Cool white LED and CFL lamps were estimated to suppress melatonin more than warm or incandescent lighting, while very warm tunable lamps and brown-tinted lenses reduced the estimate.
Evidence
A laboratory measurement study of 52 lamps, four tunable LEDs, and eight blue-light-filtering lenses calculated , melanopic illuminance, and photopic illuminance, with cool white LED and CFL medians near 12% MSV versus lower values for warmer or incandescent sources.
Caveat
The study estimated circadian impact from light measurements and suppression values rather than measuring sleep or melatonin responses in people at home.
Simplified
Evening residential illumination possesses the capacity to impair sleep quality via the suppression of endogenous melatonin production, a process largely driven by short-wavelength (blue) light. In this investigation, we characterized the light emissions from 52 distinct examples across three common lamp technologies: light-emitting diodes (LED), incandescent, and compact fluorescent (CFL) lamps. To estimate the differential circadian impact of these sources, we determined the (MSV), melanopic illuminance, and photopic illuminance for each. Our findings reveal that "cool" white LED (median 12.3% MSV) and "cool" white CFL (12.1% MSV) lamps induce considerably greater melatonin suppression than "warm" white LED (3.6%), "warm" white CFL (2.6%), or traditional incandescent (1.5%) lamps. As potential countermeasures, we examined the efficacy of tunable Correlated Color Temperature (CCT) lamps and "blue-light-filtering" (BLF) lenses. The four tunable LED lamps demonstrated a profound ability to mitigate circadian disruption, reducing estimated melatonin suppression from 10% at a 5700 K (cool white) setting to 0.1% at 2100 K (warm white). An analysis of eight BLF lenses identified variable performance; while six had moderate impacts compared to uncorrected vision, their benefit was limited relative to standard clear lenses. Only two BLF lenses, distinguished by a "brown" tint, proved highly effective, reducing estimated suppression to below 0.3%. These results suggest that cool white CFL and LED lamps may exert a greater disruptive influence on sleep physiology than other lamp types. Conversely, tunable lamps adjusted to warm settings and "brown"-tinted BLF lenses represent beneficial strategies for ameliorating this effect. (Detailed measurement methodologies are available in a previously published study, with supplementary calculations provided separately).
Key numbers
12.1%
Cool White
Median for cool white lamps.
10% to 0.1%
Tunable Reduction
Reduction in melatonin suppression from tunable lamps at different color temperatures.
0.3%
Brown-Tinted Lens
Estimated melatonin suppression with effective brown-tinted blue-light-filtering lenses.
Full Text
We can’t show the full text here under this license.