Seishin shinkeigaku zasshi = Psychiatria et neurologia Japonica··
Working conditions, sleep, fatigue, and depression in hospital nurses on three rotating shifts
Updated
Abstract
71.2% of hospitals used rapid and counterclockwise shift rotation for nurses.
- After the first night shift, sleep problems were the most severe, with the highest frequency of sleep-inducing drug use at 12.6%.
- Fatigue levels peaked after each of the two night shifts.
- Nurses had a relatively high depression score, averaging 57.8.
- Older nurses experienced greater sleep problems and fatigue.
- Nightowl nurses reported worse sleep issues after day shifts compared to morning people.
- Significant differences in sleep factors and global sleep scores were observed across different rotating shift schedules.
Simplified
These studies were performed to clarify (1) the actual conditions concerning rotating shift schedules of nurses in Japanese university and college hospitals and to evaluate (2) some aspects of the physical and mental health, and (3) sleep profile of hospital nurses working on counter-clockwise shift rotation. Two questionnaire surveys and the OSA sleep inventory (OSA) were carried out. The subjects in the study (1) were a total of 80 nursing directors in university and college hospitals. The questionnaire covered 4 categories, such as the schedule most frequently adopted and reasons for using the schedule. The questionnaires were returned by 67 directors (83.8%). The subjects in the study (2) were 189 nurses working on three-shift work schedules at Asahikawa Medical College Hospital. The items in the questionnaire covered 7 categories, as follows: 1) feeling of sleep after each shift (8 items); 2) feeling of fatigue after each shift (30 items); 3) physical symptoms; 4) inter-personal problems; 5) all the items on Zung's self-rating depression scale (SDS); 6) all the items on the Horne and Ostberg morningness-eveningness questionnaire; and 7) 24 items on the Maudsley personality inventory. The questionnaires were returned by 156 nurses (82.5%), whose mean age and duration of shift-work employment were 27.2 +/- 5.1 and 5.0 +/- 4.3 years (mean +/- SD), respectively. For 152 nurses (97.4%) of those returning the questionnaire, the working schedule consisted of 2 consecutive night shifts and 2 consecutive evening shifts, following a variable number of day shifts (rapid and counterclockwise shift rotation). The subjects in the study (3) were 8 healthy nurses working on above-mentioned three rotating shifts at the psychiatric ward of Asahikawa Medical College Hospital, whose mean age was 29.4 +/- 5.8 years (mean +/- SD). All the subjects recorded their sleep-logs and underwent OSA everyday for 30 consecutive days. Of the 240 OSA data, 95 data (16 after day shift, 17 after the 1st night shift, 16 after the 2nd night shift, 15 after the 1st evening shift, 16 after the 2nd evening shift, 15 after day off) were analyzed. In addition to five of sleep factors in the OSA analysis, we evaluated the global score (GS), which represents subjective global feeling of sleep. In the study (1), 47 of 66 hospitals (71.2%) adopted rapid and counterclockwise shift rotation. The results of study (2) were as follows: 1) After the first night shift (diurnal sleep), the sleep problems were worst, and the frequency of taking sleep-inducing drugs was highest (12.6%); 2) Feelings of fatigue were the highest level after each of the two night shifts; 3) SDS score was relatively high (57.8 +/- 8.1, mean +/- SD); 4) The older the nurse, the greater the aggravation of both sleep problems and fatigue; 5) Sleep problems after day shifts were worse and SDS score was higher in nurses classified as "nightowls" compared to those in nurses classified as "morning people"; and 6) There was no difference between introverts and extroverts in sleep problems, fatigue or SDS score. The results of study (3) were as follows: 1) In 3 of sleep factors (Sleepiness, Integrated sleep, sleep initiation) and GS, there were significant differences among each rotating shift schedule including day off; 2) The highest score in five of sleep factors and the highest GS were noted after the 2nd night shift (nocturnal sleep), and the lowest after the 1st night shift (diurnal sleep); and 3) The younger subjects (n = 4; mean age, 24.5 years) showed a higher GS compared with that of the older subjects (n = 4; mean age, 34.2 years).
Related papers
Jun '06
Sleep quality, health, work conditions, illness, and job satisfaction in female nurses working various shift patterns
top 20% journal
cited by 78 papers
comparative study
May '08
Factors Influencing Work Ability in Nurses Working Day and Shift Schedules
cited by 62 papers
research support, non-u.s. gov't
Dec '06
Napping during work partly makes up for lost sleep in night-shift nurses
top 30% journal
cited by 39 papers
research support, non-u.s. gov't
Jul '12
How reliable and accurate the Bergen Shift Work Sleep Questionnaire is for nurses on three-shift schedules
cited by 28 papers
validation study
Nov '08
How Sleep Loss Affects the Performance of Anesthesia Trainees and Specialists
cited by 70 papers
research support, non-u.s. gov't
Nov '09
Light exposure, sleep length, activity, and melatonin levels in nurses working rotating shifts
cited by 69 papers
research support, non-u.s. gov't
Dec '06
What Affects the Work Ability of Health Care Shift Workers?
top 30% journal
cited by 90 papers
research support, n.i.h., extramural
Oct '06
Work fatigue and recovery linked to age, home duties, and shiftwork
cited by 169 papers
multicenter study
Jan '13
Sleep problems during shifts change with different work schedules
top 10% journal
cited by 84 papers
research support, non-u.s. gov't
Dec '06
Daily urine melatonin levels in healthy Danish nurses during work and free time
top 30% journal
cited by 56 papers
research support, non-u.s. gov't