Relationship between HIF-1 and Circadian Clock Proteins in Obstructive Sleep Apnea Patients—Preliminary Study

Obstructive sleep apnea syndrome (OSA) is a chronic condition characterized by recurrent pauses in breathing during sleep, which leads to intermittent hypoxia (IH), hypercapnia, arousals, and sleep fragmentation. Recent studies suggest that the prevalence of sleep disordered breathing drastically increased and in moderate or severe form might affect up to 50% men and 24% women [1].

One of the typical complications of sleep disordered breathing is recurrent hypoxia, which subsequently causes modifications of gene expression. The main factor responsible for oxygen metabolism homeostasis is hypoxia-inducible factor 1 (HIF-1). It is a heterodimeric complex, which consists of two subunits: α (HIF-1α) and β (HIF-1β). Both subunits belong to helix-loop-helix (bHLH)—Per/Armt/Sim (PAS) transcription factor family [2]. Subunit α is oxygen-sensitive, while the stability of the β subunit does not depend on oxygen partial pressure [2]. Recent studies have shown that HIF-1α serum protein level is chronically increased in OSA patients and is not reverted by one-night continuous positive air pressure therapy [3,4].

Circadian clocks are endogenous coordinators of the 24-h rhythm of behavioral and molecular processes in living organisms. For humans, a master clock modulating circadian rhythms is located in the suprachiasmatic nucleus of the hypothalamus and is a pacemaker of a hierarchical system [5]. In mammals, the circadian clock is comprised of a set of genes, which function as activators—CLOCK and BMAL, which, similarly to HIF, are bHLH-PAS transcription factors [5]. Through binding to regulatory elements containing E-boxes (also present in HIF-1α gene) they activate the transcription of repressor protein period (PER) and cryptochrome (CRY). Additionally, HIF can bind to promoter regions of repressor proteins through hypoxia response elements (HRE), causing their upregulation [5]. Literature concerning circadian clock disruption among patients suffering from OSA is limited. In a study that compared eight healthy individuals and eight patients suffering from OSA, Burioka et al. found disruption of mRNA expression level of PER1 and showed that 3 months CPAP treatment reversed it [6]. Moreira et al. found that only expression of CLOCK mRNA level was altered in 13 OSA patients, compared to eight healthy individuals, and was not affected by 1 month CPAP therapy [7].

To the best of our knowledge, there is no literature regarding the relationship between hypoxia and the circadian clock in OSA patients. The study aimed to investigate differences in concentration of chosen circadian clock proteins in OSA patients and healthy participants and evaluate the association between them and HIF-1 protein subunits as well as selected polysomnography (PSG) parameters.

Characterization of both study groups including demographic and PSG parameters, as well as protein concentrations, are shown in Table 1. No differences in the evening and morning protein concentration were observed in either group (p > 0.05), except for PER1 and CRY1 (both p < 0.001).

In the multivariate general linear model with the concentration of all circadian clock proteins as dependent variables, evening HIF-1α protein level was the only significant covariant (p = 0.025). Corrected models were significant for morning and evening PER1 protein levels (p = 0.008 and p = 0.006, respectively), evening CRY1 protein level (p = 0.043), and evening BMAL protein level (p = 0.046). In corrected models, evening HIF-1α protein level had an influence on the evening PER1 protein level (p = 0.020) (Table 2). Positive correlations between evening PER1, CRY1, CLOCK proteins, and evening HIF-1α protein level were found (R = 0.618, p = 0.004; R = 0.514, p = 0.020 and R = 0.511, and p = 0.021 respectively) (Figure 1).

Intermittent hypoxia is the main contributor of OSA-related pathologies, putting the patients at risk of developing multiple comorbidities, particularly cardiovascular and metabolic disorders [9]. In this preliminary study, we demonstrate that levels of circadian clock proteins in peripheral blood are increased in OSA compared to healthy individuals, which might suggest that they are likely to suffer from dysregulation of the circadian rhythm. This might be possibly mediated by HIF-1.

Several studies have investigated the changes in mRNA expression of circadian clock genes, but not investigated them on protein level. One of the studies observed disruption of the Per1 expression profile, which was reverted and similar to healthy individuals following 3 months of CPAP treatment [6]. However, Moreira et al. found that only expression of CLOCK (but not BMAL, PER, and CRY) was increased in OSA patients and did not decrease following one month of CPAP treatment [7]. Another study showed that BMAL1, CLOCK, and CRY1 were arrhythmic in patients with OSA, with BMAL1 expression being increased in the morning in the OSA group compared to healthy control [10]. Canales et al. investigated a panel of circadian clock genes in veterans with chronic kidney disease, and patients with OSA had decreased only PER3 mRNA expression [11]. In the same study, groups were created based on the presence of nocturnal hypoxemia (NH) defined as ≥10% of total sleep time spent below 90% oxygen saturation, and individuals with NH had decreased expression of PER1 and Rev-erbα [11]. Yet, it is hard to determine if OSA per se is a decisive factor in the downregulated expression of circadian clock genes in this group, as it has been shown that kidney function influences their expression [12]. Compared to the aforementioned results, our study shows an overwhelming increase in circadian clock proteins level, both in the morning and in the evening. This might be caused by possible additional control of the translational process, which might result in an intensification of observed differences on the protein level. Nevertheless, verification of this result in a larger group and a comparison of expression on both protein and mRNA levels in the same individuals is needed.

To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study to evaluate the association between HIF-1 subunits and circadian clock protein levels in OSA patients. This relationship is particularly important, as OSA individuals have increased HIF-1α protein levels [3]. Adamovich et al. found that in cultured cells, physiological oxygen rhythms synchronize clock genes in HIF-1α-dependent manner. Additionally, in the same study it has been shown that modulation of oxygen levels quickens the recovery of wild-type mice from a jet lag protocol, but not that of HIF-1α-deficient mice [13], while Manella et al. have shown a misalignment of circadian clock in mice model of OSA [14]. Furthermore, mice exposed to hypoxia had increased levels of PER1 and CLOCK proteins [15]. The multivariate model generated in the study has shown that the protein level of HIF-1α significantly affected the concentration of circadian clock proteins, while disease severity, desaturation index, and BMI did not. This is in line with the aforementioned results from animal models. Moreover, in models corrected for each of the evaluated circadian proteins, the level of HIF-1α protein remained significant for PER1 in the evening. This might be possibly caused by the fact that this repressor protein has HRE in the promotor of the encoding gene, which allows for HIF binding, resulting in the expression of this protein [5]. Moreover, association with HIF-1α is only present in the evening measurements of the circadian clock repressor protein. This might be due to the accumulation of PER1 protein in the afternoon, which enhances the effect present only in the evening but not in the morning [5]. Similar results would be expected for the other repressor protein, CRY1; however, in the corrected model evening HIF-1α protein level did not reach a significant level, which might be caused by an insufficient number of participants. The small size of the group is the main limitation of the study, therefore the results obtained should be interpreted with caution.

The results of our study suggest that OSA patients are at risk of developing circadian clock disruption. This process might be mediated by the subunit α of HIF-1, as its increased level is associated with the overexpression of circadian clock proteins. Further studies, both in a larger cohort and with prospective observation of treatment effects, are necessary to fully understand this complex relationship.

Results of the study suggest that OSA patients are at risk for developing circadian clock disruption. This process might be mediated by subunit α of HIF-1, as its increased level is associated with overexpression of circadian clock proteins. Nevertheless, further research on larger population are needed to verify this complex relationship.