Psychedelic Science Newsletter
Issue #2September 15, 20257 studies

Ketamine beats ECT for memory, plus new psychedelic insights from 365 patients

Ketamine beats ECT for memory, plus new psychedelic insights from 365 patients

Monday, Monday, September 15th Psychedelic Medicine Newsletter Issue #2

This week brought major clarity on how different depression treatments affect your brain, plus surprising findings about what makes magic mushrooms work and whether psychedelics could help teens.

🧠 Ketamine Protects Memory Better Than ECT in Major Depression Study

Researchers compared ketamine and electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) in 365 patients with treatment-resistant depression over 3 weeks:

  • Ketamine patients performed significantly better on all cognitive tasks than ECT patients (P < 0.001)

  • Both treatments were equally effective at reducing depression, but ketamine caused less memory problems

  • After 6 months, patients who responded to either treatment showed no cognitive differences

Why this matters: This head-to-head comparison gives patients and doctors clearer data about the cognitive trade-offs between two powerful depression treatments, potentially shifting treatment decisions toward ketamine for patients concerned about memory effects.

🎖️ Top 10% journal 🔗 Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 🗓️ Sep 2

Key Findings

🍄 Magic Mushrooms May Need Their Supporting Cast

Scientists are debating whether psilocybin alone is enough, or if other compounds in magic mushrooms make the drugs work better. Some researchers think including secondary compounds from psychedelic mushrooms could create superior medications, while others remain skeptical due to limited data.

💡 The "entourage effect" debate: whole mushrooms vs. pure psilocybin could determine the future of psychedelic medicine.
🥈 Top 2% journal 🔗 ACS Central Science 🗓️ Sep 1

🔬 New Depression Drug Shows Promise Like Ketamine

PA-915, a new type of antidepressant that blocks stress-related brain receptors, showed rapid and long-lasting effects in mouse studies. Like ketamine, a single dose improved depression-like behaviors for 8 weeks in chronic stress models, without causing hyperlocomotion, cognitive problems, or dependency in healthy mice.

💡 Targeting stress pathways directly might offer ketamine-like benefits without the side effects.
🥈 Top 2% journal 🔗 Molecular Psychiatry 🗓️ Sep 3

👥 Teen Psychedelic Research Remains Virtually Nonexistent

A comprehensive review found only 3 trial registrations and 1 trial plan involving participants under 18 from 2000-2025, with none completed or published. The proposed studies would investigate MDMA or psilocybin for teens with PTSD, autism with social anxiety, or self-harm behaviors.

💡 Major evidence gap: millions of teens suffer from mental illness, but we have zero published data on psychedelic treatments for this age group.

🎯 Psilocybin Shows Dopamine Effects That Could Help Addiction

A review of 34 clinical trials found psychedelics are being tested for alcohol, cannabis, cocaine, and other substance use disorders. Brain studies in rats showed high-dose psilocybin caused sustained, mild increases in dopamine in addiction-related brain areas - potentially helping restore normal dopamine balance.

💡 Psychedelics might treat addiction by fixing the brain's reward system, not just changing consciousness.
🥉 Top 5% journal 🔗 British Journal of Pharmacology 🗓️ Sep 1

💊 Self-Compassion Key to Psychedelic Therapy Success

Research examining positive emotional experiences during psychedelic therapy found that self-compassion plays a central role in treatment benefits. The study suggests that mystical experiences and elevated mood during sessions contribute to lasting mental health improvements.

💡 How you treat yourself emotionally during a psychedelic experience may determine how much you benefit long-term.
🔗 Research square 🗓️ Sep 1

🧬 Multiple Sclerosis Progression Can Reverse in One-Third of Patients

Among 4,713 multiple sclerosis patients experiencing disability progression, about one-third saw improvement over a median of 2.6 years. Younger age, lower baseline disability, and high-efficacy treatments were associated with reversal of progression.

💡 MS progression isn't always permanent - younger patients on stronger treatments have the best chance of improvement.
🎖️ Top 10% journal 🔗 Brain Communications 🗓️ Sep 4

Implications

This week's research highlights a shift toward more personalized approaches in neuropsychiatry, from choosing ketamine over ECT based on cognitive priorities, to understanding that psychedelic benefits may depend on the full spectrum of compounds and emotional states during treatment.

Studies in this issue

Primary sources used for this newsletter.

  1. Psychedelic drugs as treatments for substance use disorders: Clinical trials and brain mechanisms
    key findingBritish journal of pharmacology2025-09-02PMID 40891276
  2. Ongoing worsening in multiple sclerosis that happens without relapses
    key findingBrain communications2025-09-05PMID 40909095
  3. Do Magic Mushrooms Have Active Components Beyond Psilocybin?
    key findingACS central science2025-09-02PMID 40893965
  4. Clinical Research on Psychedelic Drugs in Teenagers and Related Ethical Issues
    key findingThe Lancet. Child &amp; adolescent health2025-09-04PMID 40908054