What this is
- This review discusses the interaction between cancer cells and the nervous system, termed the ''.
- It highlights how within this niche can influence cancer-associated pain through inflammatory mechanisms.
- The role of the immune system, particularly natural killer (NK) cells, in targeting senescent cells for potential therapeutic strategies is also emphasized.
Essence
- in the contributes to cancer-associated pain by promoting local inflammation. Targeting senescent cells with immune strategies, particularly NK cells, may offer new pain relief approaches.
Key takeaways
- Senescence in tumor and stromal cells produces inflammatory factors that enhance pain perception. Cytokines like G-CSF and IL-6 are implicated in this process.
- Natural killer (NK) cells can target senescent cells, potentially mitigating cancer-associated pain. Their role in clearing damaged neurons and modulating inflammation is crucial.
- Therapeutic strategies aimed at senescence, including senolytic approaches and NK cell enhancement, may provide innovative pain management options in cancer care.
Caveats
- The review does not provide empirical data but rather synthesizes existing knowledge, which may limit the applicability of its conclusions.
- The complexity of the tumor microenvironment and the heterogeneity of senescent cells pose challenges for developing targeted therapies.
Definitions
- cellular senescence: A state of stable cell cycle arrest accompanied by a pro-inflammatory secretome, impacting tissue homeostasis and immune response.
- innervated niche: The tumor microenvironment where cancer cells interact with nerves, influencing tumor progression and pain.
AI simplified
Introduction
The innervated niche
Even if the concept of tumor microenvironment (TME) dates back to Virchow's findings on leukocyte infiltration in solid tumors and Paget's theory of "seed and soil" for metastatic dissemination in the XIX century, only in the last decades cancer research has moved from a tumor cell-centric view based on oncogenes and tumor suppressor genes to a TME-centric perspective (1). Nowadays, the TME is recognized as a key determinant for cancer initiation, progression, and therapy response. TME, which is represented by the biological network of cancer, stromal, endothelial, and immune cells including extracellular metabolites, can be functionally subdivided into different specialized TMEs, such as immune microenvironment, hypoxic microenvironment, cancer stem cell niche and so on (2). Local interaction between nerves and cancer cells has long been observed and is now emerging as an additional peculiar TME that impinges on tumor progression, giving rise to the notion of "innervated niche" (3 –5). The innervated niche has been explored so far in the context of neural-cancer interactions focusing on tumor growth and spreading, and cancer-therapy effects on the nervous system. The implementation of new technologies has integrated in the innervated niche the neuroimmune circuits, also facing the role of immune cells in pain processes. Here, we want to add a further player in this liaison: cellular senescence (see Box 1). To this aim, after a brief introduction to the innervated niche, how tumors generate chronic pain will be summarized. Then, senescence of tumor and stromal cells as well as of neurons and glial cells will be discussed considering its inflammatory contribution to neuropathy and thus to cancer-associated pain. Finally, how the immune system participates in the processes of pain promotion and control will be outlined, and, in this frame, a specific role of NK cells in targeting senescent cells and hence in senescence-driven pain attenuation will be proposed. We believe that a better understanding of the senescent drivers of cancer pain will be instrumental in the development of novel approaches in analgesia.
Tumors can be innervated by sympathetic, parasympathetic, or sensory nerves depending on cancer types (6). Neural-cancer communication is bidirectional and can occur via electrochemical, paracrine, systemic, and cancer therapy-mediated interactions (7). Increase of sympathetic innervation in solid tumors is mostly correlated with cancer progression, while parasympathetic signals have both tumor-suppressing and tumor-promoting properties (8, 9). Tumor-promoting action of sympathetic nerves has been ascribed to the adrenergic signaling, as many cancer cells express both the β1- and β2-adrenergic receptors (ARs), and high-grade tumors show higher levels of β-ARs compared to lower-stage diseases (10 –12). Catecholamines sustain survival and proliferation of cancer cells by regulating BCL-2 level and BAD phosphorylation, factors implicated in apoptosis, and cyclin D1 expression, an important regulator of cell cycle progression (13 –16). Furthermore, catecholamines promote tumor angiogenesis by stimulating the production of the vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) (17, 18). The role of cholinergic signaling from parasympathetic innervation is less defined and opposite effects on tumor progression have been reported (19 –21).
Cancer cells actively promote tumor innervation by different mechanisms: i) axonogenesis; ii) neurogenesis; iii) reprogramming; iv) perineural invasion. During axonogenesis, neurotrophins, such as the nerve growth factor (NGF) and brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF), semaphorins (axonal guidance molecules), and ephrinB1-containing exosomes secreted by tumor cells drive neuron morphogenesis causing a local increase in nerve density (22). New neurogenesis can originate from cancer stem cells trans-differentiation or neural progenitor cells recruited from the bloodstream (23 –26). Reprogramming toward an adrenergic phenotype has been observed in tumor-associated sensory fibers in head and neck cancer (27, 28). In perineural invasion (PNI), cancer cells grow around and invade nerve fibers spreading into the perinerium space. This process provides a facilitated route for metastases and cancer-related pain (29, 30). Although PNI has variable rates in different tumors, PNI invariably correlates with poor prognosis and low survival (31, 32).
Tumor inflammatory environment is modulated by the innervated niche
A description of the multifold mechanisms by which the nervous system affects tumor growth and regulates immune response in cancer is behind the scope of the present article and we refer to other publications (33, 34). Here, we briefly describe how local inflammation and immunosuppression in the TME, two hallmarks of cancer (35), are influenced by tumor innervation. This is possible because the majority of immune cells express the β2-AR, and cells of the innate immunity express also the α1 and α2 subtypes (36). For example, catecholamines from the sympathetic nervous system influence the function of NK cells, which are lymphocytes of the innate immune system deeply involved in anti-cancer activity (see Box 2). NK cells express the D1-like and D2-like dopamine receptors (DRs), which seem to have opposite effect on cytotoxicity and interferon-γ (IFN-γ) production. The D1- and D5-DRs activate the adenylate cyclase signaling, while the D2-, D3-, and D4-DRs inhibit the adenylate cyclase signaling, thereby enhancing and attenuating the effector functions of NK cells, respectively. Also the ARs belong to the G protein-coupled receptor family. NK cells express the α1-AR, the α2-AR, and high levels of the β2-AR but not the β1-AR. Noradrenaline preferentially activates the α-ARs, while adrenaline is an effective stimulator of the β2-AR. In general, adrenaline and noradrenaline, which rapidly increase during acute stress or exercise, seem to inhibit NK cell cytotoxicity and cytokine production as well as mobilize NK cells into the peripheral blood (37).
The inflammatory reflex represents a well characterized neuroimmune circuity based on the control that the vagus nerve executes on macrophage-dependent production of tumor necrosis factor-α (TNF-α) (33). Following proinflammatory cytokine stimulation of afferent vagus nerves, vagal efferent fibers trigger adrenergic splenic nerves to release noradrenaline that in turn acts on β2-AR-expressing memory T cells in the white pulp. This way stimulated T lymphocytes produce acetylcholine which has inhibitory effect on activated macrophages expressing the α7-nicotinic acetylcholine receptor with the consequence of reducing TNF-α secretion and thus dampening inflammation (38, 39). In addition to this general mechanism, autonomic innervation directly influences the immune cells in the innervated niche. Catecholamines drive a β2-AR-mediated polarization of tumor-associated macrophages (TAMs) toward a pro-tumorigenic M2 phenotype (40, 41). Signaling from the α2- and β2-ARs reduces maturation and migration of dendritic cells to lymph nodes, impairing T cell priming (42, 43). Moreover, the β2-AR signaling mediates direct immunosuppression on tumor antigen-specific CD8 T cells by reducing their proliferation, IFN-γ production, cytolytic effector functions, and glucose metabolism (44, 45). Accordingly, inhibition of the β2-AR signaling elicits an antitumoral microenvironment characterized by an elevated IFN-γ+CD8+:Treg ratio and reduced expression of the immune checkpoint PD-1 (46).
More in general, adrenergic innervation of lymphoid organs restrains T cell egression from the lymph nodes and bone marrow through CCR7 and CXCR4, while promotes myeloid-derived suppressor cell (MDSC) expansion via the β2-ARs and myeloid cell maturation via the α-ARs in the spleen (47 –49). On the contrary, splenic parasympathetic innervation stimulates memory T cells to produce the anti-inflammatory peptide TFF2, which suppresses MDSC expansion in colorectal cancer (50). Regarding sensory fibers, it has been observed that their stimulation by melanoma tumor cells induces the expression of proinflammatory cytokines, such as CCL2, CCL3, CCL5, which speed up MDSC recruitment and tumor growth (51).
Within TME, inflammatory cytokines, in particular IL-6 and IL-8 (CXCL8), contribute to different tumor-promoting mechanisms, such as cancer cell plasticity, angiogenesis, and immunosuppression (52, 53). High levels of IL-6 and IL-8 in the innervated niche are generated upon the engagement of the β-ARs on tumor and immune cells by both noradrenaline from local sympathetic nerves and adrenaline from the blood (54).
Cancer-associated pain
Pain is a harmful sign and debilitating symptom of advanced cancer. Nociception (the physiological process of perceiving pain) starts through the activation of peripheral pain receptors (nociceptors) represented by the median diameter myelinated Aδ-fibers and small diameter unmyelinated C-fibers, whose cell bodies are located in the dorsal root ganglia (DRG) and trigeminal ganglion (55). From an evolutionary point of view, acute pain has arisen to prevent and protect from tissue damage. Conversely, pain persistence when the original cause is exhausted (chronic pain) or without a detectable cause (sine materia) represents a pathological response (maladaptive) with no protective purpose, resulting from the shift of peripheral neuroinflammation into central neuroinflammation (pain centralization). This response characterized by altered spinal cord and brain neuroplasticity is frequently observed in cancer survivors who have undergone chronic pain triggered by cancer itself or by cancer treatments.
Several mechanisms related to cancer contribute to the generation of persistent pain: i) mechanical injury to peripheral nerves induced by tumor growth (56); ii) tumor-mediated tissue acidosis (57); iii) proteolytic activity by tumor cells which leads to neuroactive peptides or direct injury to sensory and sympathetic fibers (58); iv) direct effects of factors released by cancer and stromal cells on nociceptors innervating the tumor-bearing organ (Figure 1) (59, 60). Furthermore, cancer-derived inflammation in the innervated niche strongly sensitizes nociceptive nerves leading to allodynia (pain from normally innocuous stimuli) and hyperalgesia (exaggerated response to stimuli of poor intensity) by lowering the action potential threshold or elevating the firing frequency (55).
Inflammation is the pathophysiological response of stromal, vascular, nervous, and immune cells to pathogens and tissue damage aimed at removing the noxious stimulus, promoting the healing process, and restoring tissue integrity (61). Many mediators of inflammation are known to impact on nociceptors enhancing their excitability: histamine, bradykinin, leukotrienes, and prostaglandins from mast cells; adenosine, ATP, and protons from damaged tissues; IL-1β, IL-6, TNF-α, and NGF from macrophages (62); endothelin-1 and NGF from cancer cells. These factors act directly on nociceptors by binding to specific cell surface receptors, leading also to increased sensitivity to temperature and touch (55). For instance, endothelins are detected by the endothelin-A receptor, while ATP binds to the purinergic P2X3 receptor. Activation of these receptors, as well as the sensing of the mechanical distension of sensory fibers caused by tumor growth detected by the dorsal-root acid-sensing ion channel (DRASIC), lowers the threshold of nociceptor excitability by inducing the phosphorylation of the 1.8 and/or 1.9 sodium channels (Na+ channels) (58). Chemokines are other important mediators of cancer-associated pain by recruiting immune cells (63).
Prolonged activation of peripheral fibers contributes to central sensitization through the continuous release of glutamate, substance P (SP), calcitonin-gene related peptide (CGRP), and ATP into the synaptic space, which increases the responsiveness of second order neurons expressing the N-methyl-D-aspartate receptor (NMDAR) in the spinal cord to painful stimuli (Figure 1). Central sensitization can also derive from neuroinflammation mediated by glial cell activation, or from the loss of physiological inhibition by inhibitory neurons secreting GABA and glycine, which can lead to perceive pain from non-nociceptive myelinated Aβ primary afferent fibers after innocuous mechanosensitive stimuli (mechanical allodynia) (64). Microglia cells play a pivotal role in speeding up neuroinflammation and pain centralization by triggering astrocyte activation that sensitizes first- and second-order neurons through the release of inflammatory mediators such as TNF-α (65). It should be noted that immune cells, in the effort of a homeostatic mechanism, upon corticotrophin-releasing hormone and noradrenaline stimulation can release β-endorphins which are able to attenuate pain through the engagement of the opioid receptors on sensory nerves (66). This immuno-mediated peripheral analgesia occurs only in the event of an inflammatory response, linking inflammation to both pain-gain and pain-resolution after tissue injury (65, 67). The relationship between opioids and analgesia is ambiguous as opioid-mediated neuroinflammation has emerged. Indeed, morphine and other opioids used for the attenuation of cancer-associated pain can bind the Toll-like receptor 4 accessory protein MD-2 on both microglia and astrocytes eliciting the release of nitric oxide (NO) and production of inflammatory cytokines (68 –70). This discovery accounts for the paradoxical consequences of long-lasting opioid treatment, the opioid-induced hyperalgesia (OIH), and marks neuroinflammation as the pathological and pharmacological driving mechanism of chronic pain (71 –73).
NGF, besides its role in neuronal development and consequently in the formation of the innervated niche as previously described, is involved in inflammatory hyperalgesia and cancer-associated pain. NGF binds to the neurotrophic high-affinity tyrosine kinase receptor TrkA and the low-affinity receptor p75 expressed on sensory nerves modulating the expression and function of neurotransmitters (SP and CGRP), receptors (bradykinin R), and channels (P2X3, TRPV1, ASIC3 and sodium channels) (60). The transient receptor potential vanilloid-1 (TRPV1) channel is a key component of the pain sensing system being activated by different stimuli including heat, acid, and protons. TRPV1 and the acid-sensing ion channels (ASICs) are responsible for the generation of pain in the acidic milieu that characterizes the TME and the persistent pain occurring in the bone metastases due to the massive tissue acidosis operated by osteoclastic activity (74).
Cancer patients often face chemotherapeutic treatments and several antitumor drugs, including taxanes, the vinca alkaloids, and platinum-based compounds, can induce pain and/or sensory neuropathy, the so-called chemotherapy-induced peripheral neuropathy (CIPN). The mechanisms are poorly understood as these agents have been primarily selected to target dividing cells, but in the case of microtubule-affecting drugs it is reasonable that they impair axonal transport of nerves. Increasing findings also suggest a link between CIPN and a bioenergetic imbalance in sensory neurons caused by drug-induced mitochondrial dysfunction (75). Drug-mediated injury to C and Aδ sensory fibers can lead to myalgia, tingling, cold allodynia, and burning pain in the fingers, whereas damage to Aα and Aβ fibers can result in paresthesias and dysesthesias (60).

Mechanism of pain sensing at the tumor-nociceptor interface. The unmyelinated C and thinly-myelinated Aδ fibers which represent the primary afferent sensory nerves (known as nociceptors) detect many types of noxious stimuli from tumor cells (orange box). Protons (H+) are sensed by the transient receptor potential vanilloid-1 (TRPV1) channel and the acid-sensing ion channel-3 (ASIC3), adenosine triphosphate (ATP) by the purinergic PXreceptor, endothelins by the endothelin-A receptor, whereas the dorsal-root acid-sensing ion channel (DRASIC) detects the mechanical distension of sensory fibers caused by tumor growth. Activation of nociceptors, whose cell bodies lie in the dorsal root ganglia (DRG), results in the release of neurotransmitters (pink box), such as glutamate (Glu), substance P (SP), calcitonin gene-related peptide (CGRP), and ATP, which transmit the painful signal in the spinal cord to the second order neurons expressing the N-methyl-D-aspartate receptor (NMDAR), leading to spinal cord and brain sensitization with altered pain responsiveness (gray boxes). 2 3
Senescence and cancer pain
Senescence of tumor and stromal cells
Senescence is a complex cellular program characterized by halted cell cycle and the production of a massive inflammatory secretome called SASP (76). Senescence is triggered by a variety of exogenous and endogenous stressful stimuli including telomere shortening, DNA damage by genotoxic drug, and oxidative stress (77). Cancer cells can undergo senescence due to oncogenic proliferative stress (the so-called oncogene-induced senescence or OIS) or therapy-induced insult (the the so-called therapy-induced senescence or TIS). Senescent tumor cells have both tumor-suppressing and tumor-promoting properties, depending on the context (premalignant lesion or neoplastic tissue) and TME (cold versus hot tumors) (78, 79). A further layer of complexity is provided by the induction of senescence in stromal cells (80 –83). Senescent cells are in close connection with the immune system as the SASP drives the recruitment and activation of immune cells and, in turn, immune cells recognize and target senescent cells (84, 85). Consequently, senescence deeply modifies cancer immune landscape (86). In addition, SASP factors impact on tissue homeostasis performing tissue remodeling and repair (87 –89).
Cancer cells and cells of the immune system have a continuous dialog conceptualized in the cancer immunoediting theory (90). In this scenario, senescence affects the three phases of cancer immunoediting, i.e. elimination, equilibrium, escape. For a comprehensive review on the topic see (91). Here we want to highlight how senescent cells within the innervated niche can influence cancer-associated pain.
SASP composition is extremely heterogeneous and dynamic, depending on cell type and cause of senescence (92 –94). Nevertheless, some factors are shared among the conditions and are discussed below regarding their capacity to affect cancer-evoked pain (Table 1).
Hematopoietic colony stimulating factors. Signaling generated from the granulocyte colony stimulating factor (G-CSF) and granulocyte-macrophage colony stimulating factor (GM-CSF) has been linked to pancreatic adenocarcinoma and bone cancer pain. Starting from the finding that receptors for both cytokines are expressed on pancreatic nerves in biopsy from healthy individuals and individuals with pancreatic tumors showing hypertrophic nerves, the signal transduction investigated in a mouse sarcoma model of bone tumor–induced pain has been shown to be mediated by the JAK-STAT3 pathway and to lead to the upregulation of the sodium channel NaV1.8 and the heat-activated channel TRPV1 (95). This nociceptor sensitization is accompanied by an increased release of the pain-related peptide CGRP upon nociceptive stimulation. In this way, G-CSF and GM-CSF are responsible for thermal and mechanical hyperalgesia in bone metastases (Figure 2). It should be noted that G-CSF and GM-CSF in the TME also contribute to the formation of the innervated niche by promoting both cancer cell proliferation and the branching of tumor innervating fibers (95). As G-CSF and GM-CSF are two factors of the SASP, it is expected that senescence in the TME can strongly enhance pain perception by increasing the local level of G-CSF and GM-CSF. Even if the actual levels have been reported to be regulated by the states of senescence, namely p53 status (functional or mutated), both senescent tumor cells and senescent stromal cells, such as fibroblasts, produce high amount of GM-CSF and, in some cases, of G-CSF (96, 97).
IL-6. IL-6 is a well-known SASP factor involved in autocrine and paracrine senescence. It regulates immune response and drives somatic cell reprogramming. Being a potent inflammatory cytokine, in the TME it is associated with tumorigenesis by promoting cell proliferation, migration, metastasis, angiogenesis, and immune evasion (88). Regarding pain experience, high levels of IL-6 have been observed in the DRG and spinal cord of different rat models of pathological pain where an IL-6/JAK/PI3K/TRPV1 signaling cascade has been characterized (98, 99). Administration of IL-6 provokes mechanical allodynia and thermal hyperalgesia (100). Accordingly, IL-6 knockout mice show reduced mechano-allodynia following spinal nerve lesion (101). IL-6 mediates nociceptive plasticity in part by enhancing protein translation in sensory neurons (102, 103). Patients with painful peripheral neuropathy have been shown to have elevated local levels of IL-6 and IL-8 in the affected skin (104). IL-6 has also been implicated in CIPN, even if with conflicting findings. A protective role has been reported in three animal models of paclitaxel, cisplatin and vincristine-induced neuropathies, while a reduced incidence of vincristine-induced mechanical allodynia has been found in IL-6 knockout mice (105, 106). It should be noted that different animals were used (rat versus mouse), possibly accounting for the discrepancies. Supporting a positive correlation, two clinical studies, one in women with breast cancer after chemotherapy (taxanes) and one in patients with metastatic prostate cancer who received chemotherapy (docetaxel), point to an association of high plasma levels of IL-6 and soluble IL-6 receptor with CIPN intensity (107, 108). Nevertheless, caution should be taken before drawing conclusions as different bias could affect studies involving cancer patients experiencing chronic pain. IL-6 is also involved in the processes of inflammaging, and it is now well recognized that senescent cells that accumulate in aged tissues are great producers of systemic IL-6 (109, 110). A similar role can be assumed for senescent cells in the TME. It is reasonable that senescent cell-derived IL-6 can contribute both systemically and locally to the establishment of chronic inflammation paving the way to persistent pain. However, this scenario still needs to be experimentally validated.
CCL2. CCL2 is the most representative chemokine of the SASP involved in the recruitment of monocytes/macrophages, MDSCs, and NK cells (78, 111). It has been reported that CCL2 can be produced by neurons of the DRG in rodents and that mice lacking the chemokine receptor CCR2 abrogate the development of mechanical allodynia, suggesting that CCL2 can contribute to pain generation by a direct action on neurons (an intracellular Ca2+ signaling has been observed in DRG cells treated with CCL2) or by indirect inflammatory effects mediated by the immune system (112 –114). In this context, senescent tumor cells can be a robust source of CCL2 and possibly participate in neuropathic pain (Figure 2).
IL-1. IL-1α and IL-1β are highly produced within the SASP, driving a critical function in the establishment of the senescent phenotype (115 –117). A role in pain generation can be inferred as usage of the IL-1R antagonist anakinra has been reported to reduce mechanical hyperalgesia in rat models of bone cancer pain by dampening the NMDAR signaling and the PI3K-mTOR pathway in the spinal cord and brain, respectively (118, 119).
Bioactive lipids. There is scarce information about biologically active lipids in the SASP. Production of leukotrienes has been documented in senescent fibroblasts in correlation with lung fibrosis (120). Senescent dermal and prostatic fibroblasts have been reported to secrete prostaglandin E2 due to cyclooxygenase-2 upregulation during senescence (121). Lipid biosynthetic pathways have been shown to be orchestrated in a time-dependent manner following the induction of senescence and have been suggested to be implicated in the well-known role of senescent cells in wound healing (122, 123). Eicosanoids are important effectors of inflammation, and this may represent a further mechanism through which senescent cancer and stromal cells contribute to neuroinflammation-caused pain in the innervated niche.

The complex dialog among the actors of the innervated niche: focus on how cellular senescence impacts on cancer-associated pain. 1) Senescent tumor and stromal cells secrete large amount of granulocyte colony stimulating factor (G-CSF) and granulocyte-macrophage colony stimulating factor (GM-CSF) which upregulate the expression of the sodium channel NaV1.8 and the heat-activated channel TRPV1 on primary afferent nociceptors leading to enhanced pain perception upon nociceptive stimulation. 2) Senescent cells are a robust source of inflammatory cytokines (e.g. IL-6) and chemokines (e.g. CCL2) and actively recruit immune cells, such as macrophages (MΦ) and natural killer (NK) cells, in the innervated niche. Macrophage-promoted inflammation and oxidative stress strongly sensitize nociceptive nerves leading to enhanced nociception. 3) Senescent Schwann cells contribute to the recruitment and proliferation of the macrophage population in the innervated niche by producing the macrophage colony stimulating factor (M-CSF). 4) Senescence of sensory neurons following chemotherapy can participate in the pathogenesis of chemotherapy-induced peripheral neuropathy (CIPN). 5) Senescence-attracted NK cells target both tumoral and neuronal senescent cells through NKG2D/NKG2D ligand interaction providing an immune cell-mediated mechanism of pain control.
| SASP factor | Target cell/pathway | Downstream target | Reference |
|---|---|---|---|
| G-CSF, GM-CSF | Nerve/JAK-STAT3 | ↑NaV1.8, ↑TRPV1, ↑CGRP | () [95] |
| IL-6 | DRG/JAK-PI3K | ↑TRPV1 | (,) [98] [99] |
| IL-1β | Spinal cord | ↑NMDAR | () [119] |
| M-CSF | Macrophage | ↑TRPA1 | (,) [142] [143] |
Senescence of neurons and glial cells
Being associated with stable growth arrest, cellular senescence is commonly observed in proliferating cells, but recent evidence suggests that also postmitotic and terminally differentiated cells, such as neurons and glial cells, are able to undertake a senescence program following appropriate stimuli (124, 125). The unfolded protein response (UPR) is of particular importance in postmitotic specialized cells that have limited turnover capacity. Sustained activation of the UPR due to accumulation of stress granules and protein aggregation may account for the establishment of the senescent phenotype in aged neurons (126, 127). Indeed, it has been reported in mouse models of tauopathies and postmortem specimens from brains of patients with Alzheimer's disease that the affected neurons show a canonical senescence stress response with DNA damage, aberrant cellular respiration, upregulation of cell cycle inhibitors, resistance to cell death, and inflammation mediated by NF-κB (128). Accordingly, treatment with senolytics (dasatinib plus quercetin) in mice has been shown to reduce the senescence signature (128). Senescent neurons share different phenotypic features of senescent mitotic cells, although not all, such as enhanced β-Gal activity, DNA damage, SASP (126). The use of the β-Gal activity, as well as of lipofuscin accumulation, as marker of neuronal senescence deserves particular attention due to the positive staining occurring in normal neurons throughout the lifespan, especially in cerebellar Purkinje neurons, hippocampal CA2 neurons, and a subset of cortical neurons (128, 129). Likewise primary fibroblasts, primary rat hippocampal neurons in long-term cultures display characteristics of senescence (senescence-associated β-Gal activity, p16 accumulation, and loss of lamin B1) after experiencing proteostasis failure (130). DNA damage accumulating in aging neurons is causative of a senescence-like phenotype dependent on p21 (131).
Relevant to our discussion, neuronal senescence has been described in the event of CIPN at least in mouse models. Cisplatin-induced DNA damage in DRG neurons is not associated with apoptotic cell death but with a senescence response, as revealed by lysosomal β-Gal activity and p21 upregulation, accumulation of lipofuscin granules and morphological changes (enlarged endoplasmic reticulum and larger mitochondria), lack of caspase-3 cleavage (132). Remarkably, the clearance of cisplatin-induced senescent DRG neurons by a pharmacological approach with the ABT263 compound (Navitoclax, daily intraperitoneal injections at 50 mg/kg for 2 cycles lasting 5 days with a 16-day rest period between) or genetic deletion of p16+ senescent cells (p16-3MR transgenic mouse) improves symptoms of CIPN as assessed by mechanical (von Frey test) and thermal (hot plate test) stimulation at least until three months after 2 cycles of 2.3 mg/kg cisplatin treatment (5 days on-5 days off-5 days on), suggesting that senescent neurons play a role in the pathogenesis of CIPN (133). ABT263 is an inhibitor of the anti-apoptotic proteins BCL-2 and BCL-xL and selectively targets senescent cells, which are known to upregulate anti-apoptotic factors (134). Usage of senolytics is currently under investigation for the treatment of age-associated diseases (135), leading to hypothesize also a possible application in the management of CIPN, considering that CIPN is among the most common dose-limiting adverse effects of anticancer drugs. Based on encouraging results in preclinical models, first- and second-generation senolytics have landed into clinical trials in humans. Only mild to moderate reversible adverse events have been reported so far but the effectiveness of senolytics for the tested pathologies remains scant. Regarding pain, different trials (NCT03513016, NCT04129944, NCT04210986, NCT04229225, NCT04349956, NCT04770064) aimed at targeting senescence to reduce osteoarthritis pain by using nutlin-3a (UBX0101) or fisetin are still ongoing or failed to achieve the primary endpoint of improving pain in patients with osteoarthritis of the knee (135, 136). Interestingly, a role for cellular senescence in long-term pain has been postulated to justify the male-specific sex-biased chronic pain observed in a mouse model of nerve injury, where accumulation of senescent cells in the spinal cord due to telomere shortening has been reported only in male mice (137).
Schwann cells are the glial cells of the peripheral nervous system designed to the myelination of nerves. Schwann cells not only are involved in the saltatory nerve conduction but also contribute to nerve regeneration after injury and participate in cancer-evoked pain (138). In homeostatic conditions Schwann cells uphold pain relief by protecting neurons and counteracting demyelination whereas during inflammation they secrete a variety of neurotrophic factors (NGF and BDNF) that guide axon repair but also exacerbate pain (139). In response to nerve injury, Schwann cells assume a non-myelinating phenotype with proliferation capacity aimed at regulating the Wallerian degeneration of axon and subsequent regeneration. The efficiency of this process has been linked in mice to the duration of neuropathic pain, making Schwann cells a promising target for the management of chronic pain (140, 141). Schwann cells are also involved in a pain-eliciting circuity with macrophages, demonstrated so far only mice. Macrophages display clear pro-algesic effects at the site of nerve injury by feedforwarding oxidative stress. In the context of cancer, the high levels of reactive oxygen species (ROS) that characterized the TME trigger the transient receptor potential ankyrin 1 (TRPA1) on Schwann cells that in turn release M-CSF promoting the recruitment and expansion of the macrophage population which, in a positive feedback, increases oxidative stress and overstimulates the sensory neurons thus sustaining allodynia and spontaneous pain (Figure 2) (142, 143). Additionally, Schwann cells have been reported to reciprocally interact with cells of oral squamous cell carcinoma in both mice and humans via adenosine and TNF-α, with the result of increasing the pro-nociceptive mediators IL-6 and NGF (144, 145). Considering that this role of Schwann cells in the modulation of cancer-associated pain has been correlated, at least in some circumstances, to the production of chemokines (M-CSF, TNF-α, and IL-6) which are abundant in the SASP of senescent cells, the discovery that Schwann cells can undergo senescence discloses further conceivable mechanisms of pain generation and, at the same time, new possible opportunities for the management of cancer-evoked pain (146 –148).
Role of the immune system: the cogent case of NK cells
The immune system is deeply involved in the processes of pain generation and control [for a review see (149)]. As previously outlined, immune cell-mediated neuroinflammation triggers long-term pain by sensitization of sensory fibers. Moreover, immune cell-executed cytotoxic effects directly damage nerves. On the other hand, the immune system participates in several ways to the resolution of pain (150). This seemingly contradictory role is consistent with the functions of the immune system aimed at tissue healing after removal of harmful stimuli. This goal is achieved through the plasticity of immune cells which physiologically occurs during the healing processes and can be exploited for therapeutic interventions. Regarding pain attenuation, immune cells promote analgesia by secreting both anti-inflammatory cytokines (for instance IL-10 hinders the production of TNF-α) and pro-reparative cytokines (such as IL-4) (151). IL-10 has been shown to counteract mechanical hypersensitivity after CIPN in DRG neurons treated with cisplatin (152). IL-4-mediated effects are believed to be due, at least in part, to the analgesic properties of opioids produced by M2-polarized macrophages (153). Endogenous opioid peptides and lipidic endocannabinoids supplied by immune cells, e.g. macrophages, T cells, and microglia, are other important modulators of pain (151).
Among the effector functions of immune cells in the innervated niche, cytotoxicity is critical to target cancer cells but also can lead to painful nerve injury (154). At the same time, it is now appreciated that cytotoxic immune cells, especially macrophages, neutrophils, and NK cells, contribute to the neuropathic pain resolution by clearing damaged neurons and performing phagocytic removal of debris (155). A transient inflammatory wave driven by the activation of neutrophils, macrophages, and mast cells has been associated with musculoskeletal pain resolution in humans, preventing the transition from acute to chronic pain. Accordingly, inhibition of the inflammatory response by steroids in mice has been shown to induce analgesia in the short term but to delay full recovery from pain in the long run (156).
NK cells are lymphocytes of the innate immune system with pronounced cytotoxic and immunomodulatory functions. Involvement of NK cells in the processes of neuropathic pain is proved by different lines of evidence. Activation of NK cells has been observed in both humans and mice after acute painful stimuli, electric and heat shock, respectively (157, 158). An inverse correlation between NK cell frequency in the cerebrospinal fluid and mechanical pain sensitivity has been reported in patients with neuralgia, hypothesizing a role of NK cells in preventing central sensitization (159). The analgesic effect of electroacupuncture has been correlated with the cytotoxic activity of splenic NK cells, at least in rat models of pain (160, 161).
Injury to peripheral nerve is followed by the fragmentation of the damaged axons by a neuron-intrinsic mechanism (cytoskeletal destabilization) called Wallerian degeneration that leads to the elimination of the nerve stump distal to the site of injury but preserves the cell body (162). A permissive milieu for axonal regeneration is then promoted by debris clearance and glial reactivation. First evidence of an NK cell contribution to neuronal degeneration derived from studies of mononuclear inflammatory cell infiltration in athymic nude rats, which lack T lymphocytes, after exposure to guanethidine, an adrenergic blocking agent causing the death of sympathetic neurons resident in the superior cervical ganglia (163, 164). Furthermore, DRG neurons can be killed directly by syngenic IL-2-activated NK cells, but the efficiency of the process is strictly dependent on the lack of glia cells, restricting the NK-mediated mechanism of elimination to damaged neurons (165). The seminal work by Davies and colleagues has further demonstrated that in the context of peripheral nerve injury in adult mice NK cells complement the Wallerian degeneration by targeting damaged sensory nerves, thus participating in peripheral nerve regeneration (166). In particular, they showed that the injured neurons flag themselves as damaged by expressing the NKG2D ligand RAE-1 to trigger NK cell cytotoxicity. NK cells extravasate and infiltrate the nerves by few days from injury and promote axon degeneration through granzyme-B. RAE-1 protein is anatomically restricted to the peripheral axons of injured sensory neurons either by anterogradely transport along the axon or by mRNA local translation, indicating that NK cell-neuron cytotoxic interaction occurs at the peripheral site saving the cell body. Strikingly, NK cell activity is accompanied by reduced hypersensitivity to mechanical stimulation, a surrogate marker of chronic neuropathic pain, providing a neuron-extrinsic immune cell-mediated mechanism of pain control. Abolishing NK cell activity by anti-NK cell antibody leads to reduced degenerating fibers but more remaining abnormal fibers, as assessed by myelin and axoplasm integrity, which likely conduct the painful sensory response. Indeed, it is reasonable that an efficient clearance of the injured fibers is required to avoid the aberrant sensing of pain that characterizes damaged but functionally active sensory axons or mistargeted re-innervating neurons (167, 168). It is tempting to speculate that NK cells could work as "cellular microsurgeons" to pruning the mis-wired endings of sensory nerve (169). Genetic and chemical approaches to target nociceptors and cope with acute and chronic pain have been already proposed in clinical veterinary and human pain states (e.g. with resiniferatoxin to target TRPV1-expressing small-diameter sensory neurons) (170 –172).
Senescent cells are a preferential target of NK cells (84). Not only senescent cells actively recruit NK cells by secreting a plethora of chemokines (CCL2, CCL4, CCL5, CXCL10, CX3CL1), but also sustain and trigger NK cell activity through cytokine production (IL-15, IL-18, TNF-α) and by expressing on the cell surface the ligands of the NK cell activating receptors (111, 173 –177). The stress-induced ligands of the receptors NKG2D and DNAM-1 are strongly up-regulated by tumor cells following OIS and TIS and senescent cells are targeted by NK cells through cytotoxic granule exocytosis and not death receptor signaling (178, 179). This mechanism promotes the immune surveillance of senescent cells in different physio-pathological settings and may be relevant also for the resolution of the senescence-driven pain in the innervated niche (Figure 2). Supporting this view, the capacity of NK cells to target DRG neurons via RAE-1/NKG2D interaction has been demonstrated at least in vitro (180). Transient senescence has pro-regenerative functions, and a senescence signature has been observed after peripheral nerve injury which declines over time, suggesting a reprogramming of the senescent phenotype or an immune-mediated clearance of the induced senescent cells (181). It should be noted that the capacity of senescent cells of attracting NK cells within the TME can also affect the non-senescent cell compartment, as not senescent tumor cells are targeted by NK cells, and activated T cells can become susceptible to autologous NK lysis via NKG2D/NKG2D ligand interaction through granule exocytosis leading to inflammation quenching (182). Senescent cell accumulation and gut dysbiosis are two shared features of aging and cancer (183 –185). It has been shown in different mouse models that gut microbiota modulates NK cell effector functions against tumor cells and there is also a similar functional correlation in analyses from humans (186 –189). As a speculative hypothesis, adoption of a healthy diet or a diet supplemented with probiotics and prebiotics to enhance NK cell activity could be part of a strategy to target senescent tumor cells and thus promote cancer-associated pain relief. The therapeutic opportunity of NK cells for the treatment of neuropathic pain is not new [see (169)], but the disclosure of the role of senescence in the innervated niche could extend the field of application.
Future directions
Cancer, nervous and immune systems are deeply interweaved, demanding holistic approaches for the management of cancer-associated pain. As neuropathic pain shows features of chronic neuroinflammation and the TME is characterized by an inflammatory milieu, we are in need to pinpoint the role of cellular senescence in the innervated niche and map the precise source of inflammatory factors to weigh the contribution of senescent cells. Cellular senescence is a powerful driver of inflammation but at the same time is becoming a targetable element offering an innovative line of intervention (135, 190). Approaches currently under investigation for the targeting of senescent cells in cancer and aging diseases could be explored to treat cancer-evoked pain. Senolytic strategies are attractive but still have concerns: i) on- and off-target effects have not been fully addressed; ii) senescent cell markers are not univocal leading to misleading interpretations about senescence burden and more reliable biomarkers are essential to evaluate treatment efficacy; iii) heterogeneity of senescent cells makes difficult to weigh up beneficial and detrimental effects; iv) more studies devoted to treatment regimen and frequency are needed. Along with senolytics, strategies aimed at harnessing the immune system to tackle senescent cells are promising. These include: i) adoptive transfer of boosted NK cells (191); ii) improved NK cell cytotoxicity by targeting the CD94/NKG2A inhibitory receptor using anti-NKG2A therapeutic mAb (i.e. monalizumab) (192, 193); iii) ADCC triggered by anti-senescent cell-specific mAb (i.e. anti-DDP4 mAb) (194); iv) CAR-T cells specific for senescent cells, namely CAR-T cells that recognize the surface senescence-specific marker urokinase-type plasminogen activator receptor (uPAR) or NKG2D-CAR-T cells (195, 196); v) anti-PD-L1 or anti-PD-L2 immune checkpoint inhibitory therapies that enhance the killing capacity of cytotoxic lymphocytes against PD-L1- and PD-L2-expressing senescent cells (197, 198). Among these options, therapies based on anti-NKG2D and anti-PD-L1 monoclonal antibodies are already in clinical use with a favorable safety profile (199, 200). Compared to CAR-T cells, NK cells are emerging as a valid alternative with a safer profile, opening the possibility of an "off-the shelf" therapy (201). Senescence has undoubted immune-stimulating features, but as there is now evidence that senescence can arise not only in tumor cells but also in neurons and glial cells, due to cellular stress conditions or because of anticancer therapy-mediated effects, NK cell-based therapies against senescent cells should be carefully calibrated to the right targets to avoid unwanted and unpredictable side effects. For example, NK cell-killing of senescent neuroblasts in the dentate gyrus of hippocampus has been associated to impaired neurogenesis and loss of cognitive functions. Immunotherapies have revolutionized cancer treatment, disclosing the inherent power of the immune system plasticity. This finding should encourage the exploration of immune-mediated analgesia, a new burgeoning field across cancer neuroscience and algology.