Psychiatria Danubina···
How Shift Work Relates to Social Life and Quality of Life in Hospital Nurses
Updated
Abstract
Shift work nurses reported significantly higher stress and anxiety levels compared to day work nurses.
- Nurses working in shifts experienced increased stress and reduced coping abilities.
- Higher rates of anxiety, psychoorganic symptoms, and sleep disturbances were observed in shift work nurses.
- Decreased social functioning and reduced family and leisure time were common among shift work hospital nursing staff.
- Nurses reported greater satisfaction with shift work primarily regarding compensation.
Simplified
BACKGROUND: Approximately 20% of the European labour force is involved in some type of shift work, with nurses being on the forefront. In Bosnia and Herzegovina, a specific work scheme is pervasive in the health care arena, where all nurses involved in shift work are committed to eight night shifts per month - unlike other European countries that restrict the number of night shifts. Accordingly, we aimed to investigate whether such shift work significantly affects psychosocial functioning and the quality of life of hospital nursing personnel in this country.
SUBJECTS AND METHODS: A comparative cross-sectional study design was applied on a total of 157 hospital nursing professionals at the University Clinical Hospital Mostar during 2019. Subjects were divided into two groups: a total of 51% study subjects worked in specific shifts (12-hour day shift / 24 hours off / 12-hour night shift / 48 hours off), while 49% subjects worked in accordance with the regular 7-hour daily schedule. Standard Shiftwork Index (SSI) questionnaire was used, alongside comprehensive socio-demographic and quality of life appraisal. Descriptive and inferential statistical methods were applied, and statistical significance was set at p<0.05.
RESULTS: This study demonstrated increased amounts of stress, reduced coping abilities and reduced levels of life enjoyment in shift work nurses in comparison to day work nurses. Furthermore, increased anxiety, stress, psychoorganic symptoms and sleep disturbances were significantly more common in shift work hospital nursing staff. In our study, nurses that worked in shifts have experienced negative externalities such as decreased social functioning, as well as reduced family and leisure time. Conversely, significantly higher satisfaction rates with shift work were only shown in regards to compensation.
CONCLUSIONS: Our results reveal many detrimental effects of shift work and contribute to the field of research that is still laden with gaps in understanding its exact impact on the overall health of nursing personnel. Going forward, prospective (and even interventional) studies will be needed to disentangle the exact interplay between work-related factors in various health care systems and subsequent psychosocial disorders in health personnel.
Related papers
Oct '21
How Shift Work Relates to Health in Hospital Nurses in Bosnia and Herzegovina
top 50% journal
cited by 4 papers
journal article
Dec '18
How work conditions and healthy habits relate to sleep problems in shift-work nurses
cited by 24 papers
journal article
Jan '24
Types of Sleep Quality in Night Shift Nurses and How Work Factors Relate to Their Stress and Anxiety
top 10% journal
cited by 16 papers
journal article
Jul '19
How Night Shift Work Affects Nurses' Quality of Life and Health
top 50% journal
cited by 14 papers
journal article
Mar '13
How Leisure Activities and Work Schedules Relate to Fatigue Recovery in Shift-Working Nurses
cited by 9 papers
english abstract
Sep '18
How Moving Nurses Between Day and Night Shifts in Different Directions Affects Their Sleep and Work-Life Balance
top 20% journal
cited by 65 papers
journal article
Aug '16
Nurses' sleep quality, work conditions, and care quality in Spain during different work shifts
top 20% journal
cited by 92 papers
multicenter study
Apr '16
New types of work schedules found in nurses working in elder care homes
top 50% journal
cited by 6 papers
journal article
May '06
Sleep problems may be linked to digestive issues in nurses working rotating shifts
cited by 56 papers
research support, non-u.s. gov't
Sep '17
Health Effects of Working Night Shifts for Nurses
cited by 65 papers
journal article