncorhynchus mykiss OmCSN6 Anoplopoma fimbria (AfCSN6 Glossina morsitans morsitans (GmCSN6 Ixodes scapularis (IsCSN6 Bos Taurus (BtCSN6 Pongo abelii (PaCSN6 Canis familiaris (CfCSN6-1 CfCSN6-2 CfCSN6-3 Culex quinquefasciatus (CqCSN6 Equus caballus (EcCSN6 Apis mellifera (AmCSN6 Macaca mulatta (MmulCSN6 Sus scrofa (SscCSN6 Homo sapiens (HsCSN6a HsCSN6b Xenopus laevis XlCSN6 Danio rerio DrCSN6 Salmo salar SsaCSN6 Oryctolagus cuniculus OcCSN6 Rattus norvegicus RnCSN6 Nasonia vitripennis NvCSN6 AaCSN6 Pediculus humanus corporis PhCSN6 Strongylocentrotus purpuratus SpCSN6 Tetraodon nigroviridis TnCSN6 Acyrthosiphon pisum ApCSN6 Drosophila melanogaster DmeCSN6 Drosophila ananassae DaCSN6 Drosophila mojavensis DmoCSN6 Drosophila sechellia DsCSN6 Drosophila yakuba DyCSN6 Drosophila virilis DvCSN6 Drosophila erecta DeCSN6 Drosophila willistoni DwCSN6 Drosophila grimshawi DgCSN6 Penaeus monodon PmCSN6 O88545 Q07G98 NP_001154117 ACQ58159 ADD19564 XP_002401875 NP_001095433 NP_001124758 XP_536866 XP_860259 XP_860298 XP_001846513 XP_001505096 XP_393678 XP_001100125 NP_001098769 EAW76601 EAW76602 NP_001084619 NP_001017768 ACM09363 XP_002721904 NP_001100599 XP_001606480 EAT33443 XP_002423731 XP_001192086 CAG08305 NP_001155680 AAF56022 XP_001955632 XP_002000957 XP_002032224 XP_002098311 XP_002053971 XP_001982256 XP_002069934 XP_001993979
Discussion
Identification and Characterization of Genes Related to Testicular Development by Microarray Analysis
A cDNA microarray, UniShrimpChip, was constructed from a total of 5,568 features from different EST libraries to cover unigenes of the black tiger shrimp. The usefulness of the UniShrimpChip was demonstrated in identification of differentially expressed genes possibly involved in different testicular development degrees in wild and domesticated malebrooders. The gene expression profiles of the wild brooders from West and East coasts of Thailand and domesticated brooders with different ages (10-, 14-, and 18-month-old) were compared to a same reference of testes pooled from 114 juvenile shrimp. Peneaus monodon P. monodon
With every gene on the array, their overall gene expression patterns indicated the wild brooders, especially if they were from the same coast, exhibited similar patterns, whereas the domesticated groups expressed distinctively from the wild groups. Although actual differences between captive and wild male brooders are not well understood and some suggested no difference in sperm quality between the two [], other early reports indicated that wild-caught brooders have higher reproductive success than in the captive counterparts [,]. Another study reported that using wild instead of captive males with either wild or domesticated females has successfully resolved a problem from low quality of offspring (B. Withyachumnarnkul, personal communication). Moreover, captive maleyields lower fertilization rates of zygotes and lower survival rates of offspring than wild male[]. The differences in the overall gene expression patterns between the wild and captive male brooders provide additional evidence to support that the difference in reproductive performance of the wild and captive broodstock might even be rooted at the transcriptomic level. 14 15 16 17 P. monodon P. monodon
Considering the hierarchical clustering of differentially expressed genes, many interesting patterns were identified. For instance, the higher expression levels in domesticated broodstock in Clusters I and II might include genes whose functions are relevant to inhibiting maturation; therefore, their high expression levels might jeopardize the maturation levels in the captive male. Consequently, these genes should be further examined as they might be potential markers pinpointing maturity levels in this animal.
Various origins of the differential expressed genes from the microarray analysis confirm the versatility of UniShrimpChip. Although it is not surprising many (~30%) of the differentially expressed transcripts came from testis library, ~70% of the differentially expressed transcripts came from the other libraries combined. The significant contributions from other tissue libraries emphasize the benefit of including genes from various organs on the arrays to provide additional coverage in gene expression study.
Validation of Gene Expression Profiles by Reverse-transcriptase Quantitative PCR (RT- qPCR)
To validate gene expression profiles of some selected transcripts belonging to different gene groups in microarray data, reverse-transcriptase quantitative PCR (RT-qPCR) was performed for,, and sixgenes. The RT-qPCR results mostly agreed with microarray results. zipper SUMO-1 CSN
The expression levels ofin different brooder groups were validated by RT-qPCR, and its relatively stable expression levels from the RT-qPCR were in accord with the microarray result.was first reported infrom the testis EST analysis and its transcript levels were found to be significantly lower in the domesticated than in the wild male brooders []. Similarly, we found the similar trend between the wild (West) and the domesticated samples, albeit not significantly different. The discrepancy between the previous and our reports could be explained by different of samples used in each study; for instance, the age of domesticated samples was not reported in the previous study. SUMO-1 SUMO-1 P. monodon 9
For z, its higher transcript levels in domesticated than in the wild group from the microarray data were confirmed by the RT-qPCR. Inencodes for a conventional non-muscle myosin heavy chain, NMMHC [,] whose functions involved in embryonic development []. The homologues ofare expressed in many species such as in chickens [,] and in humans [],. Recently, Simons et al. reported that the two NMMHC-encoding genes were expressed differently in some rat tissues such as in brain and testis []. Though an actual function in testis of this gene family has not been established, the significant differences in expression levels between the wild and domesticated groups in our study might suggest that this gene could serve as a candidate biomarker indicating different maturation levels in testicular development inbrooders. Further characterization of this gene should be pursued to understand its molecular mechanism in testicular maturation and examine its roles on lower degree of male reproduction in captive brooders. ipper Drosophila, zipper zipper P. monodon 18 19 20 21 22 23 23
Another group of genes that were investigated through the RT-qPCR analysis was thegene family. In addition to the five subunits () included in UniShrimpChip,found from the testis EST library was also examined by the RT-qPCR. Compared to their expression patterns in the UniShrimpChip, the expression patterns of the fivegenes were confirmed by the RT-qPCR results. The higher expression patterns of thein the wild, especially from the West coast, than in the domesticated groups could suggest their relevance to the better testicular development of the West wild brooders. If these genes are involved in boosting testicular development, the significantly decreased expression levels of theandtranscripts in the 18-month-old domesticated brooders from both microarray and RT-qPCR results would imply that the optimal mating age should be before 18 months. This information can be very useful for thefarming practice because an optimal age for reproductive maturity of a male brooder is not determined. In another related shrimp species, a male brooder at 12 months is considered to give highest sperm quality based on spermatophore weight, sperm count, and percentage of normal sperm []. Therefore, the decrease in expressions of potential maturation-related genes at 18 months would be an undesired condition. CSN CSN4, 5, 6, 7a, 8 CSN2 CSN CSN4-6 CSN5 CSN6 P. monodon Litopenaeus vannamei 24
TheOP9igalosome (CSN) was first found inmutants that exhibited constitutive photomorphogenesis, and hence its initial name as[]. There are eight subunits of CSN found so far but not all eight subunits were found in all organisms []. In, only sixsubunits () were found in the testis, ovary, hemocyte, and gill EST libraries[,]. The homologs ofandhave not been found in. C s n Arabidopsis thaliana constitutive photomorphogenesis 9 (COP9) P. monodon CSN CSN 2, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 CSN1 CSN3 P. monodon 25 26 10 13
Due to different names of COP9 signalosome homologues in various organisms, the names have been unified to CSN [], whose system has been adopted in our study. Although the functions of the CSN are not well understood, there are many reports linking CSN with 19S proteasome based on their evolutionary relationship sharing the same number of eight subunits []. Some studies reported that E3 ubiquitin ligases were found to interact with the CSN, suggesting that CSN may function in assembling SCF (Skp1-cullin-F-box protein) complexes by bridging E3s and the proteasome [-]. However, clear biochemical and functional evidence of these hypotheses must be further verified. 27 28 29 31
From other previous studies in various organisms, loss of certain individual CSN subunits resulted in distinct phenotypes, suggesting that individual CSN subunits may have different and independent roles. For instance, in, CSN has been implicated in oogenesis, embryogenesis, and neuronal development [-]. In rat testis,was expressed differently at different developmental stages []. These links between some of thesesubunits and testicular development in other organisms raise a question whether these genes are also involved in the male reproductive process of the black tiger shrimp. Drosophila CSN1 CSN 32 34 35
The Full-length cDNA Sequences of the CSN5 and CSN6
Among thegenes,andwere expressed significantly lower in the 18-month-old domesticated group than any other groups but higher in the wild brooders from the West coast. Therefore, their full-length cDNA sequences were further characterized by RACE-PCR. For the first time in crustacean, the full-length5 and6 cDNA sequences were successfully characterized and revealed a JAB/MPN domain in both deduced proteins. This domain is one of the signature domains of a proteasome which was first observed at the N-terminus of the yeast proteins Mpr1p and Pad1p []. Among the eight subunits of the CSN, two subunits (CSN5 and CSN6) contain the JAB/MPN domain, whereas the remaining subunits contain a PCI domain []. The CSN5 homolog, JAB1, has been found in mouse and its RNA expression in testes was noticeably abundant in mouse embryonic tissue []. In, the disruption ofgene resulted in lethality at the late larval or pupal stage, suggesting its essentiality for the development to the adult stage []. Whilehomologs in various organisms have been linked to reproduction and development, there are less numbers of reports linkingto reproduction. Instead, CSN6 was linked to apoptosis in vertebrates. When a cytoplasmic protein, Nod1, is activated as a part of apoptotic pathway to provide immune response against invading pathogens in mammals, CSN6, was cleaved from the COP9 complex, jeopardizing the complex's functions []. CSN CSN5 CSN6 CSN CSN Drosophila CSN5 CSN5 CSN6 36 37 38 34 39
Phylogenetic analysis suggests thatis evolutionarily conserved in vertebrates and most invertebrates. Nevertheless,was more differentiated from that of the other members of the Insecta (bootstrapping value of 63%). The molecular phylogeny reflects distant relationships between crustaceans and insect which is in agreement with that based on the conventional systematics. In contrast,,andwere allocated to be evolutionarily closer to the vertebrate than the invertebrate(bootstrapping values of 65, 69 and 71%, respectively). This should not be the artifact from the phylogenetic analysis but the data implied thatin these and other invertebrates may be encoded by different loci. Southern blotting should be applied to determine whetheris encoded from more than one locus. However, this is beyond the scope of our present study. CSN5 PmCSN5 P. monodon Strongylocentrotus purpuratus Ixodes scapularis CSN6s CSN6s CSN6 PmCSN6
Conclusions
In summary, UniShrimpChip, a cDNA microarray containing non-redundant sequences of theunigenes, was successfully constructed and employed in a high-throughput comparative gene expression analysis to identify genes potentially involved in the reproductive maturation differences between male brooders from the wild and domestication. Through comparison between different groups of male brooders (wild from the West and East coasts of Thailand and domesticated at 10, 14, 18 months), several genes were identified to exhibit differential expression patterns. Among those genes, the gene expression levels of, and sixgenes were further validated by RT-qPCR and the results mostly agreed with the microarray data. Because of their significant decreased transcript levels in the 18-month-old captive brooders, the full-length cDNA sequences of the twogenes,and, were further characterized to compare with other organisms. P. monodon SUMO-1, zipper CSN CSN CSN5 CSN6
This study demonstrates the usefulness of the UniShrimpChip for comparative gene expression study. For the first time, the findings reveal the possibility of thegene homologs to be involved in testicular maturation and development in the black tiger shrimp. Though further studies to pinpoint the molecular mechanisms of these genes in testicular development are required, through microarray technique, these results open a new door to narrow down candidate genes relevant to an important developmental process of this important animal. CSN
Methods
Unigene Assembly and EST Clone Selection
Unigenes and contigs of previously sequenced ESTs from theEST database (PmDB:) were analyzed using ESTplus, an integrative system for comprehensive and customized EST analysis and proteomic data matching [,]. An e-value <1e-05 was taken to indicate a significant probability of homology for both nucleotides and amino acids. The sequences were grouped in different gene ontology categories according to [] using a universal tool for annotation, visualization and analysis, Blast2GO []. These unigenes and contigs were identified for the synthesis of array probes. If the plasmids containing these sequences were available from the EST libraries, the plasmids were used as templates for probe amplification. Otherwise, gene-specific primers were designed for amplification from the first strand cDNA using Primer3 program []. Primer sequences are available on requested. P. monodon http://pmonodon.biotec.or.th↗ 40 41 42 43 44
Microarray Probe Synthesis and Fabrication
In total, 5,568 sequences were amplified by PCR method, which was carried out in a 96-well PCR plate (Axygen) using a Veriti 96 well Thermocycler (ABI). For the plasmid template, a reaction mixture contained 0.3 mM dNTPs, 1× PCR buffer, 2 mM MgCl2, 0.4 μM each of LM13-F (5'-CACGACGTTGTAAAACGACGGCCAG-3') and LM13R (5'-CATGGTCATAGCTGTTTCCTGT-3'), and 1.25 U of™ DNA Polymerase (iNtRON Biotechnology, Inc; Korea). The PCR reactions were carried out for 35 cycles at the following settings: 94°C for 30 s, 60°C for 25 s, and 72°C for 3 min. For the first strand cDNA template, The PCR reactions contained 0.4 mM dNTPs, 1× PCR buffer, 0.6 μM each gene-specific primer. Amplification was carried out for 38 cycles at the following settings: 94°C for 30 s, 57°C for 60 s, and 72°C for 3 min. Five microliters of the amplicons were electrophoretically analyzed in a 1% agarose gel prepared in 0.5× TBE buffer. The PCR products were purified using MultiScreenPCR 96 (Millipore) filtration plate method, air-dried and resuspended with 7 μl 3× SSC (Invitrogen) giving the approximate concentration of 250-500 ng/μl. The plates were covered tightly and left at 4°C overnight. The resuspended products were transferred from 96-well to 384-well print plates using a liquid handler Multi Probe II Plus Ex (PerkinElmer). The cDNA microarrays were fabricated using Nanoprint LM210 microarray spotter (ArrayIt, USA) equipped with 24 pins (946MP3) in a 4 × 6 arrangement on GAPS II amino-silane coated slides (CORNING). Each amplicon was spotted in duplicate. The printed slides were UV-crosslinked at 200 mJ of energy (GS Gene Linker UV chamber, BIO-RAD) and stored at room temperature in a dry incubator. i-Taq ®
Post-processing, Labeling, Hybridization and Analysis
The slides were post-processed to block unused surfaced using a BSA-based method as previously described []. DNase-treated RNA samples were converted to the first-strand cDNAs and labeled with aminoallyl-dUTP (aa-dUTP; Sigma) using a LabelStar Array kit (Qiagen). The aa-dUTP samples were cleaned up using a Microcon YM-30 filter (Millipore) and resuspended in 6 μl of 0.1 M sodium borate buffer (pH 8.7). The aa-dUTP cDNA was fluorescently labeled with Cy3- or Cy5- dyes (GE Healthcare) at room temperature for 1 h. The unincorporated dye was removed using a Microcon YM-30 filter and the purified probe was resuspended in 6 μl of TE. The Cy3- and Cy5- samples were mixed together in a hybridization buffer (Pronto! Microarray hybridization kit, CORNING) in 30 μL of reaction volume solution and denatured at 95°C in the dark for 3 min before applying onto the post-processed slide with a glass cover slip (22 × 32 mm, Deckglasser) for each experiment. 12
Hybridization was performed overnight (12-16 hr) in a sealed hybridization chamber (CORNING) at 42°C. The hybridized arrays were immersed into a pre-warmed washing buffer I (2× SSC and 0.1% SDS) to remove a cover slip before transferred to wash in the same buffer for 5 min with gently shaking. The arrays were washed in a washing buffer II (0.2× SSC) and a washing buffer III (0.05× SSC) for 5 min each at a room temperature with gently shaking. The arrays were then dried by centrifugation at 1,000 rpm for 5 min at room temperature (Allegra X-22 R, Beckman coulter).
The hybridized slides were scanned with GenePix 4000B (Molecular Devices, Sunnyvale, CA) and processed using GenePix Pro version 6.1. The data analysis process was described previously []. The microarray data have been deposited in NCBIs Gene Expression Omnibus with GEO accession numberat. 12 GSE21890 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/geo/↗
RNA Samples and Microarray Experiments
Total RNA was extracted fromorgans using TRI-Reagent according to manufacturer's instruction (Molecular Research Center, USA). Contaminated genomic DNA was removed by treatment with DNase I (0.15 U/μg total RNA) at 37°C for 30 min. The quality and quantity of the RNA were assessed on conventional agarose based electrophoresis and NanoDrop (ND-8000) before labeling for microarray experiments. P. monodon
For all microarray experiments in this study (Table), all Cy3 samples were from testis samples pooled from 114 individuals of 4-month-old juveniles. 1
For experiments I-II, Cy5 sample was testis from individual wild-caught male brooder from Andaman Sea (West,= 3) and Gulf of Thailand (East,= 3), respectively. n n
For experiments III-V, Cy5 sample was testis from individual domesticated brooder at different ages (18-, 14-, and 10-month-old, respectively;= 4 for each age group) from the Broodstock Multiplication Center (BMC, Burapha Univeristy, Chanthaburi province, Thailand). n
Reverse-transcriptase Quantitative PCR (RT-qPCR)
Gene-specific primers with the expected product of 120-150 bp long were designed for each transcript (Table). For construction of the standard curve of each transcript, a plasmid containing the transcript was constructed by the cloning the PCR product of the transcript into a pGEM-T easy vector and transforming the resulting vector intoJM109. The plasmid was extracted and used as the template for construction of the standard curve by 10-fold serial dilutions (10-10copy numbers). Reverse-transcriptase quantitative PCR (RT-qPCR) reactions were carried out in the strip tubes. 2 E. coli 3 9
Subsequently, RT-qPCR was used to analyzed expression levels of the transcripts in testes from juveniles (JN, 4-month-old,= 6), 10-month-old domesticated broodstock (DB) with an average gonadosomatic index (GSI calculated from the percentage of gonad weight from body weight) of 0.69 ± 0.25 (= 5), 14-month-old DB (average GSI = 0.51 ± 0.05;= 5), 18-month-old DB (average GSI = 0.53 ± 0.21;= 7), wild broodstock from Andaman Sea (West) and Gulf of Thailand (East) (average GSI = 1.14 ± 0.26 and 0.74 ± 0.12, respectively;= 5 for each group) Each reaction was performed in a 20-μl total reaction volume containing 2× iQ™ SYBRGreen Supermix (Bio-Rad), 200 ng of first strand cDNA template, and 0.2 μM of each primer. Cycling parameters were 95°C for 2.5 min; followed by 40 cycles of 95°C for 30 s, 58°C for 20 s, and 72°C for 30 s. The specificity of PCR products was confirmed by melting curve analysis performed from 55°C-95°C with a continuous fluorescent reading with every 0.5°C increment. The relative expression levels of copy number of the target gene to that of a housekeeping genein different sample groups were statistically tested by ANOVA followed by Duncan's new multiple range test or Tukey test (< 0.05). Note thathave been widely used as a housekeeping gene for gene expression profile analysis in[,-]. n n n n n EF-1α P EF-1α P. monodon ® 10 45 53
| Primer | Sequence | Size (bp) | PCR Efficiencies | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Reverse-transcriptase quantitative PCR | ||||
| CSN2 | F: 5'-GAGGATGACCTGAAGAAGGGAACA-3' | 145 | 97.1% | |
| R: 5'-TAAGTGGATGGGGAATTGCCG-3' | ||||
| CSN4 | F: 5'-GCAGGGCAGCAGCGTTCAAGA-3' | 111 | 96.2% | |
| R: 5'-ACGGATGATGCGGTCCAGGTG-3' | ||||
| CSN5 | F: 5'-CGAGGGAACGGAGACAAGAGT-3' | 148 | 97.5% | |
| R: 5'-TCCAGACAGCCAGCAACCATA-3' | ||||
| CSN6 | F: 5'-CAGTTTCTCTTCACCCTCTGGTCATA-3' | 115 | 97.6% | |
| R: 5'-GTTTGTTTTCCAATCAAGGCTCC-3' | ||||
| CSN7A | F: 5'-CTCTTTGCTTATGGTGTTTATGCTGA-3' | 128 | 99.8% | |
| R: 5'-ATACTCTTCTGCCCCGTTGCC-3' | ||||
| CSN8 | F: 5'-TGGTTGCTCGGGCATATACATC-3' | 128 | 99.0% | |
| R: 5'-AATCATTCTCGTGGGTTCGTCAT-3' | ||||
| SUMO-1 | F: 5'-AGAAGGGGAAGGGAACGAATACA-3' | 148 | 98.2% | |
| R: 5'-ACGCAGCGATGCTACAGGGA-3' | ||||
| Zipper | F: 5'-TGTGAGACAGACCTGAACGACCTT-3' | 122 | 95.4% | |
| R: 5'-ATCTACACGCATCATTGCTTGGGC-3' | ||||
| EF-1α | F: 5'-TTCCGACTCCAAGAACGACC-3' | 122 | 96.5% | |
| R: 5'-GAGCAGTGTGGCAATCAAGC-3' | ||||
| RACE-PCR | ||||
| CSN5 | 3' RACE-PCR | F: 5'-GACCTACCCAAAGGGATACAAGCCACCG-3' | ||
| CSN6 | 5' RACE-PCR | R: 5'-TGGGCTAACATCACTGAGGGCACTACCG-3' | ||
| 3' RACE-PCR | F: 5'-GTCAGCGAGGCGAGGTGGAGTTCAAT-3' | |||
Rapid Amplification of cDNA Ends-Polymerase Chain Reaction (RACE-PCR) of CSN5 and CSN6
Gene-specific primers for RACE-PCR ofandwere designed (Table). RACE-PCRs of these genes were carried out using a BD SMART RACE cDNA Amplification Kit following the protocol recommended by the manufacturer (BD Biosciences Clontech). The amplified fragment of each gene was electrophoretically analyzed, purified from an agarose gel before cloning into pGEM-T Easy vector (Promega) and sequenced (Sambrook and Russell, 2001). The full-length cDNA was assembled from the EST sequences and RACE-PCR products (hereafter calledand; accession numbers areand, respectively). The functional domain of deduced amino acids of these genes was analyzed using SMART. The pand molecular weight were estimated using ProtParam. P. monodon CSN5 CSN6 PmCSN5 PmCSN6 I 2 HQ416699 HQ416700 http://smart.embl-heidelberg.de/↗ http://www.expasy.org/tools/protparam.html↗
Phylogenetic analysis of PmCSN5 and PmCSN6
The amino acid sequences ofandproteins were phylogenetically compared with those from other species found in GenBank. Multiple alignments were carried out with ClustalW []. Bootstrapped neighbor-joining trees [] were constructed with the Seqboot, Prodist, Neighbor, and Consense routines in PHYLIPand appropriately illustrated with Treeview. P. monodon CSN5 CSN6 http://ncbi.nlm.nih.gov↗ http://evolution.gs.washington.edu/phylip.html↗ http://taxonomy.zoology.gla.ac.uk/rod/treeview.html↗ 54 55
Authors' contributions
RL performed microarray experiments, gene expression analysis experiments, and full-length characterization. UU and NK constructed cDNA microarray chips. NK and SK conceived the work. RL, UU, SK and NK wrote the manuscript. All authors read and approved this manuscript.