Transcriptional noise sets fundamental limits to decoding circadian clock phase from single-cell RNA snapshots

Apr 20, 2026iScience

Random gene activity limits how well single-cell RNA can reveal circadian clock timing

AI simplified

Circadian Biology on OpenScience ↗PubMed ↗DOI ↗

Abstract

Accurate estimation of circadian clock phases may require measuring 50 low-noise, oscillatory genes.

Single-sample phase estimation from bulk RNA is a promising alternative to traditional time-series methods but faces challenges in single-cell applications.
Transcriptional noise in core-clock genes limits reliable phase estimation at the single-cell level.
Averaging counts from only three core-clock genes across 70 cells allows for robust phase estimation.
In desynchronized fibroblasts, local inter-cellular coupling is indicated by spatially heterogeneous phases that emerge only through averaging.
Coarse graining is necessary for accurate circadian phase inference using RNA measurements.

AI simplified

The circadian clock drives rhythmic physiological variations, making accurate clock-phase measurement essential. Single-sample phase inference from bulk RNA is an exciting alternative to time-series methods, but its applicability to single cells remains unclear. Using multiplexed smFISH to quantify up to six core-clock genes in mouse fibroblasts, combined with a Gaussian process-based algorithm, we show that even with minimal technical dropouts, transcriptional noise in core-clock genes prevents reliable single-cell phase estimation. Simulations predict that measuring50 low-noise, clock-like oscillatory genes is required for accurate single-cell inference. In scRNA-seq data, non-core genes were too noisy, and adding hundreds of them did not improve accuracy. Remarkably, averaging smFISH counts from only three core-clock genes across70 cells enabled robust phase estimation. In desynchronized fibroblasts, spatially heterogeneous phases indicating local inter-cellular coupling were revealed only upon averaging, not at single-cell resolution. Coarse graining is, therefore, essential for circadian phase inference from RNA measurements alone. ∼ ∼